It was the “at the same time” that got me

Feb 15, 2019
1:50:48pm

USMCdad All-American

I kept thinking same time of day at the exact same spot it was very unlikely. Surprising so many people didn’t think it through and settled on the simple answer

Report problem with this ad

USMCdad

Previous username: mosterlow
Bio page: USMCdad
Joined: Jun 23, 2009
Last login: Jan 4, 2023
Total posts: 30,839 (8,222 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It's shocking to me that a high majority failed this question

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 1:35pm

What's the correct answer?

IceBlueCoug

2/15/19 1:38pm

100%

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 1:41pm

They’d meet at the mid point at the exact same time

IceBlueCoug

2/15/19 1:47pm

Not necessarily at the midpoint, but it is 100% that there will be a spot where she is at the same time each day

cheezedawg

2/15/19 1:49pm

I don't care where they meet, nor what time. All I know is that it is guaranteed

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 1:51pm

Anything that is not mechanical, with repeatable precision

Borg

2/15/19 4:17pm

It will happen every time, without fail.

spoxjox

2/15/19 4:26pm

The image that works for me is thinking of two beads on a single string. Place one bead at each end of the string and

Cosmodiar

2/15/19 4:34pm

Dread Pirate Westley

2/15/19 1:44pm

It's a semantics disagreement. Some people are reading it as "pick any place

swimbro

2/15/19 1:38pm

Could be, but that's not what was asked.

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 1:44pm

That's exactly what was asked.

Dread Pirate Westley

2/15/19 1:51pm

The question does NOT ask you to pick a point.

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 1:53pm

once they intersect then they're at the same point and time

The Shazad

2/15/19 1:54pm

RE: once they intersect then they're at the same point and time

swimbro

2/15/19 2:03pm

Do they intersect at the same point and at the same time on consecutive days?

Dread Pirate Westley

2/15/19 2:13pm

try this:

The Shazad

2/15/19 2:26pm

<< Deleted >>

MMCougIII

2/15/19 6:54pm

velocity is a function of the first two variables, and is irrelevant

The Shazad

2/15/19 7:17pm

Sunrise sunset exact times don’t matter

YIsForBrigham

2/15/19 2:28pm

I agree with this.

BYUNITED

2/15/19 2:12pm

Question below

swimbro

2/15/19 1:55pm

I get what you're saying, but the question asked for the probability of some

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 2:00pm

That's obviously not what the question is asking though

YIsForBrigham

2/15/19 2:03pm

How precise are we meant to be with the time?

Philosoraptor

2/15/19 1:48pm

Oh. Never mind. I was just reading the responses. Now I get it.

Philosoraptor

2/15/19 1:52pm

CB and critical thinking aren't always best friends.

Kauai

2/15/19 1:49pm

It was the “at the same time” that got me

USMCdad

2/15/19 1:50pm

It comes down to how you interpret "same time"

CougarBlue08

2/15/19 2:03pm

Nope, the first option is still 100%

Left Shark Coug

2/15/19 2:06pm

Yep, it finally clicked.. overthinking strikes again

CougarBlue08

2/15/19 2:11pm

The answer as so eloquently posed via a question,

blau56

2/15/19 2:24pm

RE: It comes down to how you interpret "same time"

swimbro

2/15/19 2:09pm

I'm reading the question as: If there's a rock on the side of the path, what's

jaredm

2/15/19 2:24pm

For any given rock? Highly unlikely. That there will be 1 rock this holds. 100%

Warner

2/15/19 2:34pm

100% certainty is wrong.

Tare

2/15/19 2:13pm

Nope. It's 100%.

shimmy

2/15/19 2:21pm

No, it's 100%

whirl

2/15/19 2:30pm

What's fascinating is that the example given for the correct answer is

Troy McClure

2/15/19 2:24pm

That's because it's an example and not the exact scenario

Jericho

2/15/19 2:38pm

Yep. But still funny that in order to prove the true answer the example has

Troy McClure

2/15/19 2:45pm

Doesn't require an impossible scenario. The same example could be used

Jericho

2/15/19 3:02pm

Yep, we're LDS. We believe in proxies! Someone can be the nun's proxy.

Breaded Hamster

2/15/19 4:56pm

<< Deleted >>

Posting on CougarBoard