RE: Critchlow is NOT 4th String or else Detmer Jr. would be starting. In 2012

Report problem with this ad

Nov 21, 2017
3:20:59pm

ManicBlue All-American

http://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=18892451

Report problem with this ad

ManicBlue

Bio page: ManicBlue
Joined: Jan 10, 2005
Last login: May 19, 2024
Total posts: 48,663 (914 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

One thing that blows my mind is that fans don't seem to take into

BYURider

11/21/17 1:38pm

Our offense was awful when we had our starting QB, all of our WR's and our

BoiseBlue

11/21/17 1:47pm

I agree, im just saying injuries will be the spin for why no one is fired

BYURider

11/21/17 1:49pm

But it was practiced in the spring and fall with a lot of 2 and

basman

11/21/17 1:59pm

And they still haven't figured it out by week 13...

NorCal_Coug

11/21/17 2:03pm

he didn't do it with a 4th string QB

BYURider

11/21/17 2:08pm

The O was awful with 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th string.

NorCal_Coug

11/21/17 3:06pm

Doman beat NMSU 50-12 with 3rd string in 2012. Critchlow is 3rd string, not 4th

Mr. Scoobs

11/21/17 3:06pm

Wow .. didn't realize Lark was a freshman walk-on right off his mission in 2012

ManicBlue

11/21/17 3:18pm

We put up 20 pts with all our starters to winless Port. St, couldn't pass the 50

Mr. Scoobs

11/21/17 3:30pm

It's not just injuries but inexperience too. Our starters simply did not have

ManicBlue

11/21/17 3:40pm

This isn't the only year BYU had inexperience on the offensive side of the ball.

NorCal_Coug

11/21/17 3:48pm

Name one that has been this extensive coupled with the injuries. I'm not trying

ManicBlue

11/21/17 3:52pm

We are talking about losing to FCS level teams here. It shouldn't matter.

Mr. Scoobs

11/21/17 4:35pm

I give up... folks put their heads in the sand on this factual point.

NorCal_Coug

11/21/17 7:23pm

We lost to an FCS team? I must have missed that.

ManicBlue

11/22/17 9:29am

Never thought I'd see the day CBers would defend losses to bottom 10 teams.

Mr. Scoobs

11/22/17 9:40am

As a 40 yr season ticket holder, I've seen ups and downs before and have learned

ManicBlue

11/22/17 10:12am

injuries, inexperience - got any more excuses? we've won b4 w/ those challenges

mindzeYe

11/21/17 7:25pm

But this is ECU, UMass, and USU we're talking about!!!!

NorCal_Coug

11/21/17 10:13pm

UMass ... the team that lost to Tennessee 17-14? That UMass?

ManicBlue

11/22/17 9:31am

Take off the blue goggles. You can't put lipstick on this pig.

NorCal_Coug

11/22/17 2:40pm

RE: Take off the blue goggles. You can't put lipstick on this pig.

ManicBlue

11/22/17 3:32pm

Yea, about every 50 years.

kooogar

11/22/17 11:27pm

Stewart

lawking

11/21/17 5:04pm

^^^This^^^ Portland State was alarming

Toubabou

11/21/17 3:23pm

Good points, but it's still all Kalani's and Ty's fault. Only if they were more

socorny

11/21/17 1:48pm

We just need to tighten up all those loose things!

ManicBlue

11/21/17 1:54pm

Was it Critchlow that decided to go away from the run?

IceBlueCoug

11/21/17 1:58pm

Yeah, you'd think with a good wrench we wouldn't have so many players "loose"

Greg Kite's 'stache

11/21/17 1:59pm

go back and watch the game. Critchlow's passing was way off in the first half.

BYURider

11/21/17 2:10pm

I agree although the protection wasn't great either

I'mBatman

11/21/17 2:15pm

Detmer's play calling in the first half was actually pretty good

Greg Kite's 'stache

11/21/17 2:24pm

I don't know. They were rushing so many I don't know if rushing was the answer.

SWP

11/21/17 4:33pm

It seems that we've had a ton of injuries since Kalani took over

BYU Fan

11/21/17 1:58pm

No other teams have injuries. Its pretty unfair.

Blueto

11/21/17 2:01pm

Some teams have a lot less, and it makes a huge difference.

basman

11/21/17 2:03pm

I think it ties back to the belief the previous coaches wouldn’t go 3-10

SlantRoute

11/21/17 2:05pm

I agree with most of what you all are saying, but I'm just saying that I think

BYURider

11/21/17 2:13pm

Mangum takes bowling not sure how much I believe that... UNLV was anomaly I get

coug almighty

11/21/17 2:26pm

Critchlow is NOT 4th String or else Detmer Jr. would be starting. In 2012

Mr. Scoobs

11/21/17 2:48pm

He was our 4th string QB until half way through the season, Jr. ended up awful

GigantorCat

11/21/17 3:01pm

RE: Critchlow is NOT 4th String or else Detmer Jr. would be starting. In 2012

ManicBlue

11/21/17 3:20pm

the wretched problems of the O were in full display vs PSU before any injuries

mindzeYe

11/21/17 3:07pm

The strength and conditioning coach should be under severe scrutiny

Jeenious

11/21/17 3:39pm

This will absolutely be the spin. But it’s a false narrative.

Gerald-DeGroot

11/21/17 4:43pm

The annual injury excuse. I am tired of it

Dr T-bone

11/21/17 4:52pm

the point of my post is that the staff will be retained and

BYURider

11/21/17 4:57pm

Don’t forget about inexperience and tough schedule. Those are strong.

Gerald-DeGroot

11/21/17 5:05pm

Partly true

TroutcreekCoug

11/21/17 5:03pm

Kalani said the Portland state corners were good but that team ranks

kooogar

11/21/17 7:39pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad