I get that, I just have yet to see a BYU team that wouldn't be better with Luke

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 25, 2017
12:40:37pm

mosterlow All-American

I get that, I just have yet to see a BYU team that wouldn't be better with Luke

Over the current starter. I can't say that about any other BYU RB I have watched play.

Report problem with this ad

mosterlow

New username: USMCdad
Bio page: mosterlow
Joined: Jun 23, 2009
Last login: Jul 4, 2018
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: POLL: Who is the best RB to ever play for BYU (edited with a couple more options)?

jreid191

7/25/17 12:16pm

I'm not a lifelong fan, but Luke is the only RB when he got the ball

mosterlow

7/25/17 12:18pm

It would for me, it would depend on the personnel. Supporting cast matters

7/25/17 12:30pm

I get that, I just have yet to see a BYU team that wouldn't be better with Luke

mosterlow

7/25/17 12:40pm

RE: I get that, I just have yet to see a BYU team that wouldn't be better with

7/25/17 12:45pm

That's fair, I do think the system was Luke, and it proved out to fall short

mosterlow

7/25/17 12:52pm

RE: That's fair, I do think the system was Luke, and it proved out to fall short

7/25/17 1:08pm

Agree, both are the best to play at BYU by far

mosterlow

7/25/17 1:10pm

I don't think Luke was a system guy

wapiti

7/25/17 2:58pm

Luke dominated under both Chow and Crowton

CaliWG

7/25/17 3:15pm

Jenkins had some of the same flair. I wish BYU had him longer.

Belboz

7/25/17 12:34pm

True, unfortunately I associate him with lacking power and fumbling

mosterlow

7/25/17 12:41pm

I see the top 4 as Willis, Jenkins, Staley, and Williams.

Belboz

7/25/17 12:33pm

Yep. Good list.

7/25/17 12:35pm

Who would make top 5? Add Unga? I like your list, btw

Preppy

7/25/17 12:38pm

Unga, Hall, Brown, Lakei Heimuli... they start to blend together in a group.

Belboz

7/25/17 12:43pm

Reno Mahe even blends in that list as he may be the best receiving threat

mosterlow

7/25/17 12:45pm

But I think he was actually a receiver when he returned from his absence.

Belboz

7/25/17 12:47pm

Yup, he was a tailor made slot receiver for Crowton's system

CaliWG

7/25/17 3:06pm

Unga. Great runner, great blocker, great receiver. Not made of glass.

shakinbaker

7/25/17 2:00pm

Unga had a great skill set, but he had holes in his game too

CaliWG

7/25/17 3:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad