No, fake "championships" do not count, nor should they.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 16, 2020
3:56:27pm

neboutefan All-American

Report problem with this ad

neboutefan

Bio page: neboutefan
Joined: Mar 21, 2015
Last login: May 13, 2024
Total posts: 4,892 (24 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Interesting Discussion on Reddit - Would you guys be willing to make this trade?

ZacSeljaas'Stache

9/16/20 3:31pm

We already have one so I'd prefer them not win 2 and tie up the score.

Harbinger

9/16/20 3:33pm

I think i'd need to know how it happens.

Harbinger

9/16/20 3:36pm

So would you give up the 84 NC to displace Utah's 2 BCS runs?

TFL

9/16/20 3:39pm

What? Never said I'd give up our natty.

Harbinger

9/16/20 3:42pm

Yeah...but 2 for 1? Throw in a recency factor?

TFL

9/16/20 3:45pm

You're equating a BCS run with actually winning a natty?

kirty

9/16/20 3:58pm

Depends. Not true comparables. BYUs NC was awesome, a culmination of a great run. Did wonders for validating the program

TFL

9/16/20 4:35pm

Lol. You only wish it had an *

andrewg3

9/16/20 5:00pm

All one has to do is check the trophy case at both schools to know.

Harbinger

9/16/20 5:08pm

Not really, Never cool to take anything away from BYU's NC. It's special. But I was too young in 84

TFL

9/16/20 5:21pm

This^^^

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9/16/20 8:51pm

Can you show me where the * is? I've never seen one associated with 1984.

squidmark

9/16/20 8:52pm

National perception.

TFL

9/16/20 10:09pm

Uh wait, you are the only one giving it an *. The national media, NCAA, etc. all consider BYU the '84 NC with NO *.

TheLoneCougar

9/17/20 6:47am

Did you eat paint chips as a kid?

Ned Schneebly

9/17/20 6:55am

Amen!! People don't discuss BCA/BCS/NY6 victories. BYU does

BYUHgrad

9/17/20 6:29am

Let time run its course.

JL31

9/16/20 3:34pm

We just need to find a punter that can run for 19 yards when the pressures on

ZacSeljaas'Stache

9/16/20 3:35pm

Dude, too soon.

All-American

9/16/20 3:37pm

EVERYONE THINKS IT'S 19 YARDS & FORGETS THAT WE START 15 YARDS BACK FROM THE LOS

JL31

9/16/20 3:38pm

Johnny i love you man

IceWaterExtraIce

9/16/20 3:43pm

RE: Johnny i love you man

IceWaterExtraIce

9/16/20 3:44pm

Taysom could do it

darkcoug

9/16/20 3:52pm

Well you didn’t even make it back to the line of scrimmage so...

USMCdad

9/16/20 3:59pm

Hey he was only 23 yards short!

JohnnyComeLately

9/16/20 4:02pm

RE: Well you didn’t even make it back to the line of scrimmage so...

JL31

9/16/20 4:12pm

I loved the play. I didn't like the outcome, but I loved that you were gutsy

TailgateU

9/17/20 8:25am

RE: We just need to find a punter that can run for 19 yards when the pressures

CougarTwins

9/16/20 3:46pm

TPSA. Need someone to make hats.

CougarTwins

9/16/20 3:37pm

There's more truth to this than everyone realizes.

Y05

9/16/20 6:36pm

Yes I’d do that in a heartbeat.

Duke Silver

9/16/20 3:35pm

Utah already has their 2 asterisk championships. Do those count?

LiveCoug

9/16/20 3:36pm

No, fake "championships" do not count, nor should they.

neboutefan

9/16/20 3:56pm

Definitely.

WP17

9/16/20 3:37pm

I’d prefer to not hVe them win one ever.

Dr MoBYU

9/16/20 3:38pm

Worth it

Blueto

9/16/20 3:40pm

Shouldn't he be asking Utah about Colorado?

shoganai

9/16/20 3:40pm

I say no. It's petty, but no. I can't live with Utah winning a NC, let alone two

che flaco

9/16/20 3:44pm

Yes. Do it.

JadonY

9/16/20 3:51pm

We compete with our rival for recruits

Great38

9/16/20 3:52pm

Would be nice to be in the top 20 or better even if our rival did better also.

JadonY

9/16/20 5:08pm

Of course not! That one is easy.

Great38

9/16/20 3:51pm

No never.

YIsForBrigham

9/16/20 3:57pm

As a Texas Aggie and lifelong BYU fan, this question sucks. Never give the bad

TailgateU

9/16/20 4:05pm

A national championship would solidify BYU relevance again, even if Utah was still better

cheezedawg

9/16/20 4:09pm

Yes no brainer yes absolutely. Hate the Utes but love Cougs more. Plus

CougaRR4L

9/16/20 4:13pm

Maybe we can get a Utah guy to make the deal.

Blue Heart

9/16/20 4:21pm

1 to 0 is better than 2 to 2

ldssdl

9/16/20 4:23pm

Absolutely, no question.

DanSmith

9/16/20 4:35pm

I went back and forth on this, but ultimately decided YES. The state would have

RUNBYU1

9/16/20 5:37pm

Absolutely. If both BYU and Utah were nationally relevant, I'd be thrilled

Hill4Heisman

9/16/20 5:05pm

Yes

buckles

9/16/20 5:30pm

To the people saying yes because it would be good for the state and would make

che flaco

9/16/20 5:57pm

Cool. BYU and Texas are in the same tier of CFB.

Y05

9/16/20 6:32pm

What if the one we win is against them?

sah22

9/16/20 6:59pm

Yes, I'll take a BYU national championship. Don't care about the Utes either way

Reedme

9/16/20 8:06pm

Yes as long as our NC is the year after their 2nd one.

Bald Eagle

9/16/20 8:31pm

DEFINITELY

Sale

9/17/20 9:09am

I'm fine with Boise winning 2.

ochobeeguy

9/17/20 9:26am

I absolutely hate the U of U BUT...

CaughtForaTouchdown

9/17/20 10:25am

I question the sanity of anyone using PRC's REDDIT?

Posting on CougarBoard