Yes, that is the rule. By definition, the ball must be in constant control

You don't have the ability to post right now...

Report problem with this ad

Oct 20, 2019
1:40:23am

RebelScum All-American

Yes, that is the rule. By definition, the ball must be in constant control

all the way to the ground.

Report problem with this ad

RebelScum

Bio page: RebelScum
Joined: Feb 25, 2010
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 12,714 (1,660 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Why is nobody looking at corruption from the mwc refs?

stonecougar

10/20/19 1:29am

Bushman clearly holding on Finau's 40 yarder...

BYUALWAYSNUM1

10/20/19 1:31am

Lol you has Boise players tackling BYU linemen one one drive come on

franklyvulgar

10/20/19 1:32am

Saw that too. Reffing was uneven both ways

runnincoug

10/20/19 8:20am

Not holding when you have your arms inside the shoulder pads. They call it when

cougaman

10/20/19 8:56am

Its still technically holding and when the BSU players's back is to the Finau and Bushman is driving him to the ground

TheLoneCougar

10/20/19 9:09am

They typically won't call it unless the defender turns and the offensive players

cougaman

10/20/19 9:14am

In addition, go look at both holding calls that they did call. Offensive player

cougaman

10/20/19 9:17am

A counter is the overturned pass to BSU called in, then out of bounds

byujdmba

10/20/19 1:31am

I disagree. Indisputable evidence that he didn't complete the catch

RobAdams

10/20/19 1:32am

To me the 2nd bobble out of bounds happened after he'd secured it in bounds

byujdmba

10/20/19 1:37am

In a situation like that, WR has to control ball to the ground.

RobAdams

10/20/19 1:38am

Yes, that is the rule. By definition, the ball must be in constant control

RebelScum

10/20/19 1:40am

Have to bring the catch to the ground. He didn’t

BYU '80

10/20/19 1:40am

Any bobble is grounds for incompletion

Littlerich

10/20/19 7:01am

Would need 3 steps before the"bobble" for that to be the case

cougaman

10/20/19 8:57am

There’s a moment when the receiver isn’t touching the ball at all while his foot

akmewg

10/20/19 1:36am

Disagree but they scored anyway

BYU '80

10/20/19 1:36am

Both hands came off the ball while out of bounds.

bluecougar1985

10/20/19 8:05am

The call on Heron was freaking horrible.

SeattleBYUfan

10/20/19 1:32am

If it's the one I'm thinking of, Heron was grabbing the WR's jersey

RobAdams

10/20/19 1:36am

Yeah he is playing to ball but he can’t grab like that

akmewg

10/20/19 1:37am

You mean the one where both were hand fighting and Herron had

BYU '80

10/20/19 1:40am

Heron was in great position. And if he just doesn't grab the jersey, he's fine

RobAdams

10/20/19 1:41am

He was between the qb and receiver. The receiver was grabbing him

BYU '80

10/20/19 1:50am

It was before he went up for the ball. He was holding his jersey before that as

westsidecoug

10/20/19 2:05am

Regardless was ticky tack esp with all the grabbing Bsu got away with

BYU '80

10/20/19 7:19am

The receiver also had his arm and pulled him down. If anything it should

bluecougar1985

10/20/19 8:10am

Ticky tack

puntersarepeople

10/20/19 7:45am

I swear they gave them a 4th TO, I’ll have to go back but they were out of Time

akmewg

10/20/19 1:43am

3rd TO was called, then used for challenge, allowed. Then reaffirmed as called

Crazy Joe Davola

10/20/19 8:04am

The ref kept calling for time to be placed back on the clock...

kotacoug

10/20/19 1:54am

Even when they measured (reluctantly) and it was good, the ref pulled and

akmewg

10/20/19 1:58am

It looked like the chain guy pulled it at a funny diagonally backwards so

goofball

10/20/19 7:44am

I was fuming about this. He has predetermined it was short and remeasured.

ColdFusion1989

10/20/19 8:09am

Indispensable video evidence is a farce. End it already so expectations can be

RealityCheck

10/20/19 5:20am

The worst call was the spot on the 3rd down run on BYU's last drive.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/20/19 7:48am

So bad

I'mBatman

10/20/19 8:21am

Sitake needs to challenge that. He has the timeouts left. Nothing to lose. Bad

cougaman

10/20/19 8:59am

Harbaugh noticed the same thing at Penn State

OU Cougar

10/20/19 7:48am

Because 2/3 of CB think refs are infallible.

bluecougar1985

10/20/19 8:02am

Is this a joke? I feel like we are the worst about complaining about refs

akmewg

10/20/19 12:58pm

Nope, until your willing to pin a loss on bad calls you are

bluecougar1985

10/20/19 1:50pm

We didn’t lose, we won, if we had lost we would blame it on Refs. We complain

akmewg

10/20/19 1:58pm

The question is would YOU have blamed it on the refs in this instance?

bluecougar1985

10/20/19 5:29pm

stonecougar

10/20/19 5:46pm

Honestly I couldn't tell on most close calls with high school camera work

Pony Zale

10/20/19 8:31am

A “Refs are Corrupt” post after a win? Enjoy the win.

Alsippi89

10/20/19 8:57am

The CB. Even when our team wins, we complain about the refs.

UNHuskerCoug

10/20/19 9:01am

Correct. Upon rewatching garbage night for refs

DoctorEvil

10/20/19 12:38pm

Brethren, you won.

Posting on CougarBoard