Maybe "vacate" the title, like they did with USC.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Feb 19, 2020
10:20:47am

bluecheese All-American

Maybe "vacate" the title, like they did with USC.

Don't award it to the Dodgers. They didn't earn it. Just leave it vacated. Take back the WS rings and trophy.

Report problem with this ad

bluecheese

Previous username: Speculum
Bio page: bluecheese
Joined: Dec 14, 2004
Last login: May 17, 2024
Total posts: 14,164 (33 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Would you take away the Astros and Red Sox World Series Titles?

2/19/20 9:53am

Well, nothing's come out of the investigation with the Red Sox

cougfan03

2/19/20 9:54am

True, but given Cora was one of the instigators in Houston it's expected that

2/19/20 11:27am

I don’t care about the title as much as doing something to punish the players

Colorado

2/19/20 9:57am

Don't forget the 1951 NL pennant because Bobby Thompson's "shot heard round the

Scratch

2/19/20 10:03am

The old "well other people cheat too" argument is so tiring

Medute

2/19/20 10:15am

That's fine, but we need to be consistent. I'm all for stripping titles as long

Scratch

2/19/20 10:27am

It's all about team involvement, depth of cheating, and deviation from typical

Medute

2/19/20 10:38am

So yes to teams that have organized sign stealing from CF? And I am certainly

Scratch

2/19/20 10:47am

Don't forget the technology aspect

Medute

2/19/20 10:54am

A telescope and buzzers, like the 1951 Giants were using, was cutting edge tech.

Scratch

2/19/20 11:00am

Binoculars and signals from the Blue Jays dugout in 2015

gmj81

2/19/20 11:01am

Red Sox and their Apple watches sure sounds like technology to me.

gmj81

2/19/20 11:02am

Yep, if the Red Sox used Apple Watches to steal signals and win a WS

Medute

2/19/20 11:56am

Agreed but you gotta remove temptation and get rid of traditional signs

gmj81

2/19/20 1:02pm

Sign stealing rules weren't implemented until 1961.

2/19/20 11:31am

I just don't know enough about the 1951 Giants

Medute

2/19/20 11:53am

I would praise them for their ingenuity and ability to think outside the box.

Baron

2/19/20 10:03am

Then you'd have to take away all of the Patriots' titles, too

chazen

2/19/20 10:06am

Maybe "vacate" the title, like they did with USC.

bluecheese

2/19/20 10:20am

The MLB is in a hard place. Do you let the steroid WS keep theirs, but not the sign stealers?

2/19/20 10:44am

For the record, as an Astros fan

gmj81

2/19/20 10:46am

just do what the NFL does for QBs givem an ear piece and the coach can tell em

BYU Grounds

2/19/20 10:49am

Problem solved. I don't get the traditionalists who refuse such an easy solution

gmj81

2/19/20 10:58am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad