My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 4, 2018
12:56
:07
pm
canofpicante
Walk-on
Neither equation is true. In this game, success is measured by wins and votes
And We had more of both in the MWC and WAC.
We had more wins and we had more votes.
We had a lot less Money.
We had a lot less Big Games.
But we had a lot more success because we had wins and votes at the end of the year.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
canofpicante
Bio page
canofpicante
Joined
Oct 14, 2011
Last login
Jan 25, 2024
Total posts
4,645 (8 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
P5 > Indy, P5 > G5. Indy vs G5 is undetermined as far as what is better for BYU
palangi
4/4/18 8:34am
If Money = Success then Indy > G5. If big games vs big name schools = success then Indy > G5.
IceBlueCoug
4/4/18 8:54am
Winning = success. Finishing ranked = success. Money =/ success but should help
palangi
4/4/18 9:07am
Because winning CANNOT happen as an Indy and it's impossible to be ranked as an Indy. BYU can play these P5 programs
IceBlueCoug
4/4/18 9:12am
BYU has not finished ranked since becoming Indy
franklyvulgar
4/4/18 9:13am
I just defined what success is, and it is NOT money or playing big name teams
palangi
4/4/18 9:20am
YES!! And by those definitions we were more successful in the MWC AND WAC
canofpicante
4/4/18 12:57pm
Neither equation is true. In this game, success is measured by wins and votes
canofpicante
4/4/18 12:56pm
The ceiling is higher as Indy than G5. I prefer that
Coogar2
4/4/18 9:21am
It might not be though, I originally thought it was but a strong argument can be
palangi
4/4/18 9:41am
no, it's objectively not lower
Dissenter
4/4/18 10:34am
objectively they would've played in the same bowl as UCF so that's not "higher"
palangi
4/4/18 11:02am
Utah's ceiling IS just as high as USC's.
Dissenter
4/4/18 11:18am
I disagree. USC's ceiling is much higher than Utah's. When Utah puts together
palangi
4/4/18 11:28am
but I understand that we have different definitions of what a ceiling is
palangi
4/4/18 11:29am
It was a reaction to Utah going to the pac 12, it’s been rough
franklyvulgar
4/4/18 9:25am
Yeah it clearly hasn't helped there 🙁
palangi
4/4/18 9:39am
If you aren’t P5 then conference affiliation means nothing.
Caboom
4/4/18 10:15am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad