kama is a really good dude, so i'm not worried about the personality stuff.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 16, 2014
3:50:24pm

riboflavin

kama is a really good dude, so i'm not worried about the personality stuff.

i don't think he meant any disrespect.

lets not pretend that williams hasn't played some terrible teams too. he tore it up against texas but everything in the world was working against texas.

it'd be interesting to see their numbers side by side. number of carries, yards per carry, etc.

Report problem with this ad

riboflavin

Previous username: the_format
Bio page: riboflavin
Joined: Oct 5, 2006
Last login: Jun 15, 2024
Total posts: 79,889 (48,710 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: I would trade Jamaal Williams for Harvey Unga this year.

Undefeated

4/16/14 3:01pm

<< Deleted >>

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:02pm

Most years I would. But Jamal fits this current O better.

4/16/14 3:05pm

I would trade Jamaal Williams' O-line for Harvey Unga's O-line

billyrust

4/16/14 3:06pm

Exactly.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:13pm

For Harvey in his prime? Absolutely. I hope most that voted are forgetting that

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 3:21pm

+1. His size and elusiveness made him a joy to watch. Special player.

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:25pm

I love Unga but Jamaal will actually play in the NFL

4/16/14 3:29pm

Which current NFL player most closely resembles Jamaal?

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:34pm

A poor mans Shady McCoy.

Shimmy

4/16/14 3:43pm

very poor. I think he looks more like Stevan Ridley w/o the fumbles.

Belboz

4/16/14 3:44pm

I think a poor man's Matt Forte

CoopDizz

4/16/14 3:59pm

Could Jamaal play in the NFL this year?

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 3:39pm

I don't believe so, no.

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:05pm

he also had several of his OL go on to play on Sundays in the NFL...

icecougar

4/16/14 7:31pm

I don't think NFL teams take that into account when they draft a guy.

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 9:43pm

I love JSwag but he is not YET close to being the running back that Harvey was.

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:30pm

RE: I love JSwag but he is not YET close to being the running back that Harvey

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:34pm

Even if Kama's comment is TIC, I'll adopt it as my own. He'll end

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:37pm

RE: Even if Kama's comment is TIC, I'll adopt it as my own. He'll end

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:45pm

kama is a really good dude, so i'm not worried about the personality stuff.

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:50pm

Okay

CoopDizz

4/16/14 4:17pm

That clears it up.

4/16/14 4:36pm

RE: That clears it up.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 4:47pm

I agree, but its still fun to consider and make comparisons.

4/16/14 4:54pm

RE: I agree, but its still fun to consider and make comparisons.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 5:06pm

Not intended as a cheap shot. I personally find JSwag and his personality

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:51pm

Settle down. Don't get so worked up.

messi

4/16/14 4:00pm

Not TIC. I have no doubt that he CAN end up ther but not YET.

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:44pm

Kama knows his stuff, no worries about what Kama said

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:04pm

He was GREAT last year

CoopDizz

4/16/14 4:05pm

Harvey beats JW on size, escape moves, punishing defenders, and catching ability

Cougarclaw

4/16/14 3:48pm

RE: Harvey beats JW on size, escape moves, punishing defenders, and catching

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:51pm

Williams def has a push, but he won't run over you. drag? yes. Punish? no.

Cougarclaw

4/16/14 3:56pm

Harvey was the man. He was a Ute killer. I will always love him for what he

4/16/14 4:00pm

Only looking at last 20 years I'd take Luke, Jenkins, Harvey, Curtis, thenJamaal

Yakov

4/16/14 3:58pm

I might make it Staley, Harvey, Brown, Jenkins

4/16/14 4:40pm

Luke was waaaaay too injury prone

Blueto

4/16/14 7:52pm

But so fun to watch

AF Cougar

4/17/14 6:12am

Do we get a fullback in this trade? Harvey needs a FB

BW84

4/16/14 4:04pm

BYU did a good job at keeping this fact from the Chicago Bears

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 4:10pm

To break free yes..

4/16/14 4:55pm

I'd take Fui in short yardage situations

stoils

4/16/14 5:38pm

before the high ankle injury and surgery...

icecougar

4/16/14 7:37pm

True. I think Fui before that ankle injury MAY have been better than Harvey

Non-mo Coug

4/16/14 10:06pm

He was definately fun to watch when he ran into the line as a freshman.

4/16/14 11:33pm

RE: POLL: I would trade Jamaal Williams for Harvey Unga this year.

kbufcoug

4/16/14 5:09pm

Harvey is the slower of the two

Mars

4/16/14 5:53pm

Robert mentions that as one of Harvey strengths...

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:44pm

Is this the most votes ever on a poll?

byuluvr

4/16/14 9:31pm

Too early to say... Let's see after JAMAAL has 3 yrs under his belt like Harvey

AntiSNOT

4/16/14 11:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad