Yeah I edited my post after I checked espn's box. You were right. I was remembering some great runs

Report problem with this ad

Aug 21, 2019
12:52:52pm

DieHarder You're wrong I'm right

Report problem with this ad

DieHarder

Previous username: ChairmanOfTheBoard
Bio page: DieHarder
Joined: Aug 13, 2016
Last login: Jun 4, 2024
Total posts: 39,822 (4,019 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Who is the better QB as of RIGHT NOW? Hill or Wilson?

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

8/21/19 12:38pm

LOL at anyone saying Zach

Coop

8/21/19 12:39pm

Ask me next Friday

Denile

8/21/19 12:42pm

Taysom was real bad versus Utah every time. Not a high bar to clear.

SandYFan

8/21/19 12:44pm

I remember him being pretty good in '16. But yes he did have that bad last play

DieHarder

8/21/19 12:47pm

Let's check the stat line.

SandYFan

8/21/19 12:50pm

Yeah I edited my post after I checked espn's box. You were right. I was remembering some great runs

DieHarder

8/21/19 12:52pm

RIGHT NOW. Hill's had 3 years of NFL tutelage plus an extended bout of good health.

Indy Coug

8/21/19 12:51pm

and it's not close.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:04pm

Yep. The NFL coaches are not stupid. He would not be

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 1:07pm

You're making some assumptions.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:08pm

Um. Yes that is what we are all doing because Taysom will never be

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 1:17pm

Yes. I'm also saying until he does it IN A REAL NFL GAME I am unconvinced.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:20pm

Fair enough. I feel that way about Wilson though. He is

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 1:33pm

or we could assume that NFL training has no impact.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:30pm

Neato he's had a few good moments in preseason games.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:07pm

OK so what has Wilson done so far?

Indy Coug

8/21/19 1:08pm

Had a better passing game versus Utah than Taysom ever came close to.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:09pm

So he was good enough to throw a pick 6 and lose a 20 point lead?

Indy Coug

8/21/19 1:13pm

<< Deleted >>

ataylor

8/21/19 1:14pm

Your personal attacks mean you have nothing else to argue. Sad.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:16pm

<< Deleted >>

ataylor

8/21/19 1:24pm

Hey, compared to Tayson, he was Steve Young out there. That's all we're

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:15pm

NFL Taysom Hill hasn't played against Utah ever.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:29pm

All we know about NFL Taysom is that Sean loves him and he is the

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:30pm

Some good advice for you here..

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 1:55pm

Wilson is the better passer. Taysom the better QB if you consider rushing.

SandYFan

8/21/19 12:43pm

RE: Wilson is the better passer. Taysom the better QB if you consider rushing.

UberDeek

8/21/19 3:18pm

How could you put anything but Taysom here? Some fans are loco.

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 12:49pm

Unlike Mack Brown, Kyle W will actually have a great defensive plan next week...

Denile

8/21/19 1:11pm

Let me ask this another way. Would you take Huntley or the best high school

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 1:23pm

Of course I would take Taysom to start next week however...

Denile

8/21/19 1:37pm

I wont disagree with you there.

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 1:41pm

One of them is rostered in the NFL as a QB, the other is coming off his freshman year at BYU.

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 1:15pm

Plenty of garbage quarterbacks are third string in the NFL.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:16pm

Ok.. is John Beck garbage? How about Max Hall?

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 1:18pm

Your argument that any third-string QB is a great QB is wrong.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:19pm

Did I say he was a great QB? I said one of them is getting paid to be a professional QB in the NFL

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 1:21pm

Yeah Taysom is a poor passer and always has been. Fantastic runner and phyiscal

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:24pm

Today, it's not even close. This is ridiculous.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:28pm

You assume, based on some preseason play. Not concrete evidence.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:31pm

you assume Taysom Hill hasn't improved in years.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:34pm

Honestly he didn't improve as a passer much at all at BYU. So maybe.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:38pm

You obviously didn't watch the Nebraska game when he was healthy and at 100%

BYUMizzou

8/21/19 1:43pm

He looked amazing for less than an entire game. And when he came back, he was

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:46pm

regardless, he had no NFL coaching at that point. He's much better today.

Belboz

8/21/19 1:50pm

Based on the preseason bright spots we've seen? Nah.

SandYFan

8/21/19 1:57pm

He hasn't played against college defenses in years.

Belboz

8/21/19 2:30pm

I guarantee you the 2nd and 3rd string defensive players on NFL rosters are

BYUMizzou

8/21/19 1:42pm

Wrong, anyone who is not a 1st stringer on an NFL roster is garbage.

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 1:54pm

How good do you think the average third-string QB is?

SandYFan

8/21/19 2:02pm

In the NFL? Better than Wilson is right now.

JohnnyComeLately

8/21/19 2:03pm

Over the past 10 years, there have been an average of 11 QBs taken in the draft

BYUMizzou

8/21/19 3:16pm

Ding ding ding!!! ^^^

CougaRR4L

8/21/19 3:39pm

Not to mention many of those get cut, Taysom has managed to stay on a roster despite being a UFA.

Posting on CougarBoard