I stand corrected on stats, hadn't looked them up, steady improvement in passe

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2017
7:47:34pm

akmewg All-American

I stand corrected on stats, hadn't looked them up, steady improvement in passe

r rating and YPC, and big differences in completion % between Sophomore and J/S years. Int's didn't improve, and I guess the bad losses his last two years, utah/FSU/TCU stick in my mind most because he really played poorly in those games. But you're right he did improve over his 3 years. Does further My QB coach argument, we've had significantly better QB play when we've had a dedicated QB coach.

Report problem with this ad

akmewg

Bio page: akmewg
Joined: Aug 11, 2011
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 7,113 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Been thinking of Tanner Mangum. What happens to him now?

Santos L. Halper All-American

11/12/17 1:19pm

Probably surgery to repair his achilles, then a lot of rehab

Mike Honcho

11/12/17 1:20pm

peaked very early

BlueFrog

11/12/17 1:21pm

Before he was even in good condition.

Brisco

11/12/17 1:23pm

You think his best days are behind him? If he played great in 2015 shouldn't he be able to it next year too?

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 1:25pm

7 years ago he was an Elite 11 co mvp.

BlueFrog

11/12/17 1:32pm

and then retrogressed. Kinda sad

Soy Celeste

11/12/17 6:57pm

We all would. But he was given an infinite leash this year...

11/12/17 1:22pm

Agreed. Mangum had every chance in the world, and all the time to do it.

JerryAtric

11/12/17 8:50pm

I'd love to see Critchlow solidify his.hold on the job

11/12/17 1:22pm

The pass over the middle to Simon was when I knew

BigYfan

11/12/17 1:46pm

If this happens, i hope it becomes apparent asap. I'd like Tanner to transfer

Turbine

11/12/17 1:57pm

Who wants him? He's got 1 year of rehab and a bad resume.

11/12/17 7:09pm

If Kansas wanted Heaps, Tanner will find a spot. FBS needing veteran QB or FCS.

Turbine

11/12/17 7:11pm

I'm wondering if his BYU career is over.

mudpupper

11/12/17 1:23pm

Sue you here I come.

Bullrider

11/12/17 4:02pm

If I were him I would redshirt + transfer.

11/12/17 1:23pm

Transfer where? I feel bad for the guy.

demon_llama

11/12/17 1:26pm

Somewhere that needs a grad transfer QB for a year.

11/12/17 1:38pm

Virginia maybe? He knows the system.

pinolero

11/12/17 1:51pm

Actually, he doesn't

mudpupper

11/12/17 2:49pm

What system did he use? Anae was pretty set in his ways, he probably changed it

pinolero

11/12/17 3:45pm

Should be a good competition in camp for the starting job. Regardless of what

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:24pm

why?

11/12/17 1:25pm

Because you want the best guy to have the job.

cougaman

11/12/17 1:26pm

Because if he does really well, that's great but he won't have been tested

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:29pm

And Wilstead and Hall. Just leave it open to everyone. Hall won't have Spring

cougaman

11/12/17 1:25pm

Edit: dang my wifi sucks maybe I should just pay attention to EQ

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:25pm

He will either start next season

shakarocks

11/12/17 1:32pm

Hw should get his byu degree and be glad it was free.

11/12/17 1:50pm

You don't think he'll RS and stay?

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 1:58pm

He might but BYU will for sure move on from him if he does

shakarocks

11/12/17 2:06pm

He should be able to grad transfer (if it comes to that) with his Gray shirt

akmewg

11/12/17 7:54pm

I wish him only success. Would you rather he sucked?

11/12/17 8:31pm

I just mean I would feel crappy about having wasted his potential if that were

akmewg

11/12/17 8:36pm

IMO he’s likely taken his last meaningful snap at BYU

RockyBalboa

11/12/17 1:35pm

All comes to an end at some point.. I think he comes back to byu

cougfanz

11/12/17 1:38pm

Me too, get healthy and I beat he starts next year.

11/12/17 2:10pm

From here on out it's Critchlow's job to lose...sad for Mangum but true.

Refugee

11/12/17 2:33pm

Nah

shakarocks

11/12/17 2:41pm

I know what I'm looking for in a good QB. Been watching a lot of other teams this year

Refugee

11/12/17 4:09pm

Go read my post a few lines above yours

shakarocks

11/12/17 4:21pm

How would your post change what I saw? I'm not talking just about results, I'm talking about body language, reads,

Refugee

11/12/17 4:30pm

<< Deleted >>

East1999

11/12/17 7:08pm

It really wasn’t

shakarocks

11/12/17 9:26pm

How long is the typical rehab time for a achilles injury? Game action ready?

coastcat

11/12/17 2:53pm

If true that his injury is a torn achilles then he will likely be out at least 6

mm73

11/12/17 3:03pm

He has no chance of spring camp. Slight chance of playing fall camp

cougaman

11/12/17 3:13pm

9 months at least.

11/12/17 7:10pm

RE: How long is the typical rehab time for a achilles injury? Game action ready?

MTB_TDI

11/12/17 10:54pm

Good explanation. I like that it is based on your experience and not what

coastcat

11/13/17 2:29pm

It's too early to say Critchlow will be the starter from here out, but he looked

Skysthelimit

11/12/17 3:18pm

Gotta' remember Critchlow was going up against a weak team. I think he

rockyrd

11/12/17 5:17pm

Hopefully Detmer keeps the new spread concepts he has been implementing

Jericho

11/12/17 5:25pm

You should say that a few more times and try a little harder to be persuasive.

travelcoug

11/13/17 12:56am

The weird thing is the last QBto really develop (as in improve year to year) was

akmewg

11/12/17 5:58pm

Max's sophomore year was by far his worst.

molodyets

11/12/17 7:10pm

I stand corrected on stats, hadn't looked them up, steady improvement in passe

akmewg

11/12/17 7:47pm

Simply not true. Max improved every year

Jericho

11/12/17 8:10pm

He needs to transfer down to a lower level of football, with less pressure from

Game Changer

11/12/17 6:03pm

Not a single person blaming Detmer. Incredible.

11/12/17 7:20pm

I put 90% of the blame on Detmer. Definitely alluded to it in my post too...

Jericho

11/12/17 8:11pm

I wonder how much, if at all, Detmer is to blame. That's why I ask if Tanner's drop in performance has to

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 9:05pm

Does Tanner Put up 28 points against UNLV?

11/12/17 10:27pm

Yes

shakarocks

11/13/17 10:40am

Too bad for him or too bad for the team? TM is a great guy, but he seems to have

11/13/17 11:11am

You're really not looking very deeply

shakarocks

11/13/17 12:01pm

He becomes our very valuable experienced backup QB who doesn’t need a lot of...

icecougar

11/12/17 10:53pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad