Absolutely, but many suspected the Committee was gonna Committee.

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 23, 2021
5:38:11pm

stenso Contributor

Absolutely, but many suspected the Committee was gonna Committee.

NCAA Basketball has a track record of being much more merit based.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 23, 2021 at 5:38:11pm

Message modified by stenso on Jan 23, 2021 at 5:40:17pm

Message modified by stenso on Jan 23, 2021 at 5:40:56pm

Report problem with this ad

stenso

Bio page: stenso
Joined: Nov 4, 2018
Last login: Apr 26, 2024
Total posts: 7,484 (13 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Remember when BYU football was a shoo-in for a NY6 bowl until the actual

Future_Tacos

1/23/21 5:31pm

We have data on the NCAA tournament committee though

puntersarepeople

1/23/21 5:32pm

And they have actual metrics and criteria that they use to seed teams

Kavorka

1/23/21 5:36pm

A committee works better anyways when the amount of teams is higher

Yiowa

1/23/21 8:36pm

Also a bigger committee and an actual tournament not just a popularity contest

Powerbait DPM

1/23/21 5:40pm

Hoops is what different. Can’t really even compare them.

1/23/21 5:35pm

So BYU deserves a 9 seed right now but will get a 14 or not in at all??

gmoney7

1/23/21 5:35pm

I don’t think we were ever a lock for a NY6. Just hopeful for fairness.

stenso

1/23/21 5:35pm

Had the CFP rankings reflected the AP rankings we would have been.

Kavorka

1/23/21 5:36pm

Absolutely, but many suspected the Committee was gonna Committee.

stenso

1/23/21 5:38pm

But we also had years of evidence that committee weighed SOS more

krindorr

1/23/21 6:51pm

P4?

SaintGeorgeYFan

1/23/21 7:15pm

Big 12, Big Ten, SEC, ACC. These are always the contenders. Am I missing one?

stenso

1/23/21 8:07pm

No, I think you named all of the P4 conferences

hdx57

1/23/21 8:26pm

We couldn’t even beat “Coastal Carolina”. Who cares if we weren’t ranked fairly?

1/23/21 5:38pm

And Iowa State couldn’t even beat *checks notes*

puntersarepeople

1/23/21 5:40pm

Yeah.

Future_Tacos

1/23/21 5:42pm

I like you FT. But those are just LAME excuses. Not good reasons we lost.

1/23/21 5:46pm

I like me okay.

Future_Tacos

1/23/21 5:46pm

RE: We couldn’t even beat “Coastal Carolina”. Who cares if we weren’t ranked fairly?

Pete

1/23/21 5:46pm

And Boise and Houston, both on the road.

SaintGeorgeYFan

1/23/21 7:17pm

Think about what you just said. First off, Houston was terrible. Second, Boise

1/23/21 7:29pm

Basketball has a real system and the elements are consistent and objective.

Mr. Scoobs

1/23/21 5:43pm

^^^this^^^ football committee uses the eye test

palangi

1/23/21 8:33pm

We were never a shoo-in. Irrational exuberance took hold too soon.

Forzaitalia

1/23/21 6:05pm

Football is more of a good ole boys club. BB looks at metrics

Dr T-bone

1/23/21 6:12pm

I hate committees....

Punk Philosopher

1/23/21 6:37pm

RE: Remember when BYU football was a shoo-in for a NY6 bowl until the actual

1/23/21 7:38pm

True.

Future_Tacos

1/23/21 7:42pm

Top 64 vs top 4.

Boring

1/23/21 7:42pm

Exactly. Duke in the first four out? LOL, yeah right

trueblue04

1/23/21 7:50pm

Hoops is a night and day difference than football. Transparency and actual

1/23/21 9:35pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad