He has too many head scratching losses year after year to be in the top 10. He is a quality coach, yes, but every year he has 1-2 losses that are just not acceptable to be in the top 10.

But yes as a BYU fan I would like to have, P5 money, P5 access, and P5 players all across the board. I feel BYU has some P5 level talent, the difference is depth and at all positions. And yes I would like better coaching, but I personally would pas on Whit. But that is me and my opinion. But would I like a better coach than what we currently have, yes.