You have no evidence of that. Correlation in some areas, not causation

Apr 24, 2017
4:59:59pm

Lip Gallagher Playmaker

overall. Sorry but a talent gap would have actually done something. Sneaking out wins on missed last second attempts doesn't exactly show a talent gap. Among other things.

Report problem with this ad

Lip Gallagher

Previous username: Rusty'sJuicyCknHole
New username: Chef Carl Casper
Bio page: Lip Gallagher
Joined: Apr 26, 2013
Last login: Apr 30, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: What do you consider to be the biggest single reason for BYU's losing to Utah from 2010 on?

cougarmanguy

4/24/17 1:49pm

Significant player talent discrepancy. Even greater coaching talent discrepancy

Backcountry

4/24/17 1:50pm

And lack of overall depth.

Everyman

4/24/17 1:51pm

So why have the games been so close?

cougarmanguy

4/24/17 2:25pm

#moralvictories

Backcountry

4/24/17 2:53pm

No, it's a legitimate point. If the discrepancy so wide

Beggar

4/24/17 2:59pm

Exactly

cougarmanguy

4/24/17 3:02pm

No. A win is a win. Utah doesn't blow anyone out, but they win a ton of games.

Backcountry

4/24/17 3:03pm

I don't look at it that way

cougarmanguy

4/24/17 3:05pm

That is exactly why our games are close.

Backcountry

4/24/17 3:10pm

Except not

cougarmanguy

4/24/17 3:12pm

What's your theory?

Backcountry

4/24/17 4:38pm

This is 2nd to mental.

Gerald-DeGroot

4/24/17 6:03pm

Mental

Mathew

4/24/17 1:52pm

I'd love two more wins with two last second fg's

Cougforgood

4/24/17 1:54pm

Luck

Indy Coug

4/24/17 1:55pm

No such thing

Backcountry

4/24/17 1:56pm

Thanks Han

Indy Coug

4/24/17 1:58pm

Since when can we thumb up our own posts? Especially bad ones?

Lip Gallagher

4/24/17 2:31pm

Don't buy it.

Cougstreak

4/24/17 5:13pm

12 draft picks to 3

Blue Cat

4/24/17 1:58pm

It's different from year to year

BrutustheBrash

4/24/17 1:59pm

Recruiting OL and DL. BYU got worse and Utah just kept getting better.

Y'zFan

4/24/17 1:59pm

Coaching emphasis.

Thrill

4/24/17 2:08pm

Bronco Mendenhall, so # 3 & 5.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/24/17 2:18pm

Utah to P12. Better talent. Lavell Edwards isn't your coach, etc.

Virginia Ute

4/24/17 2:23pm

Utah was beating BYU by larger margins BEFORE P12. Obviously it didn't

Lip Gallagher

4/24/17 2:37pm

It seems the recruiting gap got wider since Utah knew they were going to the Pac

Blue Cat

4/24/17 3:13pm

Numbers on paper don't mean much. Talent gap like some claim would have

Lip Gallagher

4/24/17 3:20pm

It did produce results. 6 straight wins.

Virginia Ute

4/24/17 4:15pm

You have no evidence of that. Correlation in some areas, not causation

Lip Gallagher

4/24/17 4:59pm

6 straight wins + actual recruiting class rankings gaps = actual gap.

Virginia Ute

4/24/17 5:24pm

You're right. I laughed at the person who said luck.

Lip Gallagher

4/24/17 5:34pm

Position by position Utah has more talent than BYU.

Virginia Ute

4/24/17 5:39pm

From 2010-13, I think Bronco just got straight-up outcoached

Byu_1988

4/24/17 2:26pm

The incredibly stupid turnovers that have changed the game in Utahs favor eachyr

YouPuntYouDye

4/24/17 2:42pm

Should have included "The Max Hall Curse".

Circaman12

4/24/17 2:57pm

7. Pact with Satan

mvtoro

4/24/17 3:22pm

Better athleticism generally across much of the roster.

JmThms

4/24/17 3:30pm

#5, and I'd also add depth.

Harrison0Yfan

4/24/17 3:49pm

Talent

D.T. Survivor

4/24/17 4:01pm

Several BUT 1 annoying trend: 1 coach preached its just another game & 1

NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN

4/24/17 4:19pm

BYU was over emotional. That was part of the problem. Bronco was not saying

BYUtka

4/24/17 4:55pm

Then contradicting his words to team did same thing.

NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN

4/24/17 5:03pm

Mostly less points at the end of regulation, among other factors.

Graig Swame

4/24/17 6:19pm

Their players are better prepared in that game than ours

MaxxPower

4/24/17 6:59pm

Max Hall saying the "hate Utah" speech

BountifulCoug5

4/24/17 7:53pm

None of the above/Max Hall curse

(Private)

4/24/17 8:26pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad