A crappy steak or a poorly cooked steak is far worse

May 21, 2019
12:03:47pm

kotacoug All-American

Than crappy pizza or pasta or Asian/Mexican dishes, a good quality steak is hard to beat but it’s right up there with other cuisine. So though I don’t really agree that steak is overrated.... crappy steak is pretty bad.

Report problem with this ad

kotacoug

Bio page: kotacoug
Joined: Jul 20, 2002
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 80,591 (4,682 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Steak is overrated. There are just much better ways to spend your money on food.

scooter7

5/21/19 11:45am

I would rather eat steak than sushi, quality produce, eggs, herbs or spices.

chago04

5/21/19 11:46am

You just said Sushi was better than steak. Please dont procreate.

monkeycowboy

5/21/19 11:46am

Obviously not a concern if those are his opinions

Odysseus

5/21/19 11:48am

I love steak. but yeah, sushi is better than steak. No contest

Dissenter

5/22/19 3:58pm

Clearly you’ve never been to Outback.

garyfan

5/21/19 11:48am

Or Applebees

SJS

5/21/19 11:50am

Or IHOP

deejo

5/21/19 11:51am

Actually sounds like he has been to Applebees

braddahmike

5/21/19 1:04pm

The bloomin’ onion, right?!

HansMoleman

5/21/19 11:58am

Outback is honestly pretty good.

Jay Rick

5/21/19 12:03pm

RE: Outback is honestly pretty good.

Dillinger

5/21/19 12:04pm

I’m a foodie, but not a food snob. And I have a great love for these sorts of

Jay Rick

5/21/19 12:23pm

You're wrong. It used to be. It's basically Sizzler now

fattycoug

5/22/19 10:10am

I love the Sizz!

Jay Rick

5/22/19 10:17am

And this explains your opinion of Outback

fattycoug

5/22/19 4:04pm

I’ll admit that my love of the sizz is somewhat in jest.

Jay Rick

5/22/19 4:13pm

One time at Outback, I ordered a steak and a guy at the next table over ate part of it when I wasn’t watching. I

CDV

5/21/19 12:03pm

How did you not know someone was eating food off your plate?

Cougarclaw

5/21/19 12:06pm

I think because he was a big guy and needed more than the food he ordered, so he took some of mine.

CDV

5/21/19 12:07pm

You are lucky no one filmed you calling out the big guy stealing your food, you

ChiCityCoug

5/21/19 12:09pm

Probably a good point

CDV

5/21/19 12:10pm

Anyone, outside my wife, who tried to touch food on my plate runs the risk of

ManicBlue

5/21/19 1:03pm

Haha. That's good. In situations like this I bet you are protected by

garyfan

5/21/19 1:58pm

I love all kinds of different foods, but it’s hard to beat a good steak.

cheezedawg

5/21/19 11:50am

RE: Steak is overrated. There are just much better ways to spend your money on food.

IceBlueCoug

5/21/19 11:53am

Growing up I thought steak was terrible

stoils

5/21/19 11:53am

I will acknowledge this - many steaks are not cooked well

kccougar

5/21/19 11:55am

Yeah- all steaks are not equal, totally agree. But even really great steaks

scooter7

5/21/19 11:58am

Which top-notch steak houses?

kccougar

5/21/19 12:01pm

Ya I need to have a reference here

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:04pm

Dominic’s filet in Scottsdale

stoils

5/21/19 12:08pm

Charlie Palmer (DC) The Benjamin (NYC) Barclay Prime (Philly) The Palm (bunch

scooter7

5/21/19 12:08pm

^ Orders them well done.

kccougar

5/21/19 12:18pm

"run it through a warm kitchen" is my standard order

scooter7

5/21/19 12:20pm

And there it is.

kccougar

5/21/19 12:23pm

Explain? Rare is the only way to order at a good steakhouse.

scooter7

5/21/19 12:25pm

From your original post I assume you appreciate subltelty of taste and variety of flavor

kccougar

5/21/19 12:40pm

Agree. A New York strip is nice rare and done Chicago style. A ribeye needs

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:47pm

Oh boy. Can't imagine the difference between rare and med rare are significant

scooter7

5/21/19 12:57pm

Like I said, there it is. The fact that you can't identify the difference between rare and medium rare explains much

kccougar

5/21/19 1:16pm

I'm getting a kick out of your steak snobbishness- like it's still the 80s. Not

scooter7

5/21/19 1:24pm

What does the year have to do with it?

kccougar

5/21/19 1:34pm

Touche. Elks club- that is pretty good.

scooter7

5/21/19 1:38pm

There is no hope for you.

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:20pm

That’s crazy. Have an A5 ribcap and return and report.

shimmy

5/21/19 12:03pm

I’ve never had A5- I want to though.

cheezedawg

5/21/19 12:04pm

I have once. It delivered. I’ve had A3 a couple times and it was great, although I prefer a nice bone in ribeye over

shimmy

5/21/19 12:08pm

A few months ago I was looking at some online places to order A5. I'll probably do it this summer sometime

cheezedawg

5/21/19 12:26pm

Well said. Agree.

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:04pm

I feel sorry that you’ve apparently never had a great steak.

neboutefan

5/21/19 11:57am

I think I have- but where would you get one?

scooter7

5/21/19 11:59am

A steak from Sizzler > any sushi from anywhere

IceBlueCoug

5/21/19 12:01pm

I’ve had steak from some good steakhouses, but the best steak I’ve had is made right at home

cheezedawg

5/21/19 12:02pm

This. If you know what you are doing and what you like, the steak you cook for

svenot

5/21/19 12:15pm

The better question is if you think you have,,,where do you think have?

RockyBalboa

5/21/19 12:07pm

See above

scooter7

5/21/19 12:14pm

A $23/pound Snake River Farms Wagyu New York Strip steak reversed seared on my

Chadillac

5/21/19 12:16pm

Do they deliver them fresh or frozen?

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:20pm

If you buy online they'll ship it to you frozen.

Chadillac

5/21/19 12:27pm

Someone is kidding you. New York isn’t in the same league as Rib Eye for taste.

Bullrider

5/21/19 1:43pm

Can order online...

Heinz57

5/21/19 1:54pm

where to travel for top-notch eggs? TIA

korihor

5/21/19 12:02pm

My backyard.

cheezedawg

5/21/19 12:02pm

I'm jealous- would love to have my own chickens

scooter7

5/21/19 12:23pm

Funny- can make a big difference though.

scooter7

5/21/19 12:11pm

A crappy steak or a poorly cooked steak is far worse

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:03pm

Love a great steak, but I also agree with you. Most of the time, I’d choose

Jay Rick

5/21/19 12:05pm

RE: Love a great steak, but I also agree with you. Most of the time, I’d choose

monkeycowboy

5/21/19 12:10pm

I love steak but also quality sushi is pretty dang awesome. It just depends

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:19pm

See that’s the thing. In my mind, there’s a tie for best. Great dishes

Jay Rick

5/21/19 12:22pm

Good point. It's just if I rated the 10 best meals of my life, none included a

scooter7

5/21/19 12:31pm

Good call on the tacos! We ate at some of the best restaurants in Mexico City

scooter7

5/21/19 12:29pm

We’ve got a place down the road from us that I’m addicted to.

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:43pm

Churros!

scooter7

5/21/19 1:04pm

Actually, I’d put a good Indian dish above both…

Jay Rick

5/21/19 12:20pm

Steak is delicious. So is sushi. Why make a man choose?

durandal

5/21/19 12:10pm

Come to Chicago and see if that changes your mind.

ChiCityCoug

5/21/19 12:10pm

You get what you pay for, something from Texas Roadhouse is not good, a Mortons

RC Vikings

5/21/19 12:18pm

I rarely order steak at a restaurant unless I know they make

bag

5/21/19 12:20pm

I won't believe this until a high net worth individual like stoils chimes in.

crazY

5/21/19 12:24pm

You're right. Prime rib is better.

coolblue

5/21/19 12:25pm

I believe steak is overrated but you seriously underrate it. Eggs and sushi are

IceCreamButt

5/21/19 12:26pm

the seasoned tri tip at costco is amazing. If cooked just right it tastes as

buckeyecougarguy

5/21/19 12:27pm

How do you make it?

Adwight

5/21/19 12:37pm

Sous vide/reverse sear w clarified butter FTW

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:44pm

i've grilled it and baked it before. My grill kind of sucks so i've had mixed

buckeyecougarguy

5/21/19 2:14pm

There is nothing better eating than some great fish.

Idahofallsblue

5/21/19 12:34pm

Freaking Fish tacos from The Fish Market in Kaanapali are worth the

kotacoug

5/21/19 12:45pm

I prefer a nice thick seared Tuna Steak to a beef steak.

BYUtka

5/21/19 1:01pm

RE: I prefer a nice thick seared Tuna Steak to a beef steak.

Vincent's Picks

5/21/19 1:03pm

?????? I have a message for you.....

BYU Grounds

5/21/19 12:37pm

You'd rather spend your money on herbs and spices than steak? Weird.

LaVellIfIKnow

5/21/19 12:57pm

Not all sushi is rolled the same.

ManicBlue

5/21/19 1:06pm

What is your favorite protein to cook and/or eat.

Heinz57

5/21/19 1:35pm

Are you 67 with high cholesterol?

BlackBart

5/21/19 2:17pm

This is an awful take. Even the inventors of sushi disagree with you

Cheesy Gordita

5/22/19 9:23am

You could convince me but then you threw in eggs and I immediately dismiss your

Posting on CougarBoard