so? the other guys didn't start their soph and jr years either, like Young.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 25, 2017
2:18:58pm

Kerbouchard All-American

so? the other guys didn't start their soph and jr years either, like Young.

Walsh's stellar season was his junior season.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:18:58pm

Message modified by Kerbouchard on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:20:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Kerbouchard

Bio page: Kerbouchard
Joined: Feb 17, 2011
Last login: Aug 24, 2023
Total posts: 24,538 (19 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

John Walsh doesn't get much respect but he's 1 of 4 QB's to lead BYU to top 10

rcbyufan

4/24/17 9:48pm

I was there in Logan when he passed for over 600 yards...but lost.

realtall

4/24/17 9:50pm

For some reason, fans never warmed up to him.

eddog

4/24/17 9:52pm

I think it was the loss to Utah. It was just hard to fathom a great BYU team

rcbyufan

4/24/17 9:58pm

Utes finished top 10 right? Highest ranking by both teams in season i think

NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN

4/25/17 6:28pm

Many fans wanted Clements or even Young.

Belboz

4/24/17 10:17pm

Many fans were idiots.

Kerbouchard

4/24/17 10:42pm

So stupid. What did his religion have to do with anything?

Kerbouchard

4/24/17 10:43pm

Nothing

4/25/17 5:59am

Non-LDS and likes to party? Nah, we'd never embrace a QB like that.....

byukirty

4/25/17 4:18pm

He's one of my all time favorites

BigYfan

4/24/17 9:57pm

We had 4 pretty good non LDS QBs in a row in the 90s. I wonder what it is about our

The Dude Abides

4/24/17 9:58pm

Turning a blind eye to the honor code?

immgw

4/24/17 10:33pm

Total opinion on this so plz dont criticize my opinion like im stating facts

NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN

4/24/17 11:44pm

34-31 x 2 hurt the legacy a little

Crush4

4/24/17 9:58pm

And losing to Utah state didn't help either.

Belboz

4/24/17 10:19pm

Steve Young, and Jim McMahon and/or Marc Wilson lost to USU

Y05

4/25/17 4:07pm

without scoring 56 points.

Belboz

4/25/17 4:09pm

and without setting school and NCAA passing records.

Y05

4/25/17 4:17pm

Why did I stop there, Gary Sheide did as well.

Y05

4/25/17 4:16pm

One of the worst defenses ever hurt his legacy more.

Kerbouchard

4/24/17 10:40pm

This.

Marvelous

4/25/17 6:52am

I saved up money and bought my first season tickets When he was

GeauxCougs

4/24/17 10:00pm

Your 13-year-old behavior earned you lifetime Celestial status as a

eyes4byu

4/25/17 12:33pm

Walsh would have finished with like 12,000 yards and 100 TD passes if he had

Game Changer

4/25/17 12:11am

Furthermore, he had 3 of the best games ever played by a BYU QB, period. His

Game Changer

4/25/17 12:15am

Walsh hate was just plain stupidity

byukarl

4/25/17 7:23am

Never had to doubt whether the ball would get there... just whether the receiver

(Private)

4/25/17 8:37am

Walsh did not come back for a stellar senior season as all the other...

immgw

4/25/17 10:58am

technically speaking, if he came back for his SR season we wouldn't be talking about Sark at all since he only came to

SingleStrapBackpack

4/25/17 12:04pm

so? the other guys didn't start their soph and jr years either, like Young.

Kerbouchard

4/25/17 2:18pm

I'm not sure what you are talking about. Several of the QBs I listed started

immgw

4/25/17 2:37pm

Since Walsh, Beck and Hall are the only other QBs to have 2 seasons with

Y05

4/25/17 3:59pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad