But it's probably too early to tell.

He's 4-3 as a starter. And I will probably get flamed for this, but which BYU QB on the roster wouldn't be 4-3 in the same games?

I'm not saying anyone would have outperformed him in the Bowl game or against Utah(for which I think he played very well and with some extra motivation).

I'm still waiting to see how he does against tougher opponents etc. The kid is good no question. How good is yet to be seen.

Fans are excited because Huntley is also, like Wilson, very athletic and can use his legs to make plays. He's also experienced and can escape pressure, throw on the run etc. Doesn't mean he's the best, but he's still a good QB.