Sorta. thanksgiving existed in England. It was not a new America specific thing.

Nov 28, 2019
10:55:04am

bruincoug All-American

The “first” thanksgiving [in our colony] morphed into the “original” thanksgiving in our telling of it. But that’s like saying Christmas started in America with the Pilgrims.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 28, 2019 at 10:55:04am

Message modified by bruincoug on Nov 28, 2019 at 12:04:24pm

Report problem with this ad

bruincoug

Bio page: bruincoug
Joined: Mar 20, 2003
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 11,272 (492 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Why do we celebrate the Plymouth Thanksgiving when the first Thanksgiving was in

Dynasty1

11/28/19 9:11am

Not Virginia, try St. Augustine, Fl in 1565

NavyCougar

11/28/19 9:23am

Fair enough, but most people refer to the 13 Colonies when talking about

Dynasty1

11/28/19 9:27am

Cultural bias, especially post Civil War

NavyCougar

11/28/19 9:31am

Well if we are going to recognize cultural bias then

CDV

11/28/19 9:38am

True but the US is a product of the 13 British colonies not Florida, Louisiana

Dynasty1

11/28/19 9:39am

That’s really interesting, thanks for posting it.

chilango

11/28/19 11:46am

Technically, Thanksgiving long predates that.

bruincoug

11/28/19 10:14am

I’m assuming that you’re referring to different Harvest Festivals like

Dynasty1

11/28/19 10:40am

Sorta. thanksgiving existed in England. It was not a new America specific thing.

bruincoug

11/28/19 10:55am

Didn’t Jamestown initially fail? Something like 60 of the original 500 survived

Posting on CougarBoard