My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 13, 2019
8:18
:20
am
8theU
Playmaker
I fail to see how you see that as screwed?
Yewtah lost to USC. Bama lost to LSU.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
8theU
Bio page
8theU
Joined
May 24, 2006
Last login
Apr 17, 2024
Total posts
1,891 (9 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Does 12-1 Utah make the playoffs?
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:03pm
I still think they get screwed behind a one-loss Bama or one-loss LSU.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 6:05pm
yep. I think the Oregon Utah Pac12 champ is 5th and goes to Rose. Unless something weird happens with the teams above
BlueFrog
11/12/19 6:06pm
I think Oregon gets #4 but Utah would be #5
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:33pm
Just LSU. P12 Champ will get in ahead of Alabama if both Utah and Oregon
TFL
11/12/19 6:09pm
I disagree. Alabama will be too compelling to ignore if they win out.
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:15pm
Trust me. Why would the committee rematch LSU vs. Alabama when the Tide already
TFL
11/12/19 6:21pm
Wrong, Bama got in over OSU
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:23pm
Ohio State had 2 losses that year. In 2017, when Alabama made the playoff
Ute in DC
11/12/19 6:52pm
My point was that the committee will do what it wants
puntersarepeople
11/13/19 3:17pm
RE: Trust me. Why would the committee rematch LSU vs. Alabama when the Tide
gwill
11/12/19 6:43pm
They're not going to keep a one loss Alabama out unless
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:38pm
Bama odds for getting in are extremely low this year. Much worse than Pac12
archie
11/12/19 6:51pm
is that why Alabama is ranked 5th in the CFP Ranking? AHEAD of the Pac 12 teams?
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:57pm
These polls don't reflect the future, just the current resume.
archie
11/12/19 6:58pm
Neither could Georgia, and look what happened with them.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:08pm
I'm sorry, what's your argument?
archie
11/12/19 7:12pm
The argument is, 2 SEC teams are in, and 2 PAC 12 teams are out.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:42pm
Clemson can beat OSU if they (Lawrence) figure it out
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:55pm
Possibly. That's another match up I'd love to see.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:01pm
Bama is not making it this year over a one loss conference champ.
Michigan
11/12/19 7:54pm
But does a 1 loss Pac-12 champ make it over an undefeated Baylor...
CougarThug
11/12/19 11:55pm
Wrong IMO if Bama looks good to finish the year
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:16pm
Alabama would have just defeated Auburn.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 6:48pm
How many losses would Auburn have at that point? 3? 4?
displacedute
11/12/19 7:20pm
On a last second throw on what is essentially a road game for Oregon
TFL
11/12/19 9:48pm
That would be fair.
Rocketman
11/12/19 6:56pm
Screwed? Haha!
Ned Schneebly
11/12/19 7:28pm
Hey Ned.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 7:41pm
Hey Joe.
Ned Schneebly
11/12/19 8:07pm
LSU has absolutely earned there way in. No screwing necessary
stansburycoug
11/12/19 10:30pm
I fail to see how you see that as screwed?
8theU
11/13/19 8:18am
It will come down to their one loss to USC compared to another one good loss.
Kauai
11/12/19 6:06pm
No, SEC and BIG 10 will get a team in
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:06pm
People forget undefeated Minnesota of the BIG..
SaintGeorgeYFan
11/12/19 6:43pm
Minnesota is behind Oregon and Utah with no losses. Do you think they can lose
Scratch
11/12/19 6:49pm
Yes, a one loss Minnesota will be 2/3 against Wisconsin, Iowa, and OSU
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:54pm
Utah gets in (maybe) if:
tommyjohngonewrong
11/12/19 6:07pm
Agree but don t think all of number 5 has to happen
stansburycoug
11/12/19 6:58pm
I think Utah will lose to UCLA
Sandy Lyle
11/12/19 6:08pm
This. Mark it down
letthewookiewin
11/12/19 6:09pm
Utah is favored by 21
viper
11/12/19 6:12pm
RE: Utah is favored by 21
letthewookiewin
11/12/19 6:32pm
oh please, let it be so!
viper
11/12/19 6:53pm
They're ceiling this year is 5
archie
11/12/19 6:08pm
The top Big 12 teams are #10 and #13 right now.
displacedute
11/12/19 6:10pm
doesn't really matter what they are currently. They can't move up and Big12 can
archie
11/12/19 6:11pm
It matters a ton.
displacedute
11/12/19 6:13pm
I think that's the case with Oregon, but not with Utah
archie
11/12/19 6:15pm
I think this site is pretty good, it seems to support my statements
archie
11/12/19 6:18pm
That site says that if Bama, Utah, and OU all win out, Bama is by far the least
Scratch
11/12/19 6:21pm
I never said Bama would make it. They're ceiling is 5 too
archie
11/12/19 6:24pm
If the current leaders from those conferences win out that’s a real possibility.
Scratch
11/12/19 6:32pm
There's some give
archie
11/12/19 6:40pm
Disagree on Clemson.
DocPimp
11/13/19 4:59pm
If Baylor wins out, they d get in
stansburycoug
11/12/19 7:06pm
The odds are substantially higher than BYU fans' perception but still low
TFL
11/12/19 6:08pm
The CB angst is palpable after tonight's rankings release
tommyjohngonewrong
11/12/19 6:10pm
it is extremely unlikely Utah get considered, let alone in.
RealityCheck
11/12/19 11:36pm
I voted no. I don't see any team jumping a 1 loss LSU team. Bama, on the other
Mathew
11/12/19 6:12pm
Yep...if Alabama beat LSU, it would be over for the Pac-12, now the Pac needs
TFL
11/12/19 6:16pm
I don’t see any 1-loss team that didn’t play in a conference championship game
Scratch
11/12/19 6:20pm
Which is fair. Look, of course I would be jealous of Utah making the playoffs,
Mathew
11/12/19 6:34pm
I also think the P12 is helped by its lack of dogs. According to Sagarin, the
Scratch
11/12/19 6:39pm
Good point. A lot of football between now and then. It will be fun to see
Mathew
11/12/19 6:46pm
I think LSU gets in even if they lose to Georgia
stansburycoug
11/12/19 7:15pm
I do too. Good point.
TFL
11/12/19 7:24pm
For sure. That’s why I said “that didn’t play in a conference championship game.
Scratch
11/12/19 7:41pm
Georgia. That team could really screw it up for a few teams.
Mathew
11/12/19 7:50pm
Take your blinders off. You'll see that only one loss with out a single quality
enjoyit
11/13/19 8:21am
A one loss PAC 12 champ has a good chance over other one loss teams
Josef K
11/12/19 6:28pm
4. Alabama’s schedule sucks this year.
Scratch
11/12/19 6:33pm
If a 1-loss Georgia beats a previously undefeated LSU in the SEC championship
Scratch
11/12/19 6:35pm
RE: 4. Alabama’s schedule sucks this year.
gwill
11/12/19 6:50pm
They are both better than Bama’s so far, and then winning a CCG
Scratch
11/12/19 6:53pm
7 one-loss teams get in before 12-1 Utah
Blue Cat
11/12/19 6:39pm
Oklahoma will eh?
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:43pm
Without a doubt.
Blue Cat
11/12/19 6:47pm
Lol we’ll see. Lots of season left.
DocPimp
11/12/19 6:51pm
Debatable
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:59pm
Since Hawaii lost to Washington by 32-points, I think it's safe to say this
Ute in DC
11/12/19 7:06pm
You're right
IndepYndent
11/12/19 7:08pm
Better than BYU would then, who went 1-2 against the Pac this yr
DocPimp
11/12/19 9:10pm
Part of me hopes they make it so we can watch them get PUMMELED.
DraperCoug22
11/12/19 6:52pm
RE: POLL: Does 12-1 Utah make the playoffs?
CallingDingo
11/12/19 7:08pm
Utes schedule is weak.
Coug Dude
11/12/19 7:17pm
RE: Utes schedule is weak.
displacedute
11/12/19 7:30pm
Yep. Our loss to USF did them in.
IndepYndent
11/12/19 8:06pm
Shocked that it's not impacting them more. West coast bias?
stansburycoug
11/12/19 9:35pm
Bruins need to win out and beat Oregon in CCG. Fixes everything.
Cougarbib
11/12/19 7:51pm
So awesome that this is a poll. What a time to be alive.
DocPimp
11/12/19 9:13pm
Hell no!
BYUvermont
11/12/19 10:44pm
That the fact that this is even being debated is hilarious to me.
slatecoug
11/12/19 10:50pm
Agreed. This playoff system was carefully designed specifically to exclude
Megamind
11/12/19 11:25pm
Lol super ignorant take. If that was the case...
DocPimp
11/12/19 11:33pm
That silly computer ranking is only a minor component of the selection process.
Megamind
11/12/19 11:56pm
Highly doubtful. Need a 2nd loss by Alabama & OU to have a chance.
CougarThug
11/12/19 11:14pm
Here is the skinny.
BayUte
11/12/19 11:25pm
This is correct. LSU or possibly OSU would get in over 4 if lose in CCG
archie
11/13/19 12:21am
Lol they can very much leave a 1 loss Conf champ out
IndepYndent
11/13/19 9:15am
Who said anything about feelings?
BayUte
11/13/19 2:57pm
IDK if you realize but this has already happened. And guess who it was.
IndepYndent
11/13/19 3:13pm
Sigh... no it has not.
BayUte
11/13/19 9:12pm
Keep believing that champ. The rest of us will see how the season shakes out.
DocPimp
11/13/19 10:15pm
There will at least be one if not 2
stansburycoug
11/13/19 10:22pm
Agree about LSU losing to Georgia in champ game.
DocPimp
11/13/19 11:26pm
The most interesting decision would be Oklahoma vs Utah
stansburycoug
11/14/19 8:29am
I agree with all that!
DocPimp
11/14/19 9:09am
If you genuinely want to know why
TFL
11/14/19 10:17am
And honestly Pac showed pretty well overall against other P5
DocPimp
11/14/19 10:46am
Oregon only has 3, Utah has 5 if you are including BYU
stansburycoug
11/14/19 10:53am
Of course, BYU is included. Utah has 5 and almost no one else has that many
TFL
11/14/19 11:03am
Says the ute on BYU's board. Go look at the odds.
IndepYndent
11/14/19 2:11am
CB earlier this yr: Utah overrated, won’t win division. Will never win the Pac.
DocPimp
11/14/19 5:25am
RE: Says the ute on BYU's board. Go look at the odds.
BuckElk
11/14/19 7:17am
Utah has a 70% chance of going to the
TFL
11/14/19 10:26am
Go Bruins.
Cougarbib
11/14/19 11:06am
Go Cougs!
TFL
11/14/19 11:19am
Sorry, but leaving Alabama out would completely destroy the legitimacy of the playoff, unless Baylor goes undefeated.
slatecoug
11/13/19 10:45am
You forgot a “Hell no” option.
bornbyu93
11/13/19 7:17am
Still lots of football to be played but Utah's chances keeping going up
BYU Fan
11/13/19 7:25am
Until they lose
puntersarepeople
11/13/19 4:43pm
Which they can. Lol holding off until Sat to buy CCG tickets.
DocPimp
11/13/19 5:01pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad