This has nothing to do with judging. When's the last time you saw an article from a team's fanbase that features getting wasted? I've never seen it. This has more to do with the non-LDS faction of your fanbase wanting to distance themselves from what BYU is (mormon).
Most of us here have no problem with others who drink. You really really want to think so, but it's simply not true. This is ridiculous, because its ridiculous, plain and simple.