Would it have changed anything in 2006 though? Beck was stellar and, IMO, was not the reason why we lost any games.

Report problem with this ad

May 22, 2018
9:04:29am

Ned Schneebly Starter

Report problem with this ad

Ned Schneebly

Previous username: Thug Mormons
Bio page: Ned Schneebly
Joined: Apr 16, 2016
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 5,578 (520 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Takeaway: Taysom Hill is freaking awesome.

Ham

5/9/18 4:24pm

Bold

ChiCityCoug

5/9/18 4:27pm

Nah

Cougfourlife

5/9/18 4:28pm

Please. Healthy Taysom Hill + better team + softer schedule? Fireworks.

Ham

5/9/18 4:35pm

I love TH's athleticism as much as the next guy, but I don't think that

ChiCityCoug

5/9/18 4:37pm

Yeah, that's a fair point.

Ham

5/9/18 4:44pm

Taysom could throw. Remember the Nebraska game. He was never in a good passing

TailgateU

5/22/18 7:43am

oh ye of little faith

Cougz19

5/22/18 1:30pm

Health Taysom isn’t really Taysom.

Josef K

5/9/18 10:02pm

With the receivers and o line Beck had?

youngbuck

5/9/18 4:36pm

Yes. Brown, Harline, Coats, Jacobson, Allen, the whole 2006 team.

Ham

5/9/18 4:45pm

Watching Taysom overthrow those guys when they are open deep would

deljdc

5/22/18 7:29am

I hope Taysom Hill starts in New Orleans, wins a Super Bowl or two, plays for

BleedCougarBlue2

5/9/18 5:40pm

Come on, you know he is an injury waiting to happen.

Bullrider

5/9/18 6:28pm

Beck had a better arm, Hill was better in all other areas

Croweater

5/9/18 6:02pm

Beck had a better arm, made quicker decisions, made better decisions, was more

Lance71

5/9/18 6:30pm

This is true to the degree that “Taysom had better legs. Beck was better in all other areas” is true.

mvtoro

5/9/18 8:53pm

Yes. Beck was a great QB. Taysom was a great athlete, mediocre arm.

Shore10

5/22/18 7:38am

Not really. Taysom had better legs, Beck was better in all other areas...

icecougar

5/22/18 12:24pm

That's a tough claim because we had a full year to see a healthy john

MaxxPower

5/9/18 6:19pm

I think you're forgetting how good John Beck was.

eddog

5/9/18 6:51pm

Probably true. Recency bias at work.

Ham

5/10/18 11:25am

Exactly. There's a reason he got drafted in the 2nd round.

Yunit

5/10/18 11:47am

No thanks....

wilsdad

5/9/18 8:31pm

Nah. Beck was a master in the pocket and a guru in that offense. Could make

Yunit

5/9/18 9:55pm

A healthy Beck would have gone undefeated too

2FarGone

5/9/18 11:21pm

Definitely love Taysom but he had a major flaw, not an accurate enough passer.

BlueForLife

5/9/18 11:28pm

In 2014, he completed 67% of his passes. He also averaged 107 rushing ypg and

Gorum the Old

5/10/18 8:30am

A healthy, experienced Taysom would have gone undefeated in 2007, but so would

Gorum the Old

5/10/18 8:00am

A Healthy, Expereinced Taysom would have gone undefeated in 2012, but so would

Gorum the Old

5/10/18 8:09am

Is this TIC? Healthy Riley Nelson could never replace Max or Beck in any

Yunit

5/10/18 9:06am

Not TIC. A healthy Riley is a very good college QB and BYU's 2012 Defense was

Gorum the Old

5/11/18 12:09pm

Lol you love yourself some Riley Nelson. Dude was average to below average.

Yunit

5/11/18 1:26pm

No way riley was average. He was definitely on the bottom of the other side of your spectrum

MaxxPower

5/12/18 2:54am

Statistically, he had a season that was probably top 20% of qb rating byu qb

viper

5/12/18 10:39am

Sure but name the BYU QBs that were worst than Riley. My money is that

Yunit

5/12/18 6:02pm

I could name plenty of QBs that had a worse season than Rileys best.

viper

5/14/18 10:49am

Name the QBs not named Heaps that you would start Riley over against the same

Yunit

5/14/18 1:29pm

In his prime, he was better than a lot of underclassmen QB greats

viper

5/14/18 3:05pm

It is a tragedy that we never got to see him play a full season while 100% (not

Gorum the Old

5/10/18 8:14am

Would it have changed anything in 2006 though? Beck was stellar and, IMO, was not the reason why we lost any games.

Ned Schneebly

5/22/18 9:04am

In 06 TH wouldn't have stayed healthy. Take JB.

Y4LYFE

5/22/18 9:38am

In other words, you don't understand the job of a QB

kimdaddy35

5/22/18 10:17am

I would take Joe Montana or Lebron

Unibro

5/22/18 10:52am

Nope.

D.T. Survivor

5/22/18 11:57am

A healthy Taysom???

Posting on CougarBoard