You cited an article from a source called “Go Joe Bruin” and the other is a

Aug 18, 2019
7:18:59am

mannheimadler All-American

Columnist (Gordon Monson) who is known to go out of his way to stir things up on BYU, Utah or the Jazz.

I’m not sure either of those are the most compelling sources.

Report problem with this ad

mannheimadler

Previous username: TomZarek
Bio page: mannheimadler
Joined: Aug 27, 2009
Last login: May 21, 2024
Total posts: 14,649 (351 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A new yewt friend

Cdun101

8/18/19 6:27am

He’s wrong. No such data on BYU being dirty. He’s a homer

PortlandBlue

8/18/19 6:32am

Stats show Utah is among the most penalized for things like personal fouls.

soupie

8/18/19 6:41am

This. Stats prove UTAH is dirtier than BYU even before Kalani

Cougar76

8/18/19 6:55am

And that was before they led the country in targeting as well

Gustav

8/18/19 10:58am

Some articles

Solomon Levi

8/18/19 6:50am

You cited an article from a source called “Go Joe Bruin” and the other is a

mannheimadler

8/18/19 7:18am

Also, on closer examination, the Fox Sports article is also written by Go Joe

mannheimadler

8/18/19 7:22am

We’re not talking about third party academic review here

Solomon Levi

8/18/19 7:25am

And if you read comments by other pac 12 team fans they say the same about Utah

cougarmanguy

8/18/19 7:29am

Totally agree, and that was what I said in my initial paragraph

Solomon Levi

8/18/19 7:31am

Look, I’ve publicly defended the Salt Lake Tribune on here (mostly Drew), but

mannheimadler

8/18/19 7:31am

All I am showing is non-utah perception

Solomon Levi

8/18/19 7:33am

Showing something besides Utah in the most Utah way possible. Lol

ColdFusion1989

8/18/19 7:52am

So written by a fan of an upcoming opponent (at the time) looking to try to stir

BYUFam1

8/18/19 8:32am

Probably left over from when BYU beat them into

AF Cougar

8/18/19 7:47am

The data

JmThms

8/18/19 7:22am

How dare you use unbiased data to totally undercut biased opinions.

BlueBlood94

8/18/19 10:13am

Another one

LevZloi

8/18/19 11:28am

Err...summary?

Preppy

8/18/19 12:06pm

Utah-BYU listed as one of cfb’s dirtiest rivalries measured by occurrence of

Discrete Metric

8/18/19 2:45pm

Well said

truecougster

8/18/19 12:03pm

Didn’t happen. It’s not a thing

YIsForBrigham

8/18/19 7:00am

Please tell him that if he doesn’t start nothin’, won’t be nothin’.

Hambone

8/18/19 7:09am

The whole thing was contrived by some Utah fans looking to

cougarmanguy

8/18/19 7:19am

This article shows yewtah to be the 8th dirtiest in the country!

JmThms

8/18/19 7:19am

You don’t have to hate the Utes to want them to lose every game.

Traveshamockery

8/18/19 8:06am

Don’t have to, but happy to do it anyway. Willing to go the extra mile on this

Hambone

8/18/19 8:23am

There was a segment on PTI that talked about how dirty we were.

Cougzilla

8/18/19 8:23am

Any yewt that claims they hated BYU until Kalani got there is one of the lamest

Preppy

8/18/19 8:25am

I’m in the second category.

lilpenny

8/18/19 12:54pm

I'm. Not interested in a conversation with a yewt about Bronco being a terrible

Preppy

8/18/19 1:33pm

Games are ending at 2-3 am? Say what?

LiveCoug

8/18/19 8:27am

Kentucky...it's an island in the Atlantic ocean.

Preppy

8/18/19 8:33am

it's all perception. A nut punch and a brawl is perceived worse than 10 helmet to helmets.

BlueFrog

8/18/19 8:31am

^^^This. Refuting "dirty" with data on personal fouls and penalties is sort

kos

8/18/19 5:25pm

I’ve had a lot of interactions like that through the years

Heath Squashwell

8/18/19 8:32am

RE: I’ve had a lot of interactions like that through the years

displacedute

8/18/19 9:15am

That’s pretty pathetic.

CrimsonCardinal

8/18/19 4:18pm

Wow.

kos

8/18/19 5:26pm

It’s not news when Utah plays dirty, since that’s been their MO for years.

Nogi-oshi

8/18/19 9:06am

One thing I noticed in the Bronco years before Kalani got there

Medute

8/18/19 9:24am

your second paragraph is right on. two isolated incidents by two young men

yahtzee

8/18/19 11:37am

RE: A new yewt friend

Daveyjay019

8/18/19 9:25am

Yes. You are wrong.

BYUtka

8/18/19 9:58am

RE: Yes. You are wrong.

Daveyjay019

9/8/19 7:52pm

I see a difference between Bronco teams and Sitake teams. Bronco seemed to

ALUF 1990

8/18/19 9:34am

"head shots, alligator leg rolls" sounds like you are describing Utah, not BYU.

BYUtka

8/18/19 9:57am

Steve Tate was Mr trash talk alligator roll

Cougar76

8/18/19 1:55pm

Whittingham literally ran up the score on Wyoming for having the temerity to

Gustav

8/18/19 11:00am

Wyoming fans don’t even remember this

CrimsonCardinal

8/18/19 9:08pm

I'll bet they remember. But, maybe they washed the pain away with alcohol

Preppy

8/20/19 1:12pm

RE: Whittingham literally ran up the score on Wyoming for having the temerity to

Daveyjay019

9/8/19 7:49pm

Agree with most of what you said, except the part about Whitt. That's fantasy.

SouthernCoug

8/18/19 11:33am

You see what you want to see because Kalani was a Ute

demon_llama

8/18/19 2:52pm

He's probably referring to this PTI segment.

rggee

8/18/19 11:59am

You lost me with you want Utah to do well. And I don't think I'm extremist.

ochobeeguy

8/18/19 12:09pm

People love the "BYU, the choir boys, are actually dirty" narrative

Resurgens

8/18/19 12:24pm

RE: People love the "BYU, the choir boys, are actually dirty" narrative

Gustav

8/18/19 1:02pm

Exactly.

Resurgens

8/18/19 1:05pm

Side note: hopefully you dont "unfriend" him because he's a Ute fan.

Machiavelli

8/18/19 2:40pm

Butler-bird cheap shot on Linehan was the dirtiest play in the rivalry since

Cougar76

8/18/19 3:33pm

My condolences for living in Kentucky.

ugo1st

8/18/19 10:03pm

RE: A new yewt friend

longtimeYfan

8/18/19 10:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad