<< Deleted >>

Report problem with this ad

Oct 19, 2020
3:01:00pm

Preppy All-American

<< Deleted >>

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:01:00pm

Message modified by Preppy on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:01:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Preppy

Previous username: Forever Young
Bio page: Preppy
Joined: Nov 14, 2006
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 10,501 (1,397 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Can anyone confirm if Kalani did infact call the defensive plays in the 2nd half

dodgersjazzcougs

10/19/20 1:02pm

Didn't Sitake himself confirm the opposite: that he didn't?

I'm Dynamite

10/19/20 1:03pm

If he said that, he's lying

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:05pm

Good grief... folks need to give it a rest.

NorCal_Coug

10/19/20 1:27pm

They never give up, they are the anti Howell, Bronco, Anae on and on.😡

Beetdiggercoug

10/19/20 8:19pm

Citation needed

All-American

10/19/20 1:37pm

<< Deleted >>

Preppy

10/19/20 3:01pm

Isn't that what you would expect though? He isn't going to say, "yeah tuiaki

IceCreamButt

10/19/20 1:06pm

RE: Isn't that what you would expect though? He isn't going to say, "yeah tuiaki

I'm Dynamite

10/19/20 1:07pm

PDH writer Darnell Dickson says yes KS called them

WallaX2

10/19/20 1:04pm

BYUtv post game said the same.

IceCreamButt

10/19/20 1:06pm

I don't think that's true. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

All-American

10/19/20 1:09pm

Nixon claimed it in the postgame

LaserCoug

10/19/20 1:21pm

Going back I guess it wasn't as definitive as I thought. David nixon said we

IceCreamButt

10/19/20 1:39pm

I appreciate that honest response. Thanks.

All-American

10/19/20 1:45pm

No he didn't.

All-American

10/19/20 1:09pm

This is they typical handling of the evidence for the Tuiaki conspiracy theory.

I'm Dynamite

10/19/20 1:13pm

Thanks, Sister Tuiaki. Have fun with your tinfoil hat

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:20pm

And good luck with your pitch fork. Cheers.

I'm Dynamite

10/19/20 4:08pm

Yes, he did. I don't think you read the full article. Darnell specifically says

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:17pm

Let's say Darnell knows this. How could/would Darnell know this?

rcbyufan

10/19/20 1:20pm

That's not the point. All-American was disputing the fact that Darnell said this

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:23pm

He also admits that Kalani would say otherwise. He doesn't know.

All-American

10/19/20 1:26pm

Again, not the point. Darnell said it whether it's true or not. You can dispute

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:29pm

Okay, fine. As long as we agree he has no idea.

All-American

10/19/20 1:32pm

Oh, and on "doesn't take a genius...."

All-American

10/19/20 1:28pm

Wait, weren't you just arguing that Darnell doesn't know, but now you're...

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:33pm

First, it's "hearsay." Second, this isn't a courtroom. Third . . .

All-American

10/19/20 1:35pm

RE: First, it's "hearsay." Second, this isn't a courtroom. Third . . .

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 1:36pm

Are you saying it was "the plan" to suck in the first half to surprise them in 2

Lance71

10/19/20 5:47pm

I think the point is that it isn't REASONABLE to think Darnell would know this.

rcbyufan

10/19/20 1:38pm

I don't know what's been written it what the coaches said post game but

seco03

10/19/20 1:06pm

He relays the calls from Tuiaki in the booth. Normal.

I'm Dynamite

10/19/20 1:07pm

The head coach relaying play calls to the field from the booth is hardly normal. He was calling plays.

Turnpike Lane

10/19/20 1:09pm

But he was "calling" the plays with input from the booth, that's why they are up

basman

10/19/20 2:12pm

That’s different than just signaling in a play as a go between.

Turnpike Lane

10/19/20 5:20pm

Going purely off of that is like saying the backup QBs are calling plays because

molodyets

10/19/20 1:08pm

That's actually when things turned. We started letting Baylor call the plays.

All-American

10/19/20 1:10pm

So did David Nixon. Some refuse to believe it for some reason even after years of Tuiaki

BYU '80

10/19/20 1:08pm

Players told me today that he didn’t. That the game plan was always to surprise

4mack

10/19/20 1:13pm

The plan was to let Houston have their way and a lead and then surprise them with an actual effective defense?

No touching

10/19/20 1:22pm

I think the strategy is to get through the first half playing bend but don't

Oompabluepaw

10/19/20 1:28pm

Hope that is not the idea. That is risky to play that way.

dodgersjazzcougs

10/19/20 1:34pm

The offensive equivalent: run between tackles for first half. Mix it up and try

bruincoug

10/19/20 1:51pm

I actually think it's kind of brilliant. Can't believe I'm saying this about a

RUNBYU1

10/19/20 4:09pm

Exactly what I thought when I read that.

rebelCoug

10/19/20 1:28pm

The defense actually played pretty well the 1st quarter. The second Q was a

rcbyufan

10/19/20 1:36pm

This is where I'm also confused. 2 90+ yard scoring drives *and then* switch?

BluebloodOR

10/19/20 1:39pm

It's just like portland state, we played a tight awful game we could have

IceCreamButt

10/19/20 1:42pm

Plus PSU has a bunch of NFL DB’s and we’re going to undefeated the rest the

Gerald-DeGroot

10/19/20 1:51pm

I doubt the Utes were shocked to see us lose to LSU the next week.

CougarThug

10/19/20 2:23pm

I think the "not open the playbook" was the excuse given by fans that could not

here's to hoping

10/19/20 3:26pm

RE: The plan was to let Houston have their way and a lead and then surprise them

Gerald-DeGroot

10/19/20 1:50pm

During BYUTV postgame KS specifically credited Tuiaki for making 2H adjustments

TrueBlue58

10/19/20 2:08pm

IMO I am still "not" confident that Tuiaki is solely in charge of the D.

BleedCougarBlue2

10/19/20 2:15pm

Has anybody said he was? I thought they've been clear on collaboration.

All-American

10/19/20 2:19pm

Has KS said it's been a collaborative effort? I dunno. All I know is our D is...

BleedCougarBlue2

10/19/20 2:24pm

During Coordinators Corner on BYUtv today it sounds like No. The standard people

BYUtka

10/19/20 2:16pm

I don' know who was making the calls

Oldcougfan

10/19/20 2:50pm

IMO Kalani was a bit perturbed during the BYUtv postgame interview and

BlackBart

10/19/20 3:06pm

I don't really care where the calls are coming from, but the last two weeks have

here's to hoping

10/19/20 3:34pm

Does anyone know if Kalani didn't not not call the defense?

Big McLargeHuge

10/19/20 4:56pm

Pretty unanimous he didn't not not call the first half.

here's to hoping

10/19/20 5:02pm

I think I want KC2H to become the new SGC

BlooGeek

10/19/20 5:11pm

Kalani has 100% been calling the defensive plays since the middle of last year..

SCougar

10/19/20 5:53pm

RE: Kalani has 100% been calling the defensive plays since the middle of last

rcbyufan

10/19/20 6:34pm

It would have been worse. And BYU is doing better considering the athletes that

SCougar

10/19/20 9:51pm

Everyone knows there's diff between calling the plays and signaling them, right?

coug10278

10/19/20 7:10pm

You think the head coach would be signaling plays if he wasn’t calling them?

stev

10/19/20 9:33pm

Unless you believe the HC is only the signaler, yes he called the D second half

stev

10/19/20 9:33pm

Report problem with this ad