In what way? If we go to the AAC or the MWC, how many P5 games

Oct 18, 2016
2:19:38pm

kimdaddy35 All-American

will we get? The answer may surprise you.

We were in the WAC in 1984 when we won our national title, how many P5 games did we play that year?

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: May 18, 2024
Total posts: 46,736 (1,482 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Why being an Independent in football is sustainable

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:02pm

Holmoe and Mendenhall have both gone on record saying it's not sustainable. Are you doubting them?

buffgato

10/18/16 2:05pm

Yes.

spoxjox

10/18/16 2:05pm

A little common sense. If the conditions of being independent change, so does

bluebrotha

10/18/16 2:07pm

A quick Google search indicates they said this as recently as 2015. Has the CFB environment fundamentally changed since?

buffgato

10/18/16 2:11pm

Two things changed: ACC network and extended GOR, and B12 announced expansion

DrBYU

10/18/16 2:22pm

Yep. TH was talking money difference w/P5. Going back to G5 makes that worse.

SCcoug

10/18/16 2:26pm

More attractive is not the same thing as sustainable

buffgato

10/18/16 2:27pm

So you believe BYU Football is going to die?

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:35pm

I don't know, I'm not the one looking at the balance sheet. It's a very interesting word choice, like TH knows something

buffgato

10/18/16 3:12pm

So you admit Holmoe also meant "Going back to a G5 conf is even less sustainable

bluebrotha

10/18/16 3:13pm

Huh? I didn't say anything about that. It's probably true though.

buffgato

10/18/16 3:33pm

Mendenhall is on record as saying that

wapiti

10/18/16 2:08pm

RE: Holmoe and Mendenhall have both gone on record saying it's not sustainable.

TheLoneCougar

10/18/16 2:52pm

Depends on if you think Holmoe was being sincere or playing the PR game

TNT

10/18/16 2:05pm

Good points

SnickSnack

10/18/16 2:05pm

better forward this to tom holmoe

nashty

10/18/16 2:05pm

LOL. I'm pretty sure Holmoe knows a thing or two about this topic.

Bostonblue

10/18/16 2:22pm

he does know a lot...and HE AGREES WITH ME!!!

nashty

10/18/16 2:58pm

Wrong. The whole point of his interview last Friday was to prove unequivocally

Bostonblue

10/18/16 3:27pm

you are, again, wrong. for many reasons:

nashty

10/18/16 5:32pm

Props for the stubbornness Nashty. But you better have your come to the light

Bostonblue

10/18/16 6:17pm

Yes it is sustainable, and that has been proven by the years we have been Indy.

TheLoneCougar

10/18/16 3:02pm

What does the past really prove though? TH's comments gave me the impression that he feels the squeeze more every year

buffgato

10/18/16 3:16pm

Potentially that is true, but our contract is up here in a year or two and we

TheLoneCougar

10/19/16 9:55am

I'm waiting for TH to tell me its sustainable everything I've heard is its not

franklyvulgar

10/18/16 2:06pm

So you believe that BYU would be better off in the AAC or MWC

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:21pm

I don't know all I know is TH has repeatedly said indy is not sustainable

franklyvulgar

10/18/16 2:25pm

TH wanted badly for BYU to get into a P-5, it didn't happen

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:27pm

Not quite. He's said the financial difference isn't sustainable.

SCcoug

10/18/16 2:28pm

Meaning remain competitive with P5 teams with the financial gap in place?

franklyvulgar

10/18/16 2:30pm

That's what I understood. Coaching salaries, facilities, budgets, etc.

SCcoug

10/18/16 2:33pm

The future scheduling is not sustainable

El Paso Coug

10/18/16 2:49pm

the need to schedule 8-10 P5 teams is a real issue

Nat Gas Man

10/18/16 2:06pm

In what way? If we go to the AAC or the MWC, how many P5 games

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:19pm

I think it's very sustainable too....if BYU can win those amazing games

reagan21

10/18/16 2:07pm

ESPN has been able to get a lot of those matchups

TNT

10/18/16 2:08pm

with ESPN's financial troubles I'd look to these pay games

reagan21

10/18/16 2:09pm

Yep, it's not perfect but BYU can do it. Need donors to step up.

Bostonblue

10/18/16 2:08pm

Independence is fun, it just makes our athletic director work harder than any

Super Chicken

10/18/16 2:10pm

The thing about Alabama is, they aren't very good TV. Too many blow outs.

Coach's Dad

10/18/16 2:10pm

unless schools start to decline scheduling us.

oryguncoug

10/18/16 2:14pm

You are assuming that we can continue to put together schedules like this year

El Paso Coug

10/18/16 2:48pm

Our schedules are starting to take shape all of the way out to 2023

kimdaddy35

10/18/16 2:53pm

Still need 3 more P5 schools to add . . .

El Paso Coug

10/18/16 3:47pm

It absolutely is "sustainable" if that word and definition is what you are using

Posting on CougarBoard