Apr 22, 2021
10:50:44am
10:50:44am
1. McMahon - All American, Davey O'Brien, Third in Heisman, tons of NCAA/school Records, yards, wins.
2. Detmer - Heisman! 2x All American, Third place in Heisman, Davey O'Brien 2x, YARDS
3. Bosco - National Championship, Undefeated, Second in Davey O'Brien, Third place in Heisman, Led nation in total offense
4. Young - All American, Finished second in Heisman, Davey O'Brien, Dual Threat ability (1000 career rushing yards)
5. Marc Wilson - Schools first consensus All American, Sammy Baugh Trophy, Undefeated regular season, paved way for future QB's,
After these guys, for me, the debate for Beck, Hall, and Z Wilson all have good arguments. But none of them match the All American Status, Heismans, NC's, Insane Record setting achievements and awards of these top 5. Anyone claiming Z Wilson as the best ever, simply hasn't been a BYU fan for very long. He was great, but understand this: BYU has one of the greatest QB histories in college football, period.
2. Detmer - Heisman! 2x All American, Third place in Heisman, Davey O'Brien 2x, YARDS
3. Bosco - National Championship, Undefeated, Second in Davey O'Brien, Third place in Heisman, Led nation in total offense
4. Young - All American, Finished second in Heisman, Davey O'Brien, Dual Threat ability (1000 career rushing yards)
5. Marc Wilson - Schools first consensus All American, Sammy Baugh Trophy, Undefeated regular season, paved way for future QB's,
After these guys, for me, the debate for Beck, Hall, and Z Wilson all have good arguments. But none of them match the All American Status, Heismans, NC's, Insane Record setting achievements and awards of these top 5. Anyone claiming Z Wilson as the best ever, simply hasn't been a BYU fan for very long. He was great, but understand this: BYU has one of the greatest QB histories in college football, period.
- Previous username
- Klompus
- Bio page
- Moops
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2018
- Last login
- May 3, 2024
- Total posts
- 2,308 (1 FO)
Other Related Threads:
Some BYU QB comparisons of their best seasons to what other NCAA QBs were doing that same year. (SpiffCoug, Apr 21, 2021 at 7:07pm)
The most surprising thing about this picture is that Ty looks like the biggest (Thrill, Apr 21, 2021 at 5:36pm)
BYU's top nine QBs side by side (Ham, Apr 21, 2021 at 5:13pm)
I hate that you're making me write this. (Ham, Apr 21, 2021 at 4:53pm)
Messages
Time
