Max's sophomore year was by far his worst.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2017
7:10:59pm

molodyets All-American

Report problem with this ad

molodyets

Previous username: patches1391
Bio page: molodyets
Joined: Mar 26, 2006
Last login: May 26, 2024
Total posts: 43,429 (19,385 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Been thinking of Tanner Mangum. What happens to him now?

Santos L. Halper All-American

11/12/17 1:19pm

Probably surgery to repair his achilles, then a lot of rehab

Mike Honcho

11/12/17 1:20pm

peaked very early

BlueFrog

11/12/17 1:21pm

Before he was even in good condition.

Brisco

11/12/17 1:23pm

You think his best days are behind him? If he played great in 2015 shouldn't he be able to it next year too?

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 1:25pm

7 years ago he was an Elite 11 co mvp.

BlueFrog

11/12/17 1:32pm

and then retrogressed. Kinda sad

Soy Celeste

11/12/17 6:57pm

We all would. But he was given an infinite leash this year...

coug almighty

11/12/17 1:22pm

Agreed. Mangum had every chance in the world, and all the time to do it.

JerryAtric

11/12/17 8:50pm

I'd love to see Critchlow solidify his.hold on the job

Cougarealist

11/12/17 1:22pm

The pass over the middle to Simon was when I knew

BigYfan

11/12/17 1:46pm

If this happens, i hope it becomes apparent asap. I'd like Tanner to transfer

Turbine

11/12/17 1:57pm

Who wants him? He's got 1 year of rehab and a bad resume.

johnnycarson

11/12/17 7:09pm

If Kansas wanted Heaps, Tanner will find a spot. FBS needing veteran QB or FCS.

Turbine

11/12/17 7:11pm

I'm wondering if his BYU career is over.

mudpupper

11/12/17 1:23pm

Sue you here I come.

Bullrider

11/12/17 4:02pm

If I were him I would redshirt + transfer.

Junior Deputy

11/12/17 1:23pm

Transfer where? I feel bad for the guy.

demon_llama

11/12/17 1:26pm

Somewhere that needs a grad transfer QB for a year.

Junior Deputy

11/12/17 1:38pm

Virginia maybe? He knows the system.

pinolero

11/12/17 1:51pm

Actually, he doesn't

mudpupper

11/12/17 2:49pm

What system did he use? Anae was pretty set in his ways, he probably changed it

pinolero

11/12/17 3:45pm

Should be a good competition in camp for the starting job. Regardless of what

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:24pm

why?

Cougarealist

11/12/17 1:25pm

Because you want the best guy to have the job.

cougaman

11/12/17 1:26pm

Because if he does really well, that's great but he won't have been tested

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:29pm

And Wilstead and Hall. Just leave it open to everyone. Hall won't have Spring

cougaman

11/12/17 1:25pm

Edit: dang my wifi sucks maybe I should just pay attention to EQ

Martin Van Nostrand

11/12/17 1:25pm

He will either start next season

shakarocks

11/12/17 1:32pm

Hw should get his byu degree and be glad it was free.

johnnycarson

11/12/17 1:50pm

You don't think he'll RS and stay?

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 1:58pm

He might but BYU will for sure move on from him if he does

shakarocks

11/12/17 2:06pm

He should be able to grad transfer (if it comes to that) with his Gray shirt

akmewg

11/12/17 7:54pm

I wish him only success. Would you rather he sucked?

coug almighty

11/12/17 8:31pm

I just mean I would feel crappy about having wasted his potential if that were

akmewg

11/12/17 8:36pm

IMO he’s likely taken his last meaningful snap at BYU

RockyBalboa

11/12/17 1:35pm

All comes to an end at some point.. I think he comes back to byu

cougfanz

11/12/17 1:38pm

Me too, get healthy and I beat he starts next year.

Beetdiggercoug

11/12/17 2:10pm

From here on out it's Critchlow's job to lose...sad for Mangum but true.

Refugee

11/12/17 2:33pm

Nah

shakarocks

11/12/17 2:41pm

I know what I'm looking for in a good QB. Been watching a lot of other teams this year

Refugee

11/12/17 4:09pm

Go read my post a few lines above yours

shakarocks

11/12/17 4:21pm

How would your post change what I saw? I'm not talking just about results, I'm talking about body language, reads,

Refugee

11/12/17 4:30pm

<< Deleted >>

East1999

11/12/17 7:08pm

It really wasn’t

shakarocks

11/12/17 9:26pm

How long is the typical rehab time for a achilles injury? Game action ready?

coastcat

11/12/17 2:53pm

If true that his injury is a torn achilles then he will likely be out at least 6

mm73

11/12/17 3:03pm

He has no chance of spring camp. Slight chance of playing fall camp

cougaman

11/12/17 3:13pm

9 months at least.

johnnycarson

11/12/17 7:10pm

RE: How long is the typical rehab time for a achilles injury? Game action ready?

MTB_TDI

11/12/17 10:54pm

Good explanation. I like that it is based on your experience and not what

coastcat

11/13/17 2:29pm

It's too early to say Critchlow will be the starter from here out, but he looked

Skysthelimit

11/12/17 3:18pm

Gotta' remember Critchlow was going up against a weak team. I think he

rockyrd

11/12/17 5:17pm

Hopefully Detmer keeps the new spread concepts he has been implementing

Jericho

11/12/17 5:25pm

You should say that a few more times and try a little harder to be persuasive.

travelcoug

11/13/17 12:56am

The weird thing is the last QBto really develop (as in improve year to year) was

akmewg

11/12/17 5:58pm

Max's sophomore year was by far his worst.

molodyets

11/12/17 7:10pm

I stand corrected on stats, hadn't looked them up, steady improvement in passe

akmewg

11/12/17 7:47pm

Simply not true. Max improved every year

Jericho

11/12/17 8:10pm

He needs to transfer down to a lower level of football, with less pressure from

Game Changer

11/12/17 6:03pm

Not a single person blaming Detmer. Incredible.

Scott_Tenorman

11/12/17 7:20pm

I put 90% of the blame on Detmer. Definitely alluded to it in my post too...

Jericho

11/12/17 8:11pm

I wonder how much, if at all, Detmer is to blame. That's why I ask if Tanner's drop in performance has to

Santos L. Halper

11/12/17 9:05pm

Does Tanner Put up 28 points against UNLV?

coug almighty

11/12/17 10:27pm

Yes

shakarocks

11/13/17 10:40am

Too bad for him or too bad for the team? TM is a great guy, but he seems to have

coug almighty

11/13/17 11:11am

You're really not looking very deeply

shakarocks

11/13/17 12:01pm

He becomes our very valuable experienced backup QB who doesn’t need a lot of...

Posting on CougarBoard