NFL output doesn't matter in recruiting, P5 status does.

Report problem with this ad

Feb 12, 2016
7:56:09am

ChinoCoug All-American

Report problem with this ad

ChinoCoug

New username: BeefNoodleSoup
Bio page: ChinoCoug
Joined: Feb 23, 2004
Last login: Aug 21, 2017
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

State of Utah NFL Combine invites

Future_Tacos

2/12/16 7:39am

Ouch

SouthernBlueBlood

2/12/16 7:43am

We don't even look G5 in this

SouthernBlueBlood

2/12/16 7:43am

Should it be considered when looking at these kinds of things to review

BYUFam1

2/12/16 7:44am

Yeah in fairness I'd be curious how many seniors each team had.

titlecoug

2/12/16 7:56am

It won't offer a full answer just to have the numbers because "contribution" is

BYUFam1

2/12/16 8:42am

another thing to consider this isn't really an anomaly for BYU in the Bronco era

2/12/16 11:32am

A testament to Bronco's recruiting prowess

Singcat

2/12/16 7:44am

I believe it's a reflection of a young team + RMs. How many of these invitees

byusage

2/12/16 7:49am

RM's from colleges of Utah invited to the combine: Utah 1, SUU 1, BYU 1, USU 0.

TripleCrownCoug

2/12/16 8:48am

And we still won games....I'm not even made. I'm impressed with Bronco

jrifkin48

2/12/16 7:50am

I'm glad he focused on the bigger picture but he should have more guys worth a look.

SouthernBlueBlood

2/12/16 7:51am

Isn't that kind of like being proud of a toddler who craps himself, but cleans

srey

2/12/16 7:52am

No, it means bronco was a great coach, terrible recruiter.

idacoug

2/12/16 7:54am

So the analogy does work.

srey

2/12/16 7:55am

Doesn't mean he's a terrible recruiter. Guys can be all-star in college but not

viper

2/12/16 7:59am

I agree with both Singcat and jrifkin48. It's an indictment of Bronco's

ldssdl

2/12/16 7:56am

NFL output doesn't matter in recruiting, P5 status does.

ChinoCoug

2/12/16 7:56am

SUU seems to be doing okay

SouthernBlueBlood

2/12/16 7:59am

It does matter in recruiting when you have HS kids with NFL aspirations and you're actively & repeatedly bagging on the

foofcoug

2/12/16 8:03am

Where did I come from, why am I here, where am I going?

Bonoman

2/12/16 10:49am

They both matter and only one (to a certain measure) is in BYU's control right

Wedgetail

2/12/16 8:16am

Empirics say otherwise.

ChinoCoug

2/12/16 8:33am

I wouldnt care so much about NFL output if it didnt seem to have an effect on recruiting, and also if we at least won

IceCreamButt

2/12/16 8:01am

embarrassing

Bravescoug

2/12/16 8:02am

God bless "will over skill"...but how about a decent measure of BOTH?!

Wedgetail

2/12/16 8:08am

Player development

Huge Manatee

2/12/16 8:08am

Bright side: We have SUU's coaches now, suckers!

ChinoCoug

2/12/16 8:10am

Just look at it as bottoming out, this will change with Sitake

HuskerCoug

2/12/16 8:10am

how does Mathews and Blackmon get overlooked for players at SUU?

Pretorian

2/12/16 8:37am

It's that P5 status that SUU has.

Wedgetail

2/12/16 8:39am

RE: It's that P5 status that SUU has.

ChinoCoug

2/12/16 8:55am

I bet they never talk about how good they are at putting kids into The League,

Wedgetail

2/12/16 8:58am

Reading is FUN-damental.

ChinoCoug

2/12/16 9:23am

You obviously don;t know football

Canusa

2/12/16 8:53am

John Beck and Max Hall, it wasn't that long ago

HuskerCoug

2/12/16 10:00am

BYU had 2 QB's in the NFL as recently as 2011

Backcountry

2/12/16 11:55am

Did you really just say BYU was better than Utah in the bowl game?

Backcountry

2/12/16 11:53am

wow... no I did not... I wrote it... If you missed it just read it again...

Pretorian

2/12/16 1:22pm

Bless your little heart

Backcountry

2/12/16 1:28pm

says a person that doesn't understand a statement or can't back up their side

Pretorian

2/12/16 1:33pm

Tell me, how is a winner determined in football?

Backcountry

2/12/16 1:35pm

About what I expected

wilsdad

2/12/16 8:48am

I honestly don't care. I care about 9-4. More than 1 guy will get an NFL chance.

cougar1981

2/12/16 10:00am

Independence

trumpetur

2/12/16 10:32am

Has nothing to do with it. This is 10% on the "RM factor", 90% on the old coach

Posting on CougarBoard