I think Mandel simply forgot about BYU because we are Indy

Nov 13, 2018
10:17:02am

CaliWG All-American

To find potential fits as replacement for vacant bowl spots the natural inclination is to look for bowl eligible teams conference by conference.

Report problem with this ad

CaliWG

Bio page: CaliWG
Joined: Feb 8, 2005
Last login: May 31, 2024
Total posts: 24,153 (1,547 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Stewart Mandel the lead college football writer at The Athletic has in his bowl

cwilke1

11/13/18 9:45am

Too bad. I was looking forward to playing North Texas

Indy Coug

11/13/18 9:47am

i mean i want BYU to go bowling, but in general it should be more exclusive.

v1k0u6

11/13/18 9:48am

I wish all 6-6 & 7-5 would be left out.

Downtown

11/13/18 9:49am

Wyoming had a great team in '96, finished rankings #22, and didn't go bowling

Downtown

11/13/18 9:56am

Wow that is fascinating. That season 1995 the WAC had a 4-way tie for first

cwilke1

11/13/18 10:08am

Yep...and again, Wyoming at 10-2 left out of '96 and was really an underrated

Downtown

11/13/18 10:11am

So it seems like the old too system was too harsh if there was no bowl for a

cwilke1

11/13/18 10:16am

Well, in that case it was too harsh, but it was also an exception.

Downtown

11/13/18 10:20am

There was less bowel games back than.

Beetdiggercoug

11/13/18 3:07pm

Oops Bowl...Ha

Beetdiggercoug

11/13/18 3:09pm

That's all you think needs to be corrected in your post. 😹

Bluegoogles

11/13/18 5:17pm

No team (including BYU) should go to a bowl with a 6-6 record. There are too

Costanza

11/13/18 9:51am

Why? You don't have to watch. I'd be fine if there were bowls for 2-10 teams.

Thrill

11/13/18 10:02am

Bowl games should be rewards for a very good season not losing half your games.

Costanza

11/13/18 10:14am

That’s not why bowl games exist.

Everyman

11/13/18 10:21am

One teeny-tiny problem. Only 3 bowl games sell well anymore. CFP semi's & final.

TrueBlue67

11/13/18 1:45pm

I do agree those teams need more practice. Let them practice.

Costanza

11/13/18 10:14am

Meh. Extra football is always a good thing. No matter how meaningless

nslcougar

11/13/18 10:25am

No. If you are watching Georgia State vs. Western Kentucky in the Cure Bowl

Sandstone Cougar

11/13/18 10:34am

I meant extra BYU football. But for fans of any team in a bowl game, it's a

nslcougar

11/13/18 10:42am

I think Mandel simply forgot about BYU because we are Indy

CaliWG

11/13/18 10:17am

No he mentioned BYU in his opening paragraphs.

cwilke1

11/13/18 10:30am

yea, I think the issue is that rule applies to contracted bowls.

whiteninja

11/13/18 10:31am

That's the only reason Mandel forgot about byu?

Bluegoogles

11/13/18 5:19pm

maybe Stewart Mandel is wrong when he gives the rule that 7-5 teams must be

cwilke1

11/13/18 10:31am

Good find

Indy Coug

11/13/18 11:00am

I do know that 6-6 teams must go before 5-7 teams, but I think that's it.

dYrtbYkerYder

11/13/18 3:36pm

THIS IS THE RIGHT ANSWER

BYU Fan

11/13/18 4:01pm

BYU is going to finish 7-5 so it wont be an issue

pappabear246

11/13/18 10:56am

The Yewts have to vacate their win on 11/24/18 already? Nice.

notsofast

11/13/18 12:08pm

No, but I am calling it BYU. Come back and see me in a couple of weeks and I

pappabear246

11/13/18 7:32pm

7-5 record beats a 6-6 record

Heinz57

11/13/18 11:03am

BYU will be 7-5, so moot point.

Benfica1

11/13/18 11:16am

You want to go bowling? ... Don't lose to NIU at home.

canndyman

11/13/18 12:11pm

I am more concerned about lost practice time

Bleeding Blue

11/13/18 12:32pm

A 6-6 BYU team should turn down an invite.

Sooner Cougar

11/13/18 12:32pm

NO way. Our young bucs need the extra practices alotted fr bowls. Wilson

OmahaThunderCoug

11/13/18 1:02pm

Yeah, but think of all the lost eligibility!

squidmark

11/13/18 1:42pm

Well, maybe that would be a good thing and be the catalyst for getting us into..

Posting on CougarBoard