I wonder is $ & recruiting would get better in a P5...

Report problem with this ad

Oct 12, 2017
2:43:11pm

Shore10 All-American

Wait, no I don't wonder. It would.

Report problem with this ad

Shore10

Bio page: Shore10
Joined: Oct 26, 2009
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 14,801 (138 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What this season has taught me is that BYU fans don't have the intestinal fortitude for being in a P5 conference

Indy Coug Misunderstood

10/12/17 9:49am

And most P5 schools either have really good years

gwalker

10/12/17 9:51am

Disagree, but your point is a reasonable one.

Archaea

10/12/17 10:37am

I see your point. I disagree.

CosmoK

10/12/17 9:52am

Indy is not arguing that P5 membership wouldn't be a great thing for BYU.

ManicBlue

10/12/17 10:05am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

10/12/17 9:52am

Suggestions?

ManicBlue

10/12/17 10:06am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

10/12/17 10:15am

Loosen the purse strings and pay what it takes to get Mike Leach here. Coaches

OneUpper

10/12/17 10:17am

Feel free to donate to paying the coaches what you think they're worth. Also,

ManicBlue

10/12/17 10:33am

It was a suggestion. Stop making excuses. If BYU doesn't want to Shell out it

OneUpper

10/12/17 10:50am

The parameters and obstacles for bringing in top LDS scholars and top coaches

ManicBlue

10/12/17 11:34am

It's a suggestion smart guy. Look at the context of the subthread. And it is

OneUpper

10/12/17 11:54am

Did you link the thread you referred to? I must have missed it.

ManicBlue

10/12/17 1:45pm

Your post asking for suggestions. You didn't say they had to be realistic. The

OneUpper

10/12/17 3:10pm

You referenced another thread in an earlier post. I was looking for the link

ManicBlue

10/12/17 10:58pm

Man, you get defensive quickly, don't you?

Cyclogist

10/12/17 1:52pm

Sure don't. Thanks for playing, though.

OneUpper

10/12/17 3:08pm

BYU couldn't pay enough to get Mike Leach. Also we wouldn't want him

Dissenter

10/12/17 11:18am

BYU won't let the ROTC Commandant drink coffee at home...Mike Leach isn't coming

Cyclogist

10/12/17 1:51pm

untrue. we'd be like utah. energized at every win. because every game has

johnnycarson

10/12/17 9:52am

Different. Utah’s fan base is new money that hasn’t ever won a championship.

gwalker

10/12/17 9:54am

Well you got 1 out of 3 right.

neboutefan

10/12/17 10:01am

I got at least two. Unless Utah has a NC that no one is aware of.

gwalker

10/12/17 10:13am

well there are some tshirts

johnnycarson

10/12/17 10:14am

we are closer to the year 2050 than 1984

BlueFrog

10/12/17 10:16am

When it comes to the attitude of our fanbase, 1984 has more

gwalker

10/12/17 10:18am

which is a shame

BlueFrog

10/12/17 10:20am

In some ways. In others it isn’t. To the extent we keep the dream of future

gwalker

10/12/17 10:27am

if anyone is using 1984 as proof that BYU can still win the

BlueFrog

10/12/17 10:43am

Anyone saying we can’t doesn’t understand how much of a longshot it was in 1984.

gwalker

10/12/17 11:42am

i'm not suggesting that people can't think it can happen. it can. but using

BlueFrog

10/12/17 11:46am

The lower tier P5 schools have a better bowl situation than us I’d take it

franklyvulgar

10/12/17 9:54am

I think you're wrong. I think we exhibit lack of intestinal fortitude because

Hawk Talons

10/12/17 9:54am

Also true

Borg

10/12/17 9:54am

Exactly how I feel. If we were P5, I'd be disappointed with this year, but not

License To Ill

10/12/17 4:25pm

Indi provides lopsided scheds with no improvement in recruiting. Thats the diff

Turbine

10/12/17 9:54am

indy provides no avenue for success.

johnnycarson

10/12/17 9:54am

Indy is an exhibition season and a clear path to irrelevance

franklyvulgar

10/12/17 9:56am

and front loaded with tough road games.....can't succeed. its why no

johnnycarson

10/12/17 9:57am

I would argue this weighed on Bronco too Holmoe needs to schedule smarter

franklyvulgar

10/12/17 10:00am

Good grief...recruiting will not get better in G5.

mobius

10/12/17 10:02am

Not the discussion at all. Thanks.

Turbine

10/12/17 10:11am

did you not mention recruiting or are you just moving goal posts?

mobius

10/12/17 10:18am

P5 recruiting vs Indi. Come on man.

Turbine

10/12/17 10:29am

You are one of the most vocal advocates for G5 and you brought up recruiting

mobius

10/12/17 10:35am

I was highlighting a HUGE diff in P5 membership and Independance. and Im right.

Turbine

10/12/17 10:46am

and the gap is even bigger P5 to G5 so what's your point?

ManicBlue

10/12/17 10:49am

BYU was closer as a G5. There is no backing that it would get worse by

Turbine

10/12/17 12:06pm

Won't deny that, but it will only get worse G5

mobius

10/12/17 10:55am

Yup....very true

Borg

10/12/17 9:54am

Do you expect our coaching and player talent to stay the same? We’d be able to

Duke Silver

10/12/17 9:55am

This is critical many top tier LDS talent want a P5 opportunity Indy doesn’t fit

franklyvulgar

10/12/17 9:57am

Every time I hear something like this, it gives me a good chuckle,

Sock Gnome

10/12/17 9:59am

Not to mention that our main rival has access to all those advantages

franklyvulgar

10/12/17 10:02am

We aren't in a P5 conference. You really can't make that claim. If we were in

kolob32

10/12/17 10:03am

Just not true at all. This season is not like others...

idacoug

10/12/17 10:04am

Independence schedule <> P5 schedule...

Coug

10/12/17 10:06am

Going P5 "does not equal" going winless.

Mr. Scoobs

10/12/17 10:12am

I think you are correct in general--we don't like losing. However, we aren't

Scooter

10/12/17 10:15am

This fan base has been sold a bowl of pottage and the powers that be have put "skins....

Bonoman

10/12/17 10:16am

<< Deleted >>

stonecougar

10/12/17 10:53am

I think the Football team lacks "intestinal fortitude" they keep pooping all...

kosmokramer

10/12/17 10:56am

Are you kidding me?! Alabama fans %&$^ their pants if they lose one game! We've

Helm Hammerhand

10/12/17 11:01am

We'd have down years, but recruiting would sky rocket, especially with Kalani.

IronPotato

10/12/17 11:58am

You learned the wrong lesson

Blue2thebone

10/12/17 12:58pm

I wonder is $ & recruiting would get better in a P5...

Shore10

10/12/17 2:43pm

Nah. Once we're P5, we will all collectively let out a sigh of relief

Posting on CougarBoard