I didn't call anyone horrible. Tyson was good in 4 games for us

Jan 27, 2020
4:43:51pm

kimdaddy35 All-American

and without him we probably don't finish .500. The main reason he was in the transfer portal was because he was injury prone. That didn't change at BYU.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 46,422 (1,476 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Players in the projected 2 deep that didn't help BYU's recruiting average

donnerstag

1/27/20 8:18am

Nice research. One example of the lack of depth + arguably mediocre recruiting

MichCoug

1/27/20 8:21am

Not saying these aren’t fine players, but we’ve also gone .500 against FBS teams

Junior Deputy

1/27/20 8:28am

One could argue that the talent on last year's team was enough to win 10 games

donnerstag

1/27/20 8:34am

One could argue that but they’d be wrong.

Junior Deputy

1/27/20 8:46am

Did you actually watch the games last season?

donnerstag

1/27/20 9:30am

I watched every minute of every game, usually multiple times.

Junior Deputy

1/27/20 10:02am

You are making the mistake of judging talent on recruiting averages alone

donnerstag

1/27/20 10:17am

I don’t completely disagree with you, but making the two deep on a .500 team

Junior Deputy

1/27/20 10:46am

Recruiting rankings weren't that much higher prior to the 2006-09 run

donnerstag

1/27/20 11:12am

Great post. Well said.

inside_info?

1/27/20 11:30am

Totally agree. I actually do think that the talent is not bad

gmj81

1/27/20 10:52am

...also inconsistent QB play from the returning starter. Started okay but...

icecougar

1/27/20 5:09pm

Uh... a lot of our future NFL guys are on this list

BrutustheBrash

1/27/20 10:10am

How do you define below average?

Coop

1/27/20 8:34am

Below the recruiting class average rating

donnerstag

1/27/20 8:35am

BYU’s or overall?

Coop

1/27/20 8:36am

BYU's

donnerstag

1/27/20 8:41am

I think the recruiting numbers are too suspicious to put much into this...

Pretorian

1/27/20 9:22am

Baylor Romney, Milne, Christensen, Fonua, Wilgar, and Kaufusi are all good enough to be in the 2 deep

YIsForBrigham

1/27/20 10:01am

I watched a handfull of 3* kids commit to FCS schools this weekend...

TheLost

1/27/20 10:26am

Payton Wilgar is gonna be a star

The Maestro

1/27/20 10:38am

So I'm undecided if this list is a good thing or bad thing

mudpupper

1/27/20 12:04pm

It's both

donnerstag

1/27/20 12:21pm

My question, is this simply an FYI or are you trying to draw a conclusion or...

CoachSpeak

1/27/20 1:04pm

The strategy seems pretty clear with this staff

donnerstag

1/27/20 1:15pm

I think you're a little bit to optimistic on those points...

CoachSpeak

1/27/20 1:28pm

Results seem to indicate coaching and youth more

puntersarepeople

1/27/20 2:12pm

Consistency also is the result of better talent...

CoachSpeak

1/27/20 2:43pm

Translation: BYU has very mediocre talent

kimdaddy35

1/27/20 1:12pm

Ty’Son was one of those horrible transfers looking for playing time

puntersarepeople

1/27/20 2:13pm

I didn't call anyone horrible. Tyson was good in 4 games for us

kimdaddy35

1/27/20 4:43pm

At some point, recruits aren't defined by their initial rankings

donnerstag

1/27/20 2:19pm

Usually the talent performs as a regression to the mean. We need better

D.T. Survivor

1/27/20 3:32pm

You would be taking out over 50% on any team so this is not surprising

Posting on CougarBoard