Maybe he is right... But Ute coaches picked the wrong guy. Part of the game.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 22, 2021
7:21:24am

dave All-American

Maybe he is right... But Ute coaches picked the wrong guy. Part of the game.

Report problem with this ad

dave

Bio page: dave
Joined: Sep 27, 2005
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 8,372 (208 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Dylan Collie was on sports radio and said he thought it would

Jdoc

9/22/21 6:49am

Haha. Maybe, maybe not. How could you even know?

mobomanjoe

9/22/21 6:53am

I agree. I was shocked he said it. So we’re David James and Patrick Kinahan.

Jdoc

9/22/21 6:55am

You’re being trolled.

snowbird

9/22/21 8:22am

Meh. The game was more than QB play.

Benfica1

9/22/21 7:13am

Would Rising have prevented the defensive line from being pushed around?

Mister P

9/22/21 6:56am

He said Utah’s offensive line would have played harder for Rising. Said that

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:03am

I think it is possible to craft an argument that Utah would have won with Rising, but that one ain't it. It is frankly

Clark Addison

9/22/21 7:06am

I did think that the team voting the backup as Captain was telling.

dave

9/22/21 7:06am

If that were even remotely true, then Utah has a wimpier Oline than we thought

runnincoug

9/22/21 8:06am

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

AZPTCOUG

9/22/21 8:31am

Wait...i thought the popular excuse was that Whitt was intentionally throwing...

icecougar

9/22/21 9:07am

That is adorable

HONOMO

9/22/21 10:34am

That does not say good things about the line.

9/22/21 11:32am

I absolutely love that you guys get to stew on the what-ifs for the next 3 yrs.

cosmohio

9/22/21 11:36am

So the players-only meeting on Sunday was (A)hate the QB (B)The coach is wrong

anonymous37

9/22/21 1:31pm

You never make good decisions when you skip church. 🙂

9/22/21 1:52pm

and Jdoc is just like the same donkey cry babies that said they would have beat

byublue42

9/22/21 9:31am

I love it. AWTs are a crucial component of this rivalry.

shoganai

9/22/21 6:56am

Utah found one? This is coming from Dylan Collie, not me. Read my posts.

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:04am

Uh tons of ute fans already have said the same as Dylan

BYU '80

9/22/21 7:06am

And you're lying when you say you don't believe it. You know you do.

shoganai

9/22/21 7:10am

No I don’t. BYU is clearly a better team than Utah this year. They should have

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:11am

RE: No I don’t. BYU is clearly a better team than Utah this year. They

shoganai

9/22/21 7:13am

Thanks.

9/22/21 7:27am

Ute fans have been spouting this on Twitter for days.

zsmooth

9/22/21 7:13am

lol you came here to say it though!! Cry me a river!! 😂😂😂

AZPTCOUG

9/22/21 8:31am

And BYU would have played a different game had Zach Wilson started.

RSL

9/22/21 6:56am

Now the Utes will claim victory in an alternate universe. The "What If" reminds

Cougsanity

9/22/21 6:57am

"The streak ended because Utah forfeited..."

foofcoug

9/22/21 6:59am

Assuming they think like much of our fanbase, yes.

SinkingQuffa

9/22/21 7:00am

This is coming from Dylan Collie. You know, former BYU receiver.

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:05am

He only benefitted from a BYU education for one year

BYU '80

9/22/21 7:06am

He baited Utah fans into repeating it and you fell for it, hook, line, & sinker

rcbyufan

9/22/21 7:11am

Read my posts. I don’t agree with it.

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:11am

LOL. He just needed you to repeat it not believe it. He got you. Ha. Ha. Ha.

rcbyufan

9/22/21 7:13am

boise did as much last year saying if their starting QB was in they would have

brick oven

9/22/21 7:29am

Broken record on backup qbs. SDSU did not expect him to play

BYU '80

9/22/21 6:57am

ASU defense was much better that Utah as well.

whirl

9/22/21 7:49am

Lol you know nothing about Rising. One game tells you nothing.

Roghai

9/22/21 11:02am

I found someone else who agrees with this...

NOCAL_YFAN

9/22/21 7:01am

Good one

jtm0001

9/22/21 10:25am

Brewer was a four year starter at P5 level. But that dude in waiting is better!

txblue

9/22/21 7:02am

If anyone wants to make that claim, they have to allow BYU fans to claim that

LegitCoug

9/22/21 7:02am

Why should they be intellectually honest?

jtm0001

9/22/21 10:27am

Love the Collie family and respectfully it doesn't sound like Dylan watched the

Saxa

9/22/21 7:05am

Do you often sit in the west seats and clamor for whoever is the backup qb?

9/22/21 7:07am

Did you read my post? I don’t agree with Collie?

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:10am

It's a tale as old as time. "____ would have beat them."

9/22/21 7:13am

Yet, here you are effectively promoting it on our board.

NOCAL_YFAN

9/22/21 7:19am

Exactly, trolls gotta troll.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:19am

LOL Gustav called it, and has the receipts.

Abe Froman

9/22/21 7:11am

Uh, this is coming from one of your own.

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:12am

And you couldn't post about it fast enough.

shoganai

9/22/21 7:14am

And keep posting about it, and fully explaining it.

Corn Pop

9/22/21 7:21am

They are called trolls. Dont feed them. They aren’t worth it.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:20am

Corn Pop was a bad dude.

cougfrvr

9/22/21 8:34am

Uh, you’re using it as reinforcement for the point y’all desperately want to be

Abe Froman

9/22/21 8:04am

I mean, it wouldn't matter if it's true or not. The game was played and we lost.

kos

9/22/21 9:15am

<< Deleted >>

Benfica1

9/22/21 7:12am

Easy to say with the win in your back pocket. He was being nice.

panacablue

9/22/21 7:17am

Lol. Whatever it takes to soothe the pain.

rocker

9/22/21 7:18am

Take it up with Dylan Collie.

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:19am

Maybe he is right... But Ute coaches picked the wrong guy. Part of the game.

dave

9/22/21 7:21am

Funny thing is, he’s not the one here posting about it.

Corn Pop

9/22/21 7:22am

No, he just said it on a sports talk radio show with thousands of people

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:24am

And yet he’s not the one here posting about it.

Corn Pop

9/22/21 7:28am

Dozens.

O Gaucho

9/22/21 7:33am

You brought it here. And I think you’re being disingenuous

rocker

9/22/21 7:29am

Trolls, what can you do about it? Not much, just let it burn out.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:21am

I heard the interview. He never said that Utah would’ve won.

CopperLix

9/22/21 7:24am

He insinuated it pretty heavily. Go back and

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:27am

As a point to validate or mock your program, though? Sounded like bait to me.

SinkingQuffa

9/22/21 7:30am

I don't need to "go back". I know what he said.

CopperLix

9/22/21 8:24am

Well here are my insinuations... Yewts still acting as the little brother, BYU

byublue42

9/22/21 9:47am

🤣 heard the interview, he never said Utah would have won

LEHI cougar

9/22/21 7:30am

I never said he said Utah would have won. He insinuated it. DJ and PK were

Jdoc

9/22/21 7:33am

Well if that receiver that played 1 season for BYU said so then that must mean U essentially won…

mulletino

9/22/21 7:50am

"Basically said he thought Utah would have won." - jdoc's exact words. LOL

Megamind

9/22/21 8:14am

The truth comes out. JDOC is a troll confirmed. Trolls tend to twist the truth.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:25am

Yeah I never got the sense the he was insinuating Utah would have won.

machete

9/22/21 7:33am

The truth comes out. JDOC is a troll confirmed. Trolls tend to twist the truth.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:24am

Thanks. This is now priceless. “Different game” vs “We would have won”. LMBO.

rocker

9/22/21 7:32am

NOT TRUE. I listened to that interview and he never said that. U fans will hear

MustacheMan

9/22/21 7:30am

but he "HEAVILY" insinuated it!!!

9/22/21 7:59am

Hahahaha, what a clown response. Poor Ute fans grasping for any explanation. LOL

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:26am

Well, if a former player says so, then I guess we may as well move that win to the loss column.

Spiff

9/22/21 7:30am

Utah would not have won because nothing has changed with the OL. Until that happens, Utah is in trouble with any team

specsauce

9/22/21 7:33am

Dylan joined the 3 Yewts in a basement podcast?

WJCougar

9/22/21 7:35am

OK everyone - it sounds like Dylan said it would have been a diff game, and Jdoc heard “Utes win”. Nothing to see here.

zsmooth

9/22/21 7:43am

This ^^^^. Trolls gonna troll. And this is a classic Ute troll on display.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 8:27am

Oh the sweet toil of the what if game...

whirl

9/22/21 7:48am

And BYU wins every year Utah doesn't play game. . . .

Madam Pattirini

9/22/21 7:52am

We will have to see if they win ASU with Rising.

SJBLUE

9/22/21 7:53am

Posts like this make me want to see Rising get slaughtered next game

Heath Squashwell

9/22/21 7:57am

I almost want to see him do really well. Kyle & staff can't look competent

SinkingQuffa

9/22/21 8:03am

Not following that logic

Heath Squashwell

9/22/21 8:22am

"Really well" overstating it — noticeably better, but still pretty bad.

SinkingQuffa

9/22/21 8:57am

It was radio. You couldn't see him winking at BYU fans.

Megamind

9/22/21 8:00am

Stunning analysis - If Utah had played better football by [insert changes here], it would have been a different game.

kccougar

9/22/21 8:01am

Let me be the first to congratulate you on your moral victory.

DrYfire

9/22/21 8:11am

I think he is right, specially knowing that Zach Wilson it was suppose to be

lalochile

9/22/21 8:19am

I'm so, so happy that it's finally Utah with a QB controversy

reddead

9/22/21 8:26am

He didn’t basically say they would’ve won

9/22/21 8:26am

Yeah, lets see how he does the rest of the way

JOPE

9/22/21 8:27am

Haha, this is rich...nothing more than convenient cover

LateToTheGame

9/22/21 8:29am

We would have won EVERY game if we did it differently. EVERY game.

BYUheaven

9/22/21 8:29am

We have won every game.

Schultz is back

9/22/21 8:31am

Wow, easy with your logic. It's not welcome around the Utes right now.

LateToTheGame

9/22/21 8:33am

Only if Rising also played D Line and added some toughness to that unit.

cougarnw

9/22/21 8:36am

nah, We have been playing that game for the last 11 years

Pangare

9/22/21 8:36am

Far more likely that we'd be on a 2 game win streak if Utah hadn't wimped out...

CougarThug

9/22/21 8:44am

So the guy that was beat out by Brewer was going to somehow do better than Brewer...

Coug

9/22/21 8:48am

There were a lot of what-if for BYU over the 9 game Utah streak.

Blue Ghost

9/22/21 8:54am

Well of course. After all, Cam Rising is the 39th best D1 player in the state.

SinkingQuffa

9/22/21 9:11am

Yeah, and if Baylor Romney started BYU would throw a touchdown on EVERY pass.

inutero

9/22/21 9:15am

Baylor Romney passer rating 158.3 - perfect

9/22/21 9:18am

BYU would have beat Rising this year, and they would have beat him last year.

ochobeeguy

9/22/21 9:27am

Boy being on this side of the rivalry is soooo much better. Forgot what it felt

RalphWiggam

9/22/21 9:45am

Except Rising lost the SDSU game after being tied in overtime. SDSU adjusted.

Bee Chunder

9/22/21 10:08am

Well, he didn't, and they didn't, so who cares?

dccoug

9/22/21 10:27am

Dylan was just making fun of your coaches, if he said that.

JAGA97

9/22/21 10:46am

WRONG: It would have been Rising quitting and Brewer would now be the starter.

zzcoug

9/22/21 10:50am

There are many ifs, ands, or buts related to the past nine games where BYU comes out the winner if something were

SwimmingWithSharks

9/22/21 10:53am

He’s right. CB is on the far end of the BYU bias spectrum, so I’m not surprised

Roghai

9/22/21 11:08am

I think you are missing the point. Dylan never said what JDoc thinks he heard.

NewMexiCoug

9/22/21 11:35am

Either way, it’s true. If BYU tried to defend Utah with Rising the same way they

Roghai

9/22/21 11:49am

That is the kind of rationale that the loser comes up with. How many other

NewMexiCoug

9/22/21 11:58am

So you are basically saying if Rising was the starter instead of Brewer, BYU

byublue42

9/22/21 12:01pm

He is also admitting that Ute coaches are horrible judges of QB talent

NewMexiCoug

9/22/21 12:06pm

Well they’ve still won 9 out of 10, so I can’t be too critical. The game isn’t

Roghai

9/22/21 12:12pm

Are you sure you are not a BYU fan posing as a Ute fan?

NewMexiCoug

9/22/21 12:14pm

DING DING DING DING, but I think you got it backwards

byublue42

9/22/21 12:18pm

You don’t think conference games are more consequential for Utah? 😂🤣

Roghai

9/22/21 12:40pm

For their moods? No.

zsmooth

9/22/21 12:41pm

Lol BYU has been independent too long apparently

Roghai

9/22/21 1:16pm

Well this right here proves you are a Yewt, this is pulled straight from the

byublue42

9/22/21 2:55pm

I’m doubtful because Rising is a much better fit for Utah, and BYU had no film

Roghai

9/22/21 12:09pm

Hahahahahahaha!!!!! Keep dreaming!!!!!

MustacheMan

9/22/21 12:14pm

It wouldn’t have taken much for things to swing the other way, but okay lol

Roghai

9/22/21 12:47pm

RE: It wouldn’t have taken much for things to swing the other way, but

The_Cuss

9/22/21 12:53pm

Keep the "what ifs" coming! Delicious

machete

9/22/21 12:57pm

BYU fans are the kings of what ifs, so it’s only fair that we can do it right

Roghai

9/22/21 1:19pm

"Don't be a hypocrite" lolololololol

machete

9/22/21 1:35pm

Yep, you’re mocking using what ifs when that’s all you’ve done for the last

Roghai

9/22/21 1:50pm

So which is the correct position to take - play the what-if game or accept the results on the field?

kccougar

9/22/21 1:57pm

Right? This guy does not get it.

machete

9/22/21 2:24pm

You tell me haha. Results are obviously what matter, but there can be legitimate

Roghai

9/22/21 3:02pm

Valid when its in your favor, not valid when it isn't. Got it, no contradiction.

The_Cuss

9/22/21 3:10pm

And here you are using what ifs when you've mocked using them the past decade

machete

9/22/21 2:28pm

Yes, except what you forget is Rizing actually gets hurt third play in. so....

9/22/21 1:54pm

For Utah's sake you better hope that one difference would be the ability to make

Agaricus

9/22/21 12:13pm

Isn't that the same thing as saying the coaches suck?

protonspring

9/23/21 9:48am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad