To win one game against the college all star team? Probably every one. If I think I can coach up Lawrence and

Oct 19, 2020
3:25:47pm

YIsForBrigham Poo Poo

get him ready to face an NFL defense and win in his first NFL action ever with no other NFL veterans on his side, then maybe I'd go with him over Darnold but I dont think so.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:25:47pm

Message modified by YIsForBrigham on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:26:00pm

Message modified by YIsForBrigham on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:26:33pm

Message modified by YIsForBrigham on Oct 19, 2020 at 3:26:46pm

Report problem with this ad

YIsForBrigham

Previous username: TrueAndBlue
Bio page: YIsForBrigham
Joined: Aug 9, 2012
Last login: May 18, 2024
Total posts: 65,525 (17,792 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Thoughts?

Dakota Cougar

10/19/20 2:54pm

Nope. Jets would win by 30+.

Blueto

10/19/20 2:55pm

No, and it wouldn't even be close.

shoganai

10/19/20 2:55pm

The college team would have more top end talent

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 2:57pm

Professional men against talented amateur boys.

ReyOso

10/19/20 3:15pm

Funniest take of the day

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:31pm

That's not really true, IMO.

shoganai

10/19/20 5:45pm

Look at the guys on the Jets and who were drafted highly

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 9:14pm

I respectfully think you're off your rocker on this topic.

shoganai

10/19/20 9:29pm

Touche

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 11:31pm

I agree yes, if they had a decent coach. If they had the Jet's coaching staff

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 2:55pm

The Jets stink, but....No.

Lifi

10/19/20 2:55pm

No. Let's take a shot at the college offense.

YIsForBrigham

10/19/20 2:55pm

Which positions would you rather have the Jet's player?

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:19pm

To win one game against the college all star team? Probably every one. If I think I can coach up Lawrence and

YIsForBrigham

10/19/20 3:25pm

Good thing you aren't an NFL GM then

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:33pm

It wouldn't be close. It would be a blowout.

YIsForBrigham

10/19/20 3:51pm

Probably, because those are all future NFL high draft picks anyway

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 2:55pm

NFL draft pick =/= actual NFL rotational player

salamishiitake

10/19/20 3:04pm

How many 1st round draft picks aren't rotational players in year 1?

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:07pm

It's a hypothetical question. Hypothetically speaking, if most ended up being...

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 3:10pm

I guess? If they had several years to gel as a team with their coaching staff

salamishiitake

10/19/20 3:13pm

"I guess" is the right answer, because it's exactly that - hypothetical

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 3:15pm

LaVellIfIKnow

10/19/20 2:55pm

Schmaybe

sethj250

10/19/20 2:56pm

Here we go again......... Nope.

mudpupper

10/19/20 2:57pm

Do the Jets have 20 guys with 1st round talent?

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:00pm

does every first round draft pick belong on an NFL roster?

salamishiitake

10/19/20 3:05pm

Through week 6 only two 1st round draft picks a year ago haven't played

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:10pm

And how many of them are tearing up the league.

ReyOso

10/19/20 3:16pm

Burrow has looked phenomenal in my opinion playing on team devoid of talent.

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:28pm

Right, there are always a few outstanding rookies.

ReyOso

10/19/20 3:45pm

Taking the top draft picks at each position from a year ago would result in a

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:52pm

But how many Jets are tearing up the league?

squidmark

10/19/20 8:22pm

<< Deleted >>

Sea Chicken

10/19/20 2:57pm

Indy Coug

10/19/20 2:58pm

With an NFL coach + staff + facilities, etc. and 6 months to prep — still no.

CocaColaRecovery

10/19/20 2:58pm

I'm going to say yes. This year's rookie class is actually a good test case

4th and Niner

10/19/20 3:01pm

Well, let's see. That would be Zach, Dax, Tonga, Algiers, Barrington, Empey, . .

squidmark

10/19/20 3:02pm

So here is a potential roster for the college team:

Dakota Cougar

10/19/20 3:03pm

I think they win and with that coaching staff and time to prepare they would win

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:06pm

To be clear, I did draft-eligible players.

Dakota Cougar

10/19/20 3:58pm

No. Not close.

Jay Kay

10/19/20 3:06pm

No. And it wouldn’t be close

A Drew Aitch

10/19/20 3:07pm

Absolutely YES

Hup

10/19/20 3:08pm

Yes this is a very different question than could Alabama beat them

kimdaddy35

10/19/20 3:12pm

It’s a different game. A bad nfl team > any team of college players

Grungymtnman

10/19/20 3:10pm

This isn't comparing a college team to an NFL team. We all agree no college team

Sock Gnome

10/19/20 3:13pm

I know- I said ANY team of college players.

Grungymtnman

10/19/20 3:29pm

Negative.

lightmann

10/19/20 3:10pm

They used to have a college allstar team play the NFL champs every year. The

NewMexiCoug

10/19/20 3:13pm

Here would be the lineup

IceWaterExtraIce

10/19/20 3:14pm

Every person that says no is ignoring the X factor in this hypothetical:

crazY

10/19/20 3:24pm

I think it’s easy to say no, but I look at the NFL today and think

USMCdad

10/19/20 3:48pm

The gap between top college players and average NFL players isn’t that wide

Posting on CougarBoard