In this scenario, I am giving Utah a hypothetical CCG win over Oregon

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 13, 2019
3:40:17pm

Medute All-American

In this scenario, I am giving Utah a hypothetical CCG win over Oregon

Winning your conference, beating a top 5 team, playing 10 P5 games, 1 loss on the road without their star RB, beating opponents handily while ranking so highly in offensive and defensive statistics is more impressive than Alabama’s resume. This assumes they beat Oregon.

Report problem with this ad

Medute

Bio page: Medute
Joined: Jun 29, 2010
Last login: May 8, 2024
Total posts: 17,560 (1,113 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Who gets the final playoff spot? Alabama vs Utah

BYU Fan

11/13/19 9:47am

After listening to those ESPN guys during the USU/BYU game, it's gotta be Bama.

Eddie

11/13/19 9:51am

Agreed but USC is not a nobody - they may not be great but they aren't a nobody

BYU Fan

11/13/19 9:52am

Unranked = "nobody". USC's name recognition won't help Utah.

Eddie

11/13/19 9:55am

If USC, Wash and BYU win out 2 of them will be ranked.

Gathers

11/13/19 10:07am

I don't see how either UW or USC get ranked, let alone both....or BYU

Doogal McCougar

11/13/19 10:23am

And yet NONE of those three will be as highly ranked as LSU.

Eddie

11/13/19 1:53pm

How is this even a question? At that point, Alabama will have beaten Auburn on

Byron McNertney

11/13/19 10:06am

Not to mention Utah has had one of the weakest schedules in the Pac-12. SOS will drag Utah down.

BlueBlood94

11/13/19 10:23am

1 win vs a ranked team and should have lost by double digits at home

Medute

11/13/19 10:37am

The "eye test" is why Utah is above Minnesota right now

BYU Fan

11/13/19 10:40am

Minnesota is still being punished for squeaking by a weak early schedule

Medute

11/13/19 11:25am

And if not for a similar brainfart at the end of the half, 'Bama might have won.

Byron McNertney

11/13/19 10:57am

Yep, why play a season at all. Bama has the best talent

Medute

11/13/19 11:28am

Utah's resume is also weak

BYU Fan

11/13/19 11:48am

In this scenario, I am giving Utah a hypothetical CCG win over Oregon

Medute

11/13/19 3:40pm

Utah will have an argument, I just wouldn't pick them

BYU Fan

11/13/19 3:51pm

I think what you left out is Conference Champion

Medute

11/13/19 4:21pm

But it hasn’t historically

BYU Fan

11/13/19 4:41pm

Penn State didn’t win the CCG that year

Medute

11/13/19 4:45pm

Yes they did. Not all Conference championships are equal.

Byron McNertney

11/13/19 4:53pm

I stand corrected

Medute

11/13/19 5:24pm

Extraordinary circumstances are things like are you Ohio State or Alabama

BYU Fan

11/13/19 5:02pm

The CFP committee has used the "eye test" before and will use it again

Doogal McCougar

11/13/19 11:17am

Screw regular season and schedule strength, let’s just rematch Bama and LSU

Medute

11/13/19 11:29am

Zactly

Doogal McCougar

11/13/19 1:25pm

Bama lost barely to #1 LSU. Utes lost to mediocre USC team. Bama gets the nod.

guitarplayingcougar

11/13/19 12:18pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad