You're saying that our coaches made a bad decision based on fear?

Report problem with this ad

Sep 19, 2018
11:18:50am

panguitch All-American

Just checking.

Report problem with this ad

panguitch

Bio page: panguitch
Joined: Aug 22, 2014
Last login: Oct 2, 2023
Total posts: 2,929 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Imagine a world where Wisconsin hits that FG.

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 10:17am

No.

jdub

9/19/18 10:18am

Wisconsin makes the field goal, but that doesn't give them the win. An O/T win

spoxjox

9/19/18 10:18am

In that imaginary world, Tanner could have thrown the winning TD pass ...

BluesBrother

9/19/18 10:19am

BYU already "benched" several players between the Cal and Wisconsin games

Indy Coug

9/19/18 10:19am

If we are imagining, then I am imagining that we also beat Cal

Carnac

9/19/18 10:19am

Tanner would then end the game with 4 -5 TDs

Mr. Scoobs

9/19/18 10:20am

Imagine a world where Holker actually makes that catch and we aren't even

P-Boy Squad

9/19/18 10:25am

If Holker caught that pass I still pass on Mangum.

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 10:29am

I guess if you can prove to me that Wilson, Hall, or Cirtchlow

P-Boy Squad

9/19/18 11:32am

Replied to wrong person, sorry

CougarVeteran

9/19/18 11:54am

Imagine Wilson replaced Mangum in the Wisconsin game

CougarVeteran

9/19/18 11:56am

This is what would have happened

Blue2thebone

9/19/18 2:09pm

I thought he meant Marc Wilson, and as a certified Marc Wilson Fan Club member,

spoxjox

9/19/18 2:14pm

I think that actually means that your opinion of him is set, despite how he play

fattycoug

9/19/18 1:26pm

It is called the last 14 games where Bushman ran the route. I know he was

thecthdox

9/19/18 12:02pm

Can't compare us to Bama. If we had Tagovailoa, he'd be starting right now.

Josef K

9/19/18 10:26am

Not a sure thing, It would depend on how he reads the jet sweep

USMCdad

9/19/18 10:35am

If the defense played worse, we'd want Tanner's head right now.

mudpupper

9/19/18 10:26am

Exactly.

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 10:30am

We'd want Tanner's head for the O not putting up more than 24 on WISCONSIN?

GOR

9/19/18 11:26am

Remind me how much we scored against Wisconsin last year?

panguitch

9/19/18 11:36am

6 last year. 24 this year. I'll take it.

GOR

9/19/18 12:28pm

We have 2 wins. Just stick with TM for now

Y4LYFE

9/19/18 10:26am

In that world...

BigYfan

9/19/18 10:26am

Instead of re-typing, let me just put this here...

Eddie

9/19/18 10:30am

Go back and watch the game. Tanner won that

Cougar Rage

9/19/18 10:32am

Don't want him benched, but he also had an open guy at the sticks on that play

fulano

9/19/18 10:34am

on the wide side of the field...going away...with a defender playing it short...

MormonThug

9/19/18 11:02am

*in front of the sticks. Likely would have been 4th anyway. High risk/low reward

SUAVO

9/19/18 11:28am

Orrrr maybe a better QB actually completes a pass there for a first down.

SandYFan

9/19/18 10:38am

Orrr a young quarter back throws a pick six. If we were down, Tanner tries to

Cougar Rage

9/19/18 10:48am

Yes hooray our SENIOR QB outperformed a hypothetical 18 year old

SandYFan

9/19/18 10:50am

Glad you are a "backups are always better" kind of guy

SUAVO

9/19/18 11:31am

I'm not, and there's no way you logically got that from my post.

SandYFan

9/19/18 12:12pm

I actually thought he panicked and threw it away to quickly

Hang10

9/19/18 11:27am

I was actually pleased that he DID throw some of those away.

Eddie

9/19/18 11:36am

Too often Wisconsin had our pass plays read and had Tanner rapidly backpedaling

jre85

9/19/18 11:46am

Yep, same. Though he missed wide open back couple times.

MatthiasG

9/19/18 3:01pm

There was a great backup available with different skills for Alabama

Belboz

9/19/18 10:35am

LOL. BYU just upset the #6 team in the nation and you want to bench the QB?!

FrankenCoug

9/19/18 10:37am

Yeah I am not superstitious. Just because we won doesn't mean he played well.

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 10:45am

I think that is the WHOLE POINT, isn't it?

Eddie

9/19/18 11:00am

This kind of thing is such a waste of time...

Refugee

9/19/18 10:38am

A couple times he threw the ball away instead of taking a sack. Secured the FG!

Mr. Scoobs

9/19/18 10:44am

Runs were working

I'mBatman

9/19/18 11:06am

You're saying that our coaches made a bad decision based on fear?

panguitch

9/19/18 11:18am

Imagine a world where the average football knowledge level on CB was above

Six Foot Seven

9/19/18 11:32am

It would be if you got off

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 11:56am

RE: It would be if you got off

Six Foot Seven

9/19/18 12:03pm

Calling yourself names won't solve anything.

SLC-Warrior

9/19/18 12:09pm

Wait. You're going with the "I know you are, but what am I" defense?

Eddie

9/19/18 12:51pm

RE: It would be if you got off

GOR

9/19/18 12:29pm

What makes you think our coaches are keeping Tanner as

1CougFan

9/19/18 11:47am

Imagine a world where Columbus doesn't discover America

MajorZeus

9/19/18 1:16pm

...where the whole rainbow of humanity lives in perfect harmony and peace...

spoxjox

9/19/18 2:15pm

RE: Imagine a world where Wisconsin hits that FG.

m0resn0w

9/20/18 3:02pm

I don’t have to bc they didn’t

BYU Grounds

9/21/18 12:01pm

Technically 12 more points, but we get it.

Posting on CougarBoard