he was the best player on the field. Teams would have the perfect defense called and Taysom would out run the containment. He was a special player that had his career tarnished by injuries. That's why he belongs on the all-time "very good" list.
Stewart was a good player who saved the season after Taysom went down. The depth behind Stewart was abysmal. If you start ranking QBs from the 2000s, he's near the top of the list although QB play has been pretty average the last decade.