While I mostly agree with you why is there no outrage then when pitchers hit

Nov 15, 2019
10:57:48am

chitownboy Redshirt Freshman

batters? Cause I guarantee it's done with intent sometimes. Why the outrage over hitting someone with a helmet and not with all the other examples. So hypocritical IMO

Report problem with this ad

chitownboy

Bio page: chitownboy
Joined: Aug 6, 2010
Last login: May 13, 2024
Total posts: 1,048 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I am old enough to remember 5 Memphis players attacking a BYU player one of

travelcoug

11/14/19 11:17pm

But....but....Rudolph started it!

WJCougar

11/14/19 11:20pm

False, he is the nicest reindeer we know. He would not start a rumble.

Ode to Hoy

11/15/19 7:15am

Because we are Mormon and people have double standards with Mormons

HONOMO

11/14/19 11:37pm

But but but using a helmet

travelcoug

11/14/19 11:38pm

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 9:58am

I just rewatched that brawl the difference was

troutmaster13

11/15/19 5:18am

Terrible logic. So it’s assault if the guy being attacked isn’t wearing a helmet

chitownboy

11/15/19 5:57am

Umm, yes?

Heath Squashwell

11/15/19 6:05am

Again terrible take. You can do some bad damage with a helmet no matter what

chitownboy

11/15/19 6:36am

Punching someone with and without a helmet on is a big difference.

SlantRoute

11/15/19 7:08am

Never said there wasn’t a difference with or without a helmet

chitownboy

11/15/19 7:44am

I don’t think anyone is justifying violent behavior

Heath Squashwell

11/15/19 7:29am

So if a guy uses his body as a missle and makes direct

chitownboy

11/15/19 7:47am

The QB was lucky, VERY lucky, the helmet being swung only grazed his head; .....

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 10:04am

So if a baseball player throws a 100 mph fastball and plunks someone it's not

chitownboy

11/15/19 10:43am

All I'm saying is that assault is not judged merely on "if" the punch lands.....

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 10:47am

I'd say if it can be proven the pitcher intentionally hits the batter then he...

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 10:52am

While I mostly agree with you why is there no outrage then when pitchers hit

chitownboy

11/15/19 10:57am

Yes, I totally agree that "many" times a pitcher intentionally beans a batter...

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 12:13pm

Okay I agree but why the amount of outrage now

chitownboy

11/15/19 1:12pm

Why the outrage now? I guess because it was so flagrant and so visible.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 3:47pm

If the pitcher throws the ball and hits the dude in the head while he is being

travelcoug

11/15/19 11:47am

One can kill you and the other can give you a concussion. Important difference.

vagabonder

11/15/19 8:20am

Yeah looked like Rudolph almost died from that hit. Cmon

chitownboy

11/15/19 8:33am

*can* kill you. You're being deliberately dense. There's a reason everyone disag

vagabonder

11/15/19 8:39am

Huh. Everyone disagrees with me. Look through the threads.

chitownboy

11/15/19 8:50am

Concussions can kill you

travelcoug

11/15/19 9:58am

Gee, I guess the blood all over Nacua's face meant nothing?

oldrugger

11/15/19 10:30am

Memphis University's administration made a public apology to BYU, but BYU...

ashkii49

11/15/19 8:48am

This is what started the brawl. They hanged up and pummeled him

travelcoug

11/15/19 10:00am

Four guys holding a dude and one swinging away with a weapon. Yea there should

travelcoug

11/15/19 10:05am

Good. It was their fault.

HONOMO

11/15/19 1:23pm

I don't think this is accurate. Paxton Lynch had a great apology though...

PJMort

11/15/19 3:50pm

So, older than 14?

jkccoug

11/15/19 10:04am

And I don’t act my age

travelcoug

11/15/19 10:06am

Nacua is a legend now

ThorLebowski

11/15/19 11:19am

I've been thinking the exact same thing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ColonelMustard

11/15/19 12:54pm

Here is a short video clip of the memphis player using the helmet. The media

ColonelMustard

11/15/19 1:01pm

and here is one player stomping at ours on the ground

ColonelMustard

11/15/19 1:04pm

It was, and most people faulted Memphis rather than BYU

Sumguy

11/15/19 1:20pm

So you’re older than five years old?

D.T. Survivor

11/15/19 2:31pm

One of you should send that clip on to ESPN/Fox

mendoncoug

11/15/19 2:42pm

I think BYU got hosed in the PR-department, HUGE, on this fight. Memphis was...

BleedCougarBlue2

11/15/19 3:51pm

Yep, it was one-sided against BYU w/ many media outlets.

MatthiasPhunkHausen

11/15/19 5:08pm

With either brawl, the only issue I have is when one side tries to dismiss their

Posting on CougarBoard