Beo - He was a solid offer. He had offers from boise and washington, so it's not like rose was wasting his time on someone that no one else thought could be pretty good.
Freshman: you're right, he wouldn't start at weber over their seniors/juniors.
Guinn - One of the best defenders on the team.
Probably wouldn't start most places as he is a defensive player. He's great off the bench.
Leifson - Took chatmans schollie. Was a walk-on. I'd be fine with giving this one up.
Freshman: Definitely wouldn't start anywhere.
Shaw - a 3 star recruit, worthy of a schollie.
Freshman: He could start a couple places but it's tough to start as a center as a freshman. I think Shaw will be great.
Aytes - Definitely deserves a schollie. What is your problem with aytes? He's playing well (but not enough minutes) this year.
He would probably start a ton of places unless his health is what's keeping him from playing very many minutes. He's shooting 56% this year and has looked pretty good when I've seen him.

So there is one scholarship that is probably going to be yanked this year. You'll find that just about anywhere.