I thought LOTR did a pretty good job of following the books. I did have some things that bugged me, especially

Report problem with this ad

Jan 14, 2019
9:15:03pm

jdub FORMER USER

...the Faramir stuff. They screwed that up. That was my main complaint, but I really loved it other than that.

Report problem with this ad

jdub

Bio page: jdub
Joined: May 13, 2004
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 76,534 (17,177 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Been rewatching the Lord of the Rings trilogy

JohnnyComeLately Make The Rez Great Again

1/14/19 8:46pm

Best trilogy ever, right above the Nolan Batman trilogy

cougarnerd

1/14/19 8:48pm

Oh, so you count Star Wars as a series of six. Interesting.

All-American

1/14/19 8:49pm

RE: Best trilogy ever, right above the Nolan Batman trilogy

messi

1/14/19 8:53pm

RE: Best trilogy ever, right above the Nolan Batman trilogy

WhiteKnight

1/15/19 2:57pm

Agreed. I'd put IV V and VI of Star Wars on equal footing with The Nolan Trilogy

Adrielle

1/15/19 3:13pm

I'm a huge fan of fantasy fiction but have never made it through one of those movies without falling asleep

Slim

1/14/19 8:52pm

I've rewatched those many times. Such well done movies.

jdub

1/14/19 8:53pm

Never seen them. Don’t plan to.

Mr. Belding

1/14/19 9:05pm

RE: Never seen them. Don’t plan to.

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 9:28pm

The reason why they look so awesome is because they try to limit the amount of

trom2foot3

1/15/19 4:32pm

Why. Just curious. It’s clean, great story, good acting. One of the best

Traveshamockery

1/14/19 9:46pm

I don’t like almost all fantasy stuff. Just can’t stand it.

Mr. Belding

1/14/19 10:12pm

I thought you were a big Game of Thrones fan?

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 10:13pm

Fair enough.

Traveshamockery

1/14/19 10:14pm

It’s unfortunate they strayed from the books in so many places

kmcougar

1/14/19 9:07pm

I thought LOTR did a pretty good job of following the books. I did have some things that bugged me, especially

jdub

1/14/19 9:15pm

Ah one, other one I didn't like was Aragorn wavering on Arwen. That bugged me too.

jdub

1/14/19 9:22pm

The books are great, but this scene was one of my favorite all time movie moments.

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 9:33pm

Absolutely, it's a fantastic scene.

jdub

1/14/19 9:36pm

Just rewatched it in your post....soooooooo good

gaspasscoug

1/14/19 9:43pm

Seriously, the most epic movie theater experience ever with each of the three

cougarnerd

1/14/19 9:55pm

For some reason this is the most memorable scene to me

Bob Vance

1/14/19 10:26pm

Haha, "I guess that concludes negotiations"

Breaded Hamster

1/14/19 10:53pm

That scene I believe was only in the extended cut and was not shown in theaters.

VACOUGFAN

1/14/19 11:05pm

Too bad though. I would have liked to have heard more taunting from the mouth. Was one of the more

Bob Vance

1/15/19 2:38pm

I’d have liked to have seen them try to include the Tom Bombadil....

CoachSpeak

1/14/19 9:57pm

Yeah, I like Tom Bombadil, but that is such a non sequitur for the story.

jdub

1/14/19 10:02pm

Funny how great the LotR was by cutting the fat.

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 10:06pm

The Tolkien edit of the Hobbit is much better

KingDave

1/14/19 10:15pm

The movies are better than the books IMO

Dissenter

1/15/19 6:53am

I've just been thinking it's about time to watch them again 🙂

Breaded Hamster

1/14/19 9:34pm

I’ve been reading my kids The Hobbit and they wanted to watch that trilogy.

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 9:36pm

That's a great idea to read The Hobbit to the kids. My wife is doing the whole

Breaded Hamster

1/14/19 9:40pm

I finished the Great Brain series with them before starting the Hobbit.

JohnnyComeLately

1/14/19 9:42pm

I’d read the Narnia books with them before Harry Potter...

CoachSpeak

1/14/19 10:14pm

Great Brain series is classic

Gustav

1/15/19 3:01pm

Such a great trilogy. The Hobbit debacle was terrible.

Boanerges

1/14/19 10:07pm

I just finished them too

Borg

1/15/19 12:06am

Just finished Fellowship again...The whole part in the Mines of Moria was just stunning...

Posting on CougarBoard