My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 14, 2019
9:09
:32
am
DocPimp
3rd String
I agree with all that!
Penn St is a legit good team. But I watched the Penn/Pitt game that was way closer than it should have been. Of the good teams I think Penn is a team Utah can beat.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
DocPimp
New username
DrJazzy
Bio page
DocPimp
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Last login
Mar 24, 2020
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Does 12-1 Utah make the playoffs?
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:03pm
I still think they get screwed behind a one-loss Bama or one-loss LSU.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 6:05pm
yep. I think the Oregon Utah Pac12 champ is 5th and goes to Rose. Unless something weird happens with the teams above
BlueFrog
11/12/19 6:06pm
I think Oregon gets #4 but Utah would be #5
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:33pm
Just LSU. P12 Champ will get in ahead of Alabama if both Utah and Oregon
TFL
11/12/19 6:09pm
I disagree. Alabama will be too compelling to ignore if they win out.
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:15pm
Trust me. Why would the committee rematch LSU vs. Alabama when the Tide already
TFL
11/12/19 6:21pm
Wrong, Bama got in over OSU
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:23pm
Ohio State had 2 losses that year. In 2017, when Alabama made the playoff
Ute in DC
11/12/19 6:52pm
My point was that the committee will do what it wants
puntersarepeople
11/13/19 3:17pm
RE: Trust me. Why would the committee rematch LSU vs. Alabama when the Tide
gwill
11/12/19 6:43pm
They're not going to keep a one loss Alabama out unless
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:38pm
Bama odds for getting in are extremely low this year. Much worse than Pac12
archie
11/12/19 6:51pm
is that why Alabama is ranked 5th in the CFP Ranking? AHEAD of the Pac 12 teams?
BlueFever
11/12/19 6:57pm
These polls don't reflect the future, just the current resume.
archie
11/12/19 6:58pm
Neither could Georgia, and look what happened with them.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:08pm
I'm sorry, what's your argument?
archie
11/12/19 7:12pm
The argument is, 2 SEC teams are in, and 2 PAC 12 teams are out.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:42pm
Clemson can beat OSU if they (Lawrence) figure it out
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:55pm
Possibly. That's another match up I'd love to see.
BlueFever
11/12/19 7:01pm
Bama is not making it this year over a one loss conference champ.
Michigan
11/12/19 7:54pm
But does a 1 loss Pac-12 champ make it over an undefeated Baylor...
CougarThug
11/12/19 11:55pm
Wrong IMO if Bama looks good to finish the year
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:16pm
Alabama would have just defeated Auburn.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 6:48pm
How many losses would Auburn have at that point? 3? 4?
displacedute
11/12/19 7:20pm
On a last second throw on what is essentially a road game for Oregon
TFL
11/12/19 9:48pm
That would be fair.
Rocketman
11/12/19 6:56pm
Screwed? Haha!
Ned Schneebly
11/12/19 7:28pm
Hey Ned.
mobomanjoe
11/12/19 7:41pm
Hey Joe.
Ned Schneebly
11/12/19 8:07pm
LSU has absolutely earned there way in. No screwing necessary
stansburycoug
11/12/19 10:30pm
I fail to see how you see that as screwed?
8theU
11/13/19 8:18am
It will come down to their one loss to USC compared to another one good loss.
Kauai
11/12/19 6:06pm
No, SEC and BIG 10 will get a team in
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:06pm
People forget undefeated Minnesota of the BIG..
SaintGeorgeYFan
11/12/19 6:43pm
Minnesota is behind Oregon and Utah with no losses. Do you think they can lose
Scratch
11/12/19 6:49pm
Yes, a one loss Minnesota will be 2/3 against Wisconsin, Iowa, and OSU
puntersarepeople
11/12/19 6:54pm
Utah gets in (maybe) if:
tommyjohngonewrong
11/12/19 6:07pm
Agree but don t think all of number 5 has to happen
stansburycoug
11/12/19 6:58pm
I think Utah will lose to UCLA
Sandy Lyle
11/12/19 6:08pm
This. Mark it down
letthewookiewin
11/12/19 6:09pm
Utah is favored by 21
viper
11/12/19 6:12pm
RE: Utah is favored by 21
letthewookiewin
11/12/19 6:32pm
oh please, let it be so!
viper
11/12/19 6:53pm
They're ceiling this year is 5
archie
11/12/19 6:08pm
The top Big 12 teams are #10 and #13 right now.
displacedute
11/12/19 6:10pm
doesn't really matter what they are currently. They can't move up and Big12 can
archie
11/12/19 6:11pm
It matters a ton.
displacedute
11/12/19 6:13pm
I think that's the case with Oregon, but not with Utah
archie
11/12/19 6:15pm
I think this site is pretty good, it seems to support my statements
archie
11/12/19 6:18pm
That site says that if Bama, Utah, and OU all win out, Bama is by far the least
Scratch
11/12/19 6:21pm
I never said Bama would make it. They're ceiling is 5 too
archie
11/12/19 6:24pm
If the current leaders from those conferences win out that’s a real possibility.
Scratch
11/12/19 6:32pm
There's some give
archie
11/12/19 6:40pm
Disagree on Clemson.
DocPimp
11/13/19 4:59pm
If Baylor wins out, they d get in
stansburycoug
11/12/19 7:06pm
The odds are substantially higher than BYU fans' perception but still low
TFL
11/12/19 6:08pm
The CB angst is palpable after tonight's rankings release
tommyjohngonewrong
11/12/19 6:10pm
it is extremely unlikely Utah get considered, let alone in.
RealityCheck
11/12/19 11:36pm
I voted no. I don't see any team jumping a 1 loss LSU team. Bama, on the other
Mathew
11/12/19 6:12pm
Yep...if Alabama beat LSU, it would be over for the Pac-12, now the Pac needs
TFL
11/12/19 6:16pm
I don’t see any 1-loss team that didn’t play in a conference championship game
Scratch
11/12/19 6:20pm
Which is fair. Look, of course I would be jealous of Utah making the playoffs,
Mathew
11/12/19 6:34pm
I also think the P12 is helped by its lack of dogs. According to Sagarin, the
Scratch
11/12/19 6:39pm
Good point. A lot of football between now and then. It will be fun to see
Mathew
11/12/19 6:46pm
I think LSU gets in even if they lose to Georgia
stansburycoug
11/12/19 7:15pm
I do too. Good point.
TFL
11/12/19 7:24pm
For sure. That’s why I said “that didn’t play in a conference championship game.
Scratch
11/12/19 7:41pm
Georgia. That team could really screw it up for a few teams.
Mathew
11/12/19 7:50pm
Take your blinders off. You'll see that only one loss with out a single quality
enjoyit
11/13/19 8:21am
A one loss PAC 12 champ has a good chance over other one loss teams
Josef K
11/12/19 6:28pm
4. Alabama’s schedule sucks this year.
Scratch
11/12/19 6:33pm
If a 1-loss Georgia beats a previously undefeated LSU in the SEC championship
Scratch
11/12/19 6:35pm
RE: 4. Alabama’s schedule sucks this year.
gwill
11/12/19 6:50pm
They are both better than Bama’s so far, and then winning a CCG
Scratch
11/12/19 6:53pm
7 one-loss teams get in before 12-1 Utah
Blue Cat
11/12/19 6:39pm
Oklahoma will eh?
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:43pm
Without a doubt.
Blue Cat
11/12/19 6:47pm
Lol we’ll see. Lots of season left.
DocPimp
11/12/19 6:51pm
Debatable
IndepYndent
11/12/19 6:59pm
Since Hawaii lost to Washington by 32-points, I think it's safe to say this
Ute in DC
11/12/19 7:06pm
You're right
IndepYndent
11/12/19 7:08pm
Better than BYU would then, who went 1-2 against the Pac this yr
DocPimp
11/12/19 9:10pm
Part of me hopes they make it so we can watch them get PUMMELED.
DraperCoug22
11/12/19 6:52pm
RE: POLL: Does 12-1 Utah make the playoffs?
CallingDingo
11/12/19 7:08pm
Utes schedule is weak.
Coug Dude
11/12/19 7:17pm
RE: Utes schedule is weak.
displacedute
11/12/19 7:30pm
Yep. Our loss to USF did them in.
IndepYndent
11/12/19 8:06pm
Shocked that it's not impacting them more. West coast bias?
stansburycoug
11/12/19 9:35pm
So awesome that this is a poll. What a time to be alive.
DocPimp
11/12/19 9:13pm
Hell no!
BYUvermont
11/12/19 10:44pm
That the fact that this is even being debated is hilarious to me.
slatecoug
11/12/19 10:50pm
Agreed. This playoff system was carefully designed specifically to exclude
Megamind
11/12/19 11:25pm
Lol super ignorant take. If that was the case...
DocPimp
11/12/19 11:33pm
That silly computer ranking is only a minor component of the selection process.
Megamind
11/12/19 11:56pm
Highly doubtful. Need a 2nd loss by Alabama & OU to have a chance.
CougarThug
11/12/19 11:14pm
Here is the skinny.
BayUte
11/12/19 11:25pm
This is correct. LSU or possibly OSU would get in over 4 if lose in CCG
archie
11/13/19 12:21am
Lol they can very much leave a 1 loss Conf champ out
IndepYndent
11/13/19 9:15am
Who said anything about feelings?
BayUte
11/13/19 2:57pm
IDK if you realize but this has already happened. And guess who it was.
IndepYndent
11/13/19 3:13pm
Sigh... no it has not.
BayUte
11/13/19 9:12pm
Keep believing that champ. The rest of us will see how the season shakes out.
DocPimp
11/13/19 10:15pm
There will at least be one if not 2
stansburycoug
11/13/19 10:22pm
Agree about LSU losing to Georgia in champ game.
DocPimp
11/13/19 11:26pm
The most interesting decision would be Oklahoma vs Utah
stansburycoug
11/14/19 8:29am
I agree with all that!
DocPimp
11/14/19 9:09am
If you genuinely want to know why
TFL
11/14/19 10:17am
And honestly Pac showed pretty well overall against other P5
DocPimp
11/14/19 10:46am
Oregon only has 3, Utah has 5 if you are including BYU
stansburycoug
11/14/19 10:53am
Of course, BYU is included. Utah has 5 and almost no one else has that many
TFL
11/14/19 11:03am
Says the ute on BYU's board. Go look at the odds.
IndepYndent
11/14/19 2:11am
CB earlier this yr: Utah overrated, won’t win division. Will never win the Pac.
DocPimp
11/14/19 5:25am
RE: Says the ute on BYU's board. Go look at the odds.
BuckElk
11/14/19 7:17am
Utah has a 70% chance of going to the
TFL
11/14/19 10:26am
Sorry, but leaving Alabama out would completely destroy the legitimacy of the playoff, unless Baylor goes undefeated.
slatecoug
11/13/19 10:45am
You forgot a “Hell no” option.
bornbyu93
11/13/19 7:17am
Still lots of football to be played but Utah's chances keeping going up
BYU Fan
11/13/19 7:25am
Until they lose
puntersarepeople
11/13/19 4:43pm
Which they can. Lol holding off until Sat to buy CCG tickets.
DocPimp
11/13/19 5:01pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad