I was not conflating NDT's statement to more than he said, I previously pointed out why the conclusion provided by his example is an oversimplification that does not consider all possibilities.

You are.  You're trying to categorize it as a general attempt to disprove the existence of any god, but it's not.  All-powerful, all-knowing, and all-benevolent are specific traits.

You and NDT are largely talking past each other because mormon thelogy does not define god as all-powerful.