Isn't that the guy people wanted benched in 2016 for the backup that is now the

Report problem with this ad

Aug 21, 2018
10:54:18am

DrKennethNoisewater All-American

potential starter that people want (and even wanted last year) benched for the potential back up?

Report problem with this ad

DrKennethNoisewater

Previous username: Andy Stitzer
New username: DKN
Bio page: DrKennethNoisewater
Joined: Nov 25, 2006
Last login: May 7, 2019
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

My promise to CB. Tanner vs. Wilson

Adrielle Stable Genius

8/21/18 10:44am

Team Wilson, Unite!

HingleMcCringleberry

8/21/18 10:45am

If Tanner sucks early, he's done. And if Wilson sucks, ride it out.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:46am

If it's a tie, shouldn't youth win out?

Mr. Scoobs

8/21/18 10:48am

Loki says, "I consider 'experience' experience", but I'm with Thanos on this..

HingleMcCringleberry

8/21/18 10:51am

RE: Loki says, "I consider 'experience' experience", but I'm with Thanos on

Cougarrr

8/21/18 10:54am

If it's a tie in practice, logic would seem to dictate that the guy with the experience is who you go with

Adrielle

8/21/18 10:51am

Sure, if you don't care about the future.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:53am

There is a very strong argument that if you start Wilson with this early schedule that includes two

Adrielle

8/21/18 10:56am

If he's that weak, bench him. I don't want him around.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:59am

You clearly have never coached football. Bringing guys along slowly is a practice that

Adrielle

8/21/18 11:18am

It's certainly a practice, it's not the only practice.

HingleMcCringleberry

8/21/18 11:24am

I think he's more like Max Hall than Jake Heaps

icecougar

8/21/18 3:48pm

I hope so. And I have no personal knowledge of his mental toughness

Adrielle

8/21/18 6:06pm

I agree with this - bad idea to start a promising freshman against a schedule

MajorPain

8/21/18 7:04pm

The future is sometime in the future. I want BYU to win today.

ptcougr

8/21/18 5:45pm

If the experience guy isn't better, you'd have to think w/experience youth

Mr. Scoobs

8/21/18 10:55am

Here is the real question for me.

PJMort

8/21/18 11:01am

That's cool and stuff. It doesn't matter who the coaches pick, the fans will

DrKennethNoisewater

8/21/18 10:48am

No? If the starting QB is awesome, no one will call for his backup.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:49am

That hasn't happened since 2009.

DrKennethNoisewater

8/21/18 10:49am

Right....

rggee

8/21/18 10:50am

Truth. No one called for Max's backups. Since then, it's been open season.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:50am

Uh huh

rggee

8/21/18 10:51am

Let's not pretend Taysom's job was secure his entire career. Dude had some

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:52am

When were people calling for his backups?? I must have missed it.

rggee

8/21/18 10:54am

I guess 2016 under Detmer. Other than that he was the man.

rggee

8/21/18 10:54am

Yeah that time he recording a sparkling QBR of 38.7 vs Utah in 2013 was amazing.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:58am

Didn't max?

rggee

8/21/18 11:07am

He sure did.

SandYFan

8/21/18 11:09am

Sadly that terrible game was still higher than Magnum's last year average

Mr. Scoobs

8/21/18 11:13am

An amazing lack of great quarterbacking for BYU the last decade.

SandYFan

8/21/18 11:14am

Isn't that the guy people wanted benched in 2016 for the backup that is now the

DrKennethNoisewater

8/21/18 10:54am

Correct.

SandYFan

8/21/18 10:54am

True, the 2016 Detmer year. The other 4, not the case.

rggee

8/21/18 10:55am

There were calls for Stewart after the 2014 Spring game into the summer

Coop

8/21/18 10:56am

Turns out when you go from top 30 QB as freshman to the bottom 30 as a JR

Mr. Scoobs

8/21/18 11:00am

You say this as if nothing else changed except Tanner went from freshman to jr

MajorPain

8/21/18 7:13pm

Sarkesian was nothing his first year - fortunately, coaches stayed with him and

MajorPain

8/21/18 7:08pm

I’m still struggling with KS but am 100% behind this team. I’m working on being more supportive of KS but I’m pretty

Refugee

8/21/18 10:49am

I'm in the "I hope both get game reps" camp

Coop

8/21/18 10:51am

I am 100% committed to second guessing the coaches

mudpupper

8/21/18 11:12am

3 games seems mean.

displacedute

8/21/18 11:15am

the only thing...is that if its Tanner who starts the year, and he bombs you get Wilson in for the McNeese Game t

Adrielle

8/21/18 11:21am

RE: the only thing...is that if its Tanner who starts the year, and he bombs you

libertycoug

8/21/18 11:48am

If either's confidence is shot by being pulled, then I want the other.

QBarrister

8/21/18 11:20am

That's why I laugh about posters questioning position changes...

Alister Mackenzie

8/21/18 11:26am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

8/21/18 12:15pm

I'm glad you're not the coach

Adrielle

8/21/18 12:21pm

You’re totally right cuz it’s not like Nick Saban switched quarterbacks at

TBirdCougar

8/21/18 2:54pm

And for every story like yours there are many more where the backup is worse than

Adrielle

8/21/18 3:31pm

If you starter is not working why would you not try your backup?

TBirdCougar

8/21/18 4:33pm

Always amazes me that people seem to disregard that development occurs during

MajorPain

8/21/18 7:19pm

<< Deleted >>

East1999

8/21/18 9:00pm

Just win baby. Whoever can do that.

cougarnw

8/21/18 4:43pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad