Not in with the top 5 greats. But you said "embarrassing."

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 20, 2017
12:46:46pm

TheWanderer Contributor

Not in with the top 5 greats. But you said "embarrassing."

The guy is on a 53 in the NFL. I'm not embarrassed by that. Let's not move the goal posts.

Report problem with this ad

TheWanderer

Bio page: TheWanderer
Joined: Mar 18, 2016
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 11,088 (1,420 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The coaches (new or returning) had not better pick a starting QB until August

Indy Coug Misunderstood

11/20/17 12:39pm

Let’s see how the Hawaii game goes.

Mr. Scoobs

11/20/17 12:41pm

The existing QB talent is embarrassing. TBH, it's been embarrassing for a long

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:41pm

Well, outside of Taysom Hill.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:44pm

Where's he fit on the list of BYU QB Greats?

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:45pm

Not in with the top 5 greats. But you said "embarrassing."

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:46pm

Taysom was not a great QB at BYU, full stop. He had great games here and there

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:48pm

Yes he was. His win % vs P5 teams kills the rest. And he played way more games as well.

11/20/17 12:50pm

He caught some P5 teams at their lowest points. I'm not willing

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:52pm

No one's saying he is elite. You're moving the goalpost. You said "embarrassing"

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:54pm

Sort of sounds like you're moving the goal posts. Backpedal.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:53pm

Having one guy with the talent to sort of enter the conversation, in EIGHT YEARS

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:54pm

So now you'll backpedal and admit that TH was not an embarrassment?

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:56pm

Taysom was not an embarrassment, and I never intended to say he was. But

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:57pm

This I can agree with on a holistic view.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 1:02pm

He'd be at the top if he had one more healthy season. 2014 was set to be

gmj81

11/20/17 12:47pm

If if if.

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:48pm

As recently as the end of 2015, even our existing QB talent

jbcoug

11/20/17 12:45pm

Nonsense

Bob Vance

11/20/17 12:46pm

Okay, name one QB since Max Hall that is even in the conversation

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:49pm

Taysom Hill. Been trying to tell you this for 3+ years, and you still ignore it. QB eval is not your strength. Sorr

11/20/17 12:51pm

Okay, so in eight years, BYU has had one guy that can sniff that conversation.

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:53pm

You set the 8 year window, And that guy is on an NFL roster. But keep persisting.

11/20/17 12:58pm

You can blindly trust NFL execs all you want.

SandYFan

11/20/17 1:04pm

Listen Turnpike. SandYFan made Tom GOAT Brady who he is today. Listen to him.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 1:18pm

I disagree.

Brigham

11/20/17 1:25pm

Here's the problem: This year more than ever, we need an off-season commander

runnincoug

11/20/17 12:54pm

I honestly think that the QB battle should be between Wilstead and Jaren Hall

MAcc15Coug

11/20/17 2:55pm

And here's exhibit 1,000,000,000+1 that CB poster know nothing

jomo

11/20/17 4:04pm

Uh. Why and when would they? Of course they wouldn't.

11/20/17 1:26pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad