My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 25, 2016
6:06
:53
pm
southernfriedcougar
Playmaker
In what world is that depressing?
BYU is part of the group of over achievers with recruiting, so recruits landing them that high would be a drastic help to BYU. Team rankings are misunderstood by many, but when you can make a jump 20-30 spots, it's noticeable.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
southernfriedcougar
Previous username
cougidaho
New username
Lip Gallagher
Bio page
southernfriedcougar
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Last login
Apr 10, 2017
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Our 2017 recruiting looks terrible early on.
Pimpin4Paradise
9/25/16 11:08am
Just let TNT know when it is acceptable to panic
TNT
9/25/16 11:10am
Start panicking now
byuluvr
9/25/16 11:19am
As soon as TNT tells everyone why or how he thinks panicking will help
BYUCoug11
9/25/16 11:39am
RE: Just let TNT know when it is acceptable to panic
COACHdrn
9/25/16 9:39pm
McChesney is undervalued imo. But yes that is not a highly regarded list.
PapaBill
9/25/16 11:23am
I have been tempted to do this every time we are assured that there's going to
Freddie Cougar
9/25/16 11:24am
2018 looks pretty good so far though. 8 recruits. 6 with 3 stars early on, and
cougaman
9/25/16 11:41am
It will pick up.
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 12:23pm
Let's hope
The Dangler
9/25/16 1:31pm
Look how many flips and near flips they managed in just a few weeks.
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 1:50pm
Not sure about Alden Tofa
BaseballCoug
9/25/16 6:07pm
Words from his mouth are pretty telling
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 6:11pm
You can't say something like that without including a link or a quote.
cougaman
9/25/16 6:23pm
Boo
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 6:39pm
Thanks. Oregon not looking good this year, and they want to fire their HC right
cougaman
9/25/16 6:58pm
Glad to hear that. Words are better
BaseballCoug
9/25/16 8:22pm
A local kid on a visit with other recruits to a U of U home game.
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 8:28pm
He wasn't posing for a pic. He was on the field, excited, flashing the U ...
BaseballCoug
9/25/16 9:21pm
All I said was that he was with other recruits on a visit to THEIR place.
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 9:32pm
I'm agreeing with you, recruits do weird stuff
BaseballCoug
9/25/16 10:40pm
Also something to consider, don't a lot of the really good recruits tend to wait
Harrison0Yfan
9/25/16 7:42pm
Fautea to Ore St
jrj84105
9/25/16 8:44pm
Yes, and it's lame. But what makes you say they're not in play for Katoa?
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 9:01pm
which Katoa, the RB that signed with Oregon state out of AF?
pegushin
9/26/16 5:24am
2017. Tayler Katoa. 4 star athlete (LB)
southernfriedcougar
9/26/16 9:21am
ok thanks, if we were talking the RB I know he would like to possibly transfer
pegushin
9/26/16 11:18am
Never trust star rankings! Star fruad is a real thing
Kama'aina
9/25/16 12:27pm
Some are overrated and some are underrated, but it's not wrong.
Pimpin4Paradise
9/25/16 12:46pm
The better programs have the better starred recruits IN GENERAL. So yes....
JmThms
9/25/16 2:32pm
Some concerns there
The Dangler
9/25/16 1:28pm
I'll be honest - I think the Langi offer might be due
tcherrin
9/25/16 5:16pm
Anyone good coming home from a mission?
Chicago Cougar fan
9/25/16 1:35pm
Fuga is back and red shirting, I think
I'mBatman
9/25/16 2:02pm
Some promising Dline from last years class as well, that will be here in 2018.
cougaman
9/25/16 2:15pm
Isaiah Nacua
JKLCoug
9/25/16 8:59pm
not for a few years. Went on a mission this spring
cougaman
9/25/16 9:16pm
That kid's gonna really be pee'in off P5 coaches by his Sr year!
mantis mutu
9/26/16 1:51am
Isn't it more common these days for the big time recruits to wait until later in the recruiting cycle? Isn't lot like
HarlemCoug
9/25/16 1:42pm
Stock up on Hanshaw, Buchanan, Bywater, Baker, and McChesney. All could gain a
wiscougarfan
9/25/16 2:02pm
As high as 35! That is depressing.
Diablo and Doc
9/25/16 4:38pm
Not in year 1. Huge jump. Ill take it.
Turnpike Lane
9/25/16 5:15pm
Are you kidding? You do not follow BYU recruiting closely. 35 would be amazing for us
YIsForBrigham
9/25/16 5:52pm
Purely playing devils advocate here. If we recruit consistently at the 60-80
Chicago Cougar fan
9/25/16 5:56pm
It means the recruiting rankings do not accurately grade the typical BYU recruit
YIsForBrigham
9/25/16 6:10pm
Especially with as many early recruits as BYU has had over the years.
cougaman
9/25/16 6:22pm
And that's why it's depressing.
Diablo and Doc
9/25/16 6:00pm
In what world is that depressing?
southernfriedcougar
9/25/16 6:06pm
There are a few programs like BYU in the 60-80 range that consistent overperform
wiscougarfan
9/25/16 9:27pm
I guess another thing I didn't think about is highly ranked recruits will come
Chicago Cougar fan
9/25/16 9:30pm
Baker isn't playing this year, injured
Heinz57
9/25/16 7:02pm
So far, status quo, all BM-type recruits.
ag4cougs
9/25/16 4:37pm
Isn't it true a lot of top re recruites commit later in the process?
ZooBlue
9/25/16 5:34pm
It does seem this way. Many like to do the stupid hat "ceremony" and make
Duke Silver
9/25/16 9:51pm
Yes, but BYU almost never gets hat ceremony type kids
wiscougarfan
9/25/16 9:58pm
Correct, but there's still plenty 3 and 4 star kids who wait til after doing all
Duke Silver
9/25/16 10:06pm
Makes sense...
ZooBlue
9/26/16 10:07am
Who have we missed on?
sandiegocgrfan
9/25/16 7:20pm
Higher rated recruits generally do not commit early...
CoachSpeak
9/25/16 8:31pm
RE: Higher rated recruits generally do not commit early...
wcj99
9/25/16 9:53pm
I've made a list but haven't posted it publically yet. Nearly 1/3 of the kids
wiscougarfan
9/25/16 10:02pm
Also I hate comparing us to Utah....
CoachSpeak
9/25/16 8:46pm
Crap, with that kind of recruiting we'll start 1-3....
byucougarsbig12
9/25/16 9:00pm
Until yewtah starts losing in the pac, we will play second fiddle and wont turn the tide.
indocoug
9/25/16 9:16pm
This time around everyone might be waiting on B12 news.
ditch
9/25/16 10:07pm
I like that they are at least trying to improve the TE position
CougarsFanSince80s
9/25/16 11:08pm
Alls you need is a 4 star in there and it'll pretty much mirror a typical Mendenhall class...
ocmyhome
9/25/16 11:17pm
In terms of stars, maybe--but not in terms of parity.
mantis mutu
9/26/16 1:39am
3 to consider: Hanshaw will be a star as either a TE or DE. Great athlete there.
mantis mutu
9/26/16 1:34am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad