Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up
Sep 22, 2017
8:32:22am
Everyman All-American
Agree. The football team simply does not have the depth to compete, consistently
with winning P5 teams.

Of Bronco's 7 wins against P5s that finished with a winning season, only 2 occurred since independence. The current regime was 0-2 against such teams, last year and will likely finish 0-4, this year.

Using UU and TCU as benchmark, the 2017 signing class illustrates the disparity. I'm using 247 Sports composite rankings,


BYU - 23 signees
4* - 2
3* - 12
2* or lower - 9

UU - 23 signees
4* - 3
3* - 20
2* or lower - None

TCU - 23 signees
4* - 4
3* - 16
2* or lower - 3

2016, which was a good year for BYU, ranking-wise, was not much different

BYU - 24 signees
4* - 2
3* - 17
2* or lower - 5

UU - 30
4* - 3
3* - 23
2* or lower - 4

TCU - 23 signees
4* - 9
3* - 14
28 or lower - None

In 2015, BYU had seven 2* or lower recruits, UU and TCU had none.

The talent gap between BYU and the higher-ranked programs is even more pronounced. And will continue to widen as the power conferences continue to dominate CFB and separate from the rest.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Sep 22, 2017 at 8:32:22am
Message modified by Everyman on Sep 22, 2017 at 8:32:58am
Everyman
Previous username
Everymancoug
Bio page
Everyman
Joined
May 27, 2012
Last login
Apr 29, 2024
Total posts
19,923 (105 FO)