Uh. Why and when would they? Of course they wouldn't.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 20, 2017
1:26:15pm

Lip Gallagher All-American

Uh. Why and when would they? Of course they wouldn't.

Just saying, kind of a captain obvious post. That's the only time of the year when positions are won and decided on.

Report problem with this ad

Lip Gallagher

Previous username: Rusty'sJuicyCknHole
New username: Chef Carl Casper
Bio page: Lip Gallagher
Joined: Apr 26, 2013
Last login: Apr 30, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The coaches (new or returning) had not better pick a starting QB until August

Indy Coug Misunderstood

11/20/17 12:39pm

Let’s see how the Hawaii game goes.

Mr. Scoobs

11/20/17 12:41pm

The existing QB talent is embarrassing. TBH, it's been embarrassing for a long

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:41pm

Well, outside of Taysom Hill.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:44pm

Where's he fit on the list of BYU QB Greats?

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:45pm

Not in with the top 5 greats. But you said "embarrassing."

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:46pm

Taysom was not a great QB at BYU, full stop. He had great games here and there

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:48pm

Yes he was. His win % vs P5 teams kills the rest. And he played way more games as well.

11/20/17 12:50pm

He caught some P5 teams at their lowest points. I'm not willing

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:52pm

No one's saying he is elite. You're moving the goalpost. You said "embarrassing"

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:54pm

Sort of sounds like you're moving the goal posts. Backpedal.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:53pm

Having one guy with the talent to sort of enter the conversation, in EIGHT YEARS

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:54pm

So now you'll backpedal and admit that TH was not an embarrassment?

TheWanderer

11/20/17 12:56pm

Taysom was not an embarrassment, and I never intended to say he was. But

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:57pm

This I can agree with on a holistic view.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 1:02pm

He'd be at the top if he had one more healthy season. 2014 was set to be

gmj81

11/20/17 12:47pm

If if if.

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:48pm

As recently as the end of 2015, even our existing QB talent

jbcoug

11/20/17 12:45pm

Nonsense

Bob Vance

11/20/17 12:46pm

Okay, name one QB since Max Hall that is even in the conversation

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:49pm

Taysom Hill. Been trying to tell you this for 3+ years, and you still ignore it. QB eval is not your strength. Sorr

11/20/17 12:51pm

Okay, so in eight years, BYU has had one guy that can sniff that conversation.

SandYFan

11/20/17 12:53pm

You set the 8 year window, And that guy is on an NFL roster. But keep persisting.

11/20/17 12:58pm

You can blindly trust NFL execs all you want.

SandYFan

11/20/17 1:04pm

Listen Turnpike. SandYFan made Tom GOAT Brady who he is today. Listen to him.

TheWanderer

11/20/17 1:18pm

I disagree.

Brigham

11/20/17 1:25pm

Here's the problem: This year more than ever, we need an off-season commander

runnincoug

11/20/17 12:54pm

I honestly think that the QB battle should be between Wilstead and Jaren Hall

MAcc15Coug

11/20/17 2:55pm

And here's exhibit 1,000,000,000+1 that CB poster know nothing

jomo

11/20/17 4:04pm

Uh. Why and when would they? Of course they wouldn't.

11/20/17 1:26pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad