I'm going to split this out by metric, but take all of them into account when you rank them.

PER:
Player A: average: 21.8, high: 23.9, low: 13.3, seasons with PER at/above 21: 16
Player B: average: 23.8, high: 31.5, low: 16.3, seasons with PER at/above 21: 9
Player C: average: 25.1, high: 30.0, low: 19.7, seasons with PER at/above 21: 14
Player D: average: 18.1, high: 22.2, low: 14.5, seasons with PER at/above 21: 2
Player E: average: 24.1, high: 27.0, low: 20.6, seasons with PER at/above 21: 12

TS%
Player A: average: .608, high: .656, low: .548, seasons with TS% at/above .600: 11
Player B: average: .623, high: .675, low: .557, seasons with TS% at/above .600: 7
Player C: average: .582, high: .614, low: .537, seasons with TS% at/above .600: 3
Player D: average: .516, high: .554, low: .487, seasons with TS% at/above .600: 0
Player E: average: .610, high: .637, low: .581, seasons with TS% at/above .600: 10

AST%
Player A: average: 50.2, high: 57.5, low: 35.9, seasons with AST% at/above 40: 18
Player B: average: 31.5, high: 42.3, low: 24.2, seasons with AST% at/above 40: 1
Player C: average: 45.6, high: 54.5, low: 34.0, seasons with AST% at/above 40: 12
Player D: average: 37.4, high: 47.9, low: 30.3, seasons with AST% at/above 40: 4
Player E: average: 40.9, high: 49.3, low: 25.2, seasons with AST% at/above 40: 8

Win shares per 48 minutes
Player A: average: .209, high: .238, low: .100, seasons with WS/48 at/above .200: 14
Player B: average: .207, high: .318, low: .077, seasons with WS/48 at/above .200: 5
Player C: average: .243, high: .292, low: .172, seasons with WS/48 at/above .200: 11
Player D: average: .109, high: .173, low: .007, seasons with WS/48 at/above .200: 0
Player E: average: .225, high: .270, low: .180, seasons with WS/48 at/above .200: 9

Offensive box plus/minus
Player A: average: 4.9, high: 7.0, low: -1.7, seasons with OBPM at/above 5.0: 13
Player B: average: 6.0, high: 10.3, low: 1.1, seasons with OBPM at/above 5.0: 7
Player C: average: 5.3, high: 7.2, low: 2.7, seasons with OBPM at/above 5.0: 9
Player D: average: 2.4, high: 5.1, low: -0.3, seasons with OBPM at/above 5.0: 1
Player E: average: 5.9, high: 8.3, low: 3.1, seasons with OBPM at/above 5.0: 9

Defensive box plus/minus
Player A: average: 1.9, high: 3.7, low: 0.2, seasons with DBPM at/above 2.0: 8
Player B: average: 0.4, high: 1.7, low: -0.7, seasons with DBPM at/above 2.0: 0
Player C: average: 2.3, high: 3.8, low: 1.1, seasons with DBPM at/above 2.0: 9
Player D: average: 0.2, high: 1.2, low: -2.2, seasons with DBPM at/above 2.0: 0
Player E: average: 1.6, high: 3.3, low: 0.5, seasons with DBPM at/above 2.0: 3