So explain how it makes sense. How does one come to fruition without the other?

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 15, 2021
11:52:59am

Lip Gallagher Intervention Needed

So explain how it makes sense. How does one come to fruition without the other?

I'm really curious how you can both suck at the lifeblood of college sports, and also string together really good seasons with a bunch of depth and pro talent.
Please help everyone understand how they can both happen.

Instead of just claiming you agree with something, can you actually explain the reasoning?

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 15, 2021 at 11:52:59am

Message modified by Lip Gallagher on Jan 15, 2021 at 11:54:05am

Report problem with this ad

Lip Gallagher

Previous username: Rusty'sJuicyCknHole
New username: Chef Carl Casper
Bio page: Lip Gallagher
Joined: Apr 26, 2013
Last login: Apr 30, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

4 Star recruits are becoming extinct with BYU

crm48 Pretty...Pretty...Pretty Good

1/14/21 4:53pm

Well, they all go to P5 schools, nowadays. Our only chance is to get in a P5 or

CougarTailDevourer

1/14/21 4:57pm

Ah You was also a 4* recruit...

Benfica1

1/14/21 10:56pm

99% do go P5. BYU does get some LDS diehards. Conover and Ah You.

delete_king

1/15/21 10:49am

He said 'becoming extinct'.... as if things were changing. BYU has always

Benfica1

1/15/21 11:07am

4 Star recruits that agree to and live the ‘Honor Code.’

MichCoug

1/14/21 4:58pm

Logan Fano

JKLCoug

1/14/21 5:01pm

Logan Fano is rated as a four star by some services

puntersarepeople

1/14/21 5:02pm

Here are questions, somebody knows:

Archaea

1/14/21 5:04pm

The gap between P5 and not-P5's grows every year.

TheLost

1/14/21 5:10pm

They're not less dispersed. They've always been dispersed throughout the P5s.

1/14/21 5:51pm

Kids don't want to live the HC anymore, or at least don't want to feel

Fargo

1/14/21 5:12pm

Kids don't want to work for dads dusty old company.. they want tech startups..

TheLost

1/14/21 5:18pm

That's a pretty broad and judgmental brush

2FarGone

1/14/21 5:28pm

This.

Cougstreak

1/15/21 7:02am

I’m all due respect, I’ve heard this since this board started.

StalwartBraveTrue

1/14/21 6:24pm

If we start putting more guys in the NFL, the recruits will come.

ManicBlue

1/14/21 5:21pm

There are like two 4 stars committed outside of P5 schools.

sidsie716

1/14/21 5:24pm

Wasn’t there only one or two four stars that didn’t sign with a P5 school? BYU

LyleLanley

1/14/21 5:40pm

RE: Wasn’t there only one or two four stars that didn’t sign with a

CougarTailDevourer

1/14/21 5:41pm

Yes

delete_king

1/14/21 9:16pm

Well Notre Dame signed 8, but they're a P5-like Independent

krindorr

2/26/21 4:36pm

Looks like there ended up being 5 (not including ND)

krindorr

2/26/21 4:48pm

Um, Ah You, Tuifua, Fano, Warner, Tanielu,

1/14/21 5:45pm

Steve Young was adamant in his interview

UVCoug

1/14/21 6:13pm

RE: Steve Young was adamant in his interview

1/14/21 6:30pm

Steve stays close to the program

UVCoug

1/14/21 9:18pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

1/14/21 9:27pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

UVCoug

1/14/21 9:35pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

1/14/21 9:38pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

UVCoug

1/14/21 9:48pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

bluescholar

1/14/21 10:08pm

RE: Steve stays close to the program

UVCoug

1/14/21 10:12pm

So, you think the talent on the team this last year looked like the product of

bluescholar

1/14/21 10:14pm

<< Deleted >>

ochobeeguy

1/14/21 11:30pm

<< Deleted >>

bluescholar

1/14/21 11:43pm

Here’s the point Lip is trying to make: if recruiting has been lowsy how did we

puntersarepeople

1/14/21 11:03pm

You don't seem fine with him disagreeing...

ochobeeguy

1/15/21 10:07am

You agree with him without seeing the irony? Lol go for it.

1/15/21 10:28am

Agree to disagree, my friend.

UVCoug

1/15/21 11:46am

So explain how it makes sense. How does one come to fruition without the other?

1/15/21 11:52am

So you believe you can have a good season with lousy recruiting?

puntersarepeople

1/15/21 11:53am

Recruiting since going Indy had been bad. It's just a fact.

Moops

1/14/21 6:21pm

It has less to do with being Indy and more with Utah being P5

thebyuman32

1/14/21 6:25pm

Haha ok. Doesn't explain being passed up by AAC schools.

Moops

1/14/21 6:28pm

Go away if that's all you ever want to talk about.

1/14/21 6:31pm

What recruits have chose AAC schools over BYU?

cougman02

1/14/21 7:34pm

Another thing those who don't follow recruiting closely need to understand is

bluescholar

1/14/21 7:48pm

He's not a byu fan. He's one of those "conference fans" and hangs out here

1/14/21 9:29pm

<< Deleted >>

bluescholar

1/14/21 10:05pm

Byu does well against middle AAC, not against top.

Moops

1/14/21 7:57pm

Zach Wilson, Brady Christensen, Khyiris Tonga, Dax Milne...

SinkingQuffa

1/14/21 7:29pm

Where are you hearing that independence has opened recruiting doors?

1/14/21 8:10pm

Well the general sentiment is that When recruits see the schedule, venues and

SnickSnack

1/14/21 9:09pm

On avg only 3 or 4 4-Star rated players don't go P5 each year. The way to get

delete_king

1/14/21 9:14pm

Independence is not the problem.

1/14/21 9:39pm

Disagree, there are five to ten G5 teams out recruiting BYU each year.

delete_king

1/14/21 9:49pm

Yep, West coast kids are dying to play in the AAC.

bluescholar

1/14/21 10:07pm

I think it could open up more recruiting zones. At this point we are getting

delete_king

1/14/21 10:46pm

Because they are winning more. Most of all kids want to play for a winning team.

1/15/21 12:04am

Fano is. John Henry Daley and Raider Damuni not being a 4 star is a crime, IMO

1/14/21 10:27pm

I can confidently say that being a G5 wouldn’t be any different than being indy

Coug Man in Florida

1/14/21 10:54pm

BYU as an Ind

SC-Zoobie

1/14/21 11:05pm

Except they aren't. Nobody should take you seriously when you can't even look at the facts.

1/15/21 7:06am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad