Cache Valley is the best part of Utah. Still feels small, doesn't have a bunch of dummies driving through on I-15, has most of what anyone could want except a regional airport (and having an airport would probably make it worse).
If my wife was okay with snow and I could make the same money there that I make now? I'd move to CV in a heartbeat. Probably River Heights or Logan near the Country Club. Someplace with a view of the River. Or maybe right on Hyrum Dam.