Yes.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 27, 2018
8:19:13am

Dr MoBYU All-American

Yes.

Report problem with this ad

Dr MoBYU

Previous username: MoBYU
Bio page: Dr MoBYU
Joined: Jul 22, 2001
Last login: May 17, 2024
Total posts: 16,287 (1,001 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Taysom Hill. Top ten BYU QB?

Holy Driver

5/26/18 11:33pm

Nope.

5/26/18 11:33pm

Don’t know. But I think he’s the best athlete to ever don the Y

Future_Tacos

5/26/18 11:36pm

I don't know about that

shakarocks

5/26/18 11:45pm

Hard to argue with your logic.

Future_Tacos

5/26/18 11:47pm

Don’t forget people like Ziggy Ansah

BYUCLA

5/27/18 11:29am

Pure athleticism....yes....and no one else is close....

Bonoman

5/26/18 11:51pm

Young was just as athletic if not more

PenrynCoug

5/26/18 11:55pm

Young was never the strongest lifter pound for pound like Taysom was in college and is in the NFL...

Bonoman

5/27/18 12:01am

young was a better athlete

PenrynCoug

5/27/18 12:04am

Even Young himself said Taysom was a better Athlete.

cougsrule

5/27/18 12:08am

Because he was slower and weaker?

ZooBlue

5/28/18 5:22pm

That's because Young really didn't lift a lot

shakarocks

5/27/18 12:06am

Just because you can list a lot doesn't mean you are a great athlete.

BlueForLife

5/27/18 11:54pm

You completely leave out coordination

shakarocks

5/27/18 12:09am

That’s right, Taysom can’t throw at all or play basketball or do anything else...all he can do is lift and run fast..SMH

Bonoman

5/27/18 12:34am

He didn't say that. He's basically saying Steve Young is more coordinated

Yunit

5/27/18 3:21pm

He actually struggled with throwing to a degree

shakarocks

5/27/18 9:29pm

No. Steve Young

Little Britches

5/27/18 11:50am

Carter and sheide were really good too

midlandcoug

5/26/18 11:38pm

Overlooked imo.

Heinz57

5/26/18 11:43pm

I'd put Virgil Carter in the top 10 ahead of Doman and Hill.

ptcougr

5/27/18 3:03am

Agree with this. History needs to be put in perspective. Top 10 yes.

coastcat

5/27/18 9:17am

Hard to judge. Had he stayed healthy and played a standard schedule

billyrust

5/26/18 11:44pm

Yes.

Dr MoBYU

5/27/18 8:19am

Drop Doman for Hill and you’re good.

5/27/18 8:19am

This article has a good list

Bucko

5/27/18 9:28am

Top ten talent, not top ten performance.

rockhound

5/27/18 5:36pm

How I feel too

Little Britches

5/27/18 9:00pm

I love Hill, but he is not a top ten. Never really had a great full year, never even beat Utah, no post season success

nybyblue

5/27/18 7:36pm

How about Gifford Nielson, he also started on bball team as freshman

baldcoug74

5/27/18 9:58pm

Not sure I would use "beating Utah" as a measuring stick.

Eddie

5/27/18 11:21pm

Very true. Even when Gifford was QB we were beating Utah consistently.

Holy Driver

5/28/18 6:27am

If Taysom makes it in the NFL as some are now anticipating, he will be remembered differently.

mvtoro

5/28/18 2:57am

Hill>>Fetrrick or Walsh

Reedme

5/28/18 7:18am

Taysom is at the top of the "what if" list. He could have challenged for the

Fdnman

5/28/18 8:31am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad