with better players around him. To me they are a wash. Tatum is close to Klay. Hooward, if having a similar season to his last year in Utah is a level below KD, but not by a lot. I think Horford does better with DG than any Cav has. Brown is better than anyone left on the GS roster, so could be a good wild card for them. I think they match up well to be honest. 

To answer your question, I would take Kyrie over Klay and wouldn't be that mad with taking him over Steph. Harward over Klay isn't a stretch either. KD is the unicorn that really couldn't be replaced.