... but has the best results. Perhaps he's the most talented?

Report problem with this ad

Nov 14, 2019
10:29:34am

ToasterChive All-American

Report problem with this ad

ToasterChive

Previous username: Chicarl
Bio page: ToasterChive
Joined: Sep 3, 2010
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 22,056 (418 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Baylor beat Utah St. and Boise St. 2 of 3 rivalry games. Zach lost to Toledo and

ToasterChive

11/14/19 10:27am

Agreed...I'd stick with Romney the rest of the season...let the other QBs rest

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

11/14/19 10:28am

Romney's play has been more than sufficient to let coaches be patient with Zach's injury.

SpiffCoug

11/14/19 10:37am

Yep. No reason to risk another quick injury on ZW or Hall. Maybe the bowl game

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

11/14/19 10:43am

I'm fine shutting down ZW if Romney is told ZW will start in spring. There is

jcase16byu

11/14/19 3:42pm

Why wouldn’t you want a competition?

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 4:35pm

Because he completely earned his spot. You don't lose your status due to injury

jcase16byu

11/14/19 4:48pm

That isn’t what you said..:

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 5:35pm

Meh sorry I didn't type clear enough for you to understand what no meant

jcase16byu

11/14/19 10:03pm

That wasn’t it, you said it should be clear there’s no competition

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 10:10pm

I meant going into spring ball. Qb1 would be known to be ZW and that he would

jcase16byu

11/14/19 10:14pm

Well I have no issue with him going into spring as the #1...

CoachSpeak

11/15/19 9:47am

I totally agree with you and this is what I poorly tried to say earlier

jcase16byu

11/15/19 8:15pm

People lose their jobs to injury all the time.

SpiffCoug

11/14/19 5:49pm

Ask Wally Pipp.

Archaea

11/14/19 6:09pm

Dont know about the season, but I would rest him at least this weekend and then

Ode to Hoy

11/14/19 11:03am

I think you have to say Hall beat USU as well. That first half was the best

Dangerous

11/14/19 10:28am

^^^This! People are undervaluing Hall's play that 1st half. He was crazy good!

IntelCougar

11/14/19 11:03am

Hall looked like an actual star that first half...

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 12:36pm

Romney is the least talented of the three...

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 10:28am

... but has the best results. Perhaps he's the most talented?

ToasterChive

11/14/19 10:29am

<< Deleted >>

Cougazul

11/14/19 10:30am

Perhaps the coaching has been better?

DieHarder

11/14/19 10:31am

What does that even mean. Like they ate their wheaties on gameday?

ToasterChive

11/14/19 10:32am

RE: What does that even mean. Like they ate their wheaties on gameday?

Turnpike Lane

11/14/19 10:35am

How does he have the "best results"?

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 10:32am

23/33 passing, 3TDs, 70% CMP%, 160 PER is mediocre? And I agree in that Hall was

dazcoug

11/14/19 1:05pm

I notice you omitted the int...

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 4:39pm

I thought that's what we were doing since you ommitted the second half of USU

dazcoug

11/14/19 9:43pm

No I didn’t...

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 9:48pm

That depends on what criteria are used to define "talent." Romney obviously has some QB skills that are

lightmann

11/14/19 10:48am

In this regard, I will just trust the coaches. I don't have a dog in the fight

Archaea

11/14/19 10:48am

Zach beat USC and Tennessee. Also if your giving credit to Romney for beating

Blueto

11/14/19 10:30am

USF? Game was completely lost when Baylor came in.

ToasterChive

11/14/19 10:33am

He had two drives down 4 points that ended on downs. I don't blame him for

Blueto

11/14/19 10:39am

Ok. But mentioning USF in the way you do is the ultimate cherry picking.

ToasterChive

11/14/19 10:54am

"Utah St was coming back in the 2nd half and Baylor had it all under control"

Ungoy

11/14/19 1:26pm

Actually got down close on two drives, but couldn't get it in the end zone. If

basman

11/14/19 10:40am

Romney played one drive against USF. Not even close to the same thing.

Dakota Cougar

11/14/19 10:33am

Actually got down close on two drives, but couldn't get it in the end zone. If

basman

11/14/19 10:37am

You want ZW every time and it’s not close.

shammy

11/14/19 10:31am

you type this as if the QB is the only person playing both sides of the ball

hxmCougar2000

11/14/19 10:31am

Was thinking the exact same thing.

Refugee

11/14/19 1:25pm

Jaren Beat USU just as much as Baylor.

LEHI cougar

11/14/19 10:51am

I agree. But I'd give ZW a chance. Competition is good. Play both against ISU

mandalorian

11/14/19 11:22am

My view is that Baylor has made substantial progress during the season and

Y-Zag

11/14/19 11:42am

Offensive playcalling and OL play have improved greatly post-Zach injury, plus

JKLCoug

11/14/19 12:10pm

I'm OK with that.

Y-Zag

11/14/19 12:17pm

What I would like to see is a completely open competition...

CoachSpeak

11/14/19 12:33pm

^^^^this

puntersarepeople

11/14/19 2:46pm

Yup!

Ned Schneebly

11/14/19 4:11pm

He RS last year

puntersarepeople

11/14/19 4:25pm

We’ve played multiple QBs in multiple games - start ZW, give Baylor 2nd half...

TrueBlue58

11/14/19 12:49pm

We were up 23-14 when Jaren Hall got his concussion...

The Maestro

11/14/19 1:24pm

NO WAY! If you’d like Zach to transfer to Utah, go right ahead.

BountifulCoug5

11/14/19 2:24pm

Also, how about his mediocre performance against Liberty?

BountifulCoug5

11/14/19 2:25pm

So how does Zack Wilson beating USC and Tennessee fit into your argument?

gww687

11/14/19 2:31pm

It doesn't really, but when you beat 2 of 3 rivals and Zach hasn't.. then yeah.

ToasterChive

11/14/19 3:37pm

Only a sith deals in absolutes

LifelongAP

11/14/19 2:48pm

Typical backup qb syndrome here on CB. Never gets old...

coug719

11/14/19 3:41pm

Preach

Posting on CougarBoard